The Arthur Pincus Blog
  • 03:13 PM ET  11.20
Views
925
Comments
12

CUBS LAW: If any single MLB team makes a really bad decision, it's sure to be the Cubs. If several teams make really bad decisions, the worst one is going to be made by the Cubs. (Law first proposed  by baseball fans on Cubs acquisition of sore-backed Ralph Kiner in 1953; defined  in 1960 with the Cubs College of Coaches; confirmed by trade of Lou Brock for Ernie Broglio in 1964; proven innumerable times since.)

Like Doc Daneeka said about Catch-22, Cubs Law, it's the best there is.

This off-season continues to amaze for what roads the Cubbies are traveling. For a team that lost 96 games last season and finished with the worst record in the National League it would seem you'd have to do better in the coming season. You'd have to think that finally they'd take the right road. But now that's not so certain. Oh, for sure the Cubs will hit a lot more with Alfonso Soriano about to join the Cubs for $136 million for eight years (it's shocking just to write that) along with the staying-home Aramis Ramirez and the hopefully recuperated Derrek Lee. And with those three and Mark DeRosa, Michael Barrett Cesar Izturis and Henry Blanco, they'll cost a lot more; but with a pitching staff that has Carlos Zambrano as a definite starter and lots of not yets and many injured maybes led by Mark Prior and Kerry Wood, there may be little chance that they'll win much  more.

GM Jim Hendry, by signing the offensively gifted, defensively challenged, attitudinally uncertain Soriano, is heading for the salary stratosphere with no pitching to speak of. And to nurse this group along, and wait patiently for the return to health of Wood and Prior and the meshing of Ramirez, Soriano and Lee, is the calm, re-assuring presence of new manager Sweet Lou Piniella.  

You wonder sometimes what game all those GMs and other bright bulbs in Major League Baseball are watching but I don't think it's the same one I'm paying attention to. In my game, pitching wins; good pitching stops good hitting; and great pitching (or hot pitching but pitching) wins the World Series. The Cubs have not played in the World Series in 61 years and they have not won one in 98, so they may not know what it takes to win a pennant or a World Series, being so far removed from those accomplishments.

No one can doubt the innate talent of Wood or Prior. But The New York Times pointed out over the weekend that Wood has been on the DL 10 times in his 8 seasons--27 percent of his active duty. And last season was lost almost entirely with 4 starts and 162 days (out of 182) on the DL. Prior's career numbers are even worse--30 percent of his days have been on the DL, 8 times total in 5 seasons and 144 of 182 days last season. These are two of the pitchers the Cubs apparently are counting on. How about you Cubs fans? Are you counting on them?

Since hiring Piniella as manager, the Cubs have re-signed Ramirez, the third baseman, to a $75-million, five-year deal; added free agent second baseman  DeRosa ($13 million over three years), acquired left-hander Neal Cotts from the White Sox and re-signed Kerry Wood ($1.75 million with a potential of $6 million) and Wade Miller ($1.5 million for a pitcher who appeared in 5 games last season and has been plagued with injuries the last three years), and backup catcher Blanco ($5.25 million over two years).

The Cubs moves, questionable as they all seem at first, are made even more curiouser by the uncertainty of the ownership, The Tribune Company. The media giant, struggling in so many areas, is reported to be shopping the Cubs after 25 years of ineffectual and ineffective ownership. So naturally, the team has gone out and burdened potential new owners with a bunch of over-priced contracts. Great business. But, hey, it's the Cubs after all.

November 20, 2006  05:37 PM ET

Well either their building a team that will contend for the next couple years, or one that will burden them for the next couple years. Either way they've committed a hell of a lot of money on a gamble.

By the way, "more curiouser"? ummm... ok.

November 20, 2006  11:23 PM ET

"Curiouser and curiouser" cried Alice as she went down the rabbit hole. Kind of like being a Cubs fan and more.

November 21, 2006  01:54 PM ET

Basically Jim Hendry is trying to deflect the blame for losing onto others. He has assembled a collection of high played players that should serve as a solid offensive core. That said, Arams is awful in the field, and while I don't think Soriano was that bad in LF, I don't know if he will be any good in CF. As Pincus pointed out, the need is still pitching. For years I have harrassed my Cubs fan friends about their faith in unproven and oft-injured starters. Last year I said they should've gone after someone like Jeff Weaver ONLY because he will give you 200+ innings. Investing in Prior, Wood, and Miller is plain stupid. You would think they would learn. Alas, Hendry is a moron. The Cubs look a lot like the Sox did in the late 90's: big power, no pitching or defense.

November 21, 2006  03:02 PM ET

What happened to Juan Pierre in CF? He lead the team in OBP, steals and runs scored. Why not keep Soriano in RF, Pierre in CF and move Jones to LF. At least that way you had a legit CF covering for Jones and Soriano.

November 21, 2006  03:07 PM ET

I don't know; when Juan Pierre was with the Marlins in 2003, he just completely wore out the Yankees in the World Series. Almost dominated as I recall, getting on base, stealing doing all the stuff that a leadoff guy should do.
But Krish, your question, I think is answered by two words; Cubs Law.

November 22, 2006  12:05 PM ET

Pierre had a lot of hits this year, but they seemed very untimely. At least that's what I heard from Cubs fans. When DLee was out the offense relied on Pierre and Aramis, neither of whom did anything at that time. Not necessarily logic based reasoning here, but I wouldn't be surprised if Soriano is out in CF next year, which would mean that Pierre was expendable.

November 22, 2006  12:24 PM ET

Pierre is a Dodger. Soriano is not a centerfielder, Jaque Jones is an abortion in the field, Aramis' fielding can be summed up in the play against the Braves midway through the season (in the 15th inning) when a routine pop-up hit him on the head. Prior will spend the year on the DL, Wood will spend half the year on the DL, Zambrano will pitch brilliant with moments of complete futility, and another season will pass without the Cubs addressing the real issue, Jim Hendry and Tribune ownership.

November 22, 2006  12:53 PM ET

Cubs Law.

November 23, 2006  08:41 AM ET

If the Cubs get Zito or Schmidt I think they make a playoff run. Outfield defense is overratted....look how far the Mets got last year, almost to the World Series....

November 23, 2006  03:24 PM ET

Don't agree Krish, you Cubs fan you; do you remember Endy Chavez's catch in the playoffs? Mets outfield defense had Carlos Beltran and Chavez. And it cost them big time because Shawn Green is terrible in right. But if you want to wish Soriano to be a good center fielder, go right ahead.

December 6, 2006  10:42 PM ET

Just hat to h/t the Catch-22 reference.

-- Milo Minderbinder

 
December 6, 2006  11:28 PM ET

Thanks Milo. Can you get us some parachute silk?

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


Coming soon: Log in with your Facebook account, send comments and Throwdowns to Facebook and more.

Start Your Own Blog

Start Now

The Si.com Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Stub Hub

The 2009 schedule has been released. Search for tickets!

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Chargers accuse McDaniels of trash talk
    Views
    20644
    Comments
    2805
  2. 2
    Source: Damon won't take pay cut
    Views
    48385
    Comments
    968
  3. 3
    Should Notre Dame join Big Ten?
    Views
    19564
    Comments
    233
  4. 4
    Weis won't resign
    Views
    41102
    Comments
    221
  5. 5
    Beckham won't own Montreal team
    Views
    1104
    Comments
    181

Message Boards

  1. MMA > General MMA

    Arlovski's next fight -…
    Views
    309
    Replies
    7
  2. NCAAF > Ohio State Buckeyes

    Season Analysis
    Views
    211
    Replies
    31
  3. NFL > Chicago Bears

    Jay Cutler Must GO!!!!
    Views
    182
    Replies
    25

Blogs

SI.com

Swimsuit

SI Photos