• 11:11 AM ET  05.22
Views
84297
Comments
64
 

Odds are that the Portland Trailblazers, winners of this year's draft lottery, will use the top pick to take Ohio State big man Greg Oden. How have past No. 1 picks worked out since the league instituted the lottery in 1985? Here's one interested observer's ranking. What do you think?

1. Shaquille O'Neal, 1992: Four rings, countless careers made, Hall of Fame plaques buffed for Phil Jackson and -- soon -- Pat Riley.  From the time he entered the league until this season, all but five NBA titles have been won by Shaq or the team that eliminated Shaq.

2. Tim Duncan, 1997: Three titles and a fourth likely on the way.

3. LeBron James, 2003: He's scored more than 8,000 points, handed out more than 2,000 assists and grabbed more than 2,000 rebounds, all before the age of 23.

4. Allen Iverson 1996: He may never win a title, but the player with the third-highest career scoring average in NBA history was instrumental in helping the NBA make the transition from old school to new school, with all its pluses and minuses.

5. Patrick Ewing, 1985: Never won the title he famously promised year after year, but he made the Knicks relevant again and a title contender while also helping generate some of the most memorable rivalries in league history.

6. David Robinson, 1987: OK, he needed Duncan to come along before he could finally win a ring, but the onetime MVP averaged 21 points, 10.6 rebounds and blocked more than 2 shots a game in the course of a 14-year career.

7. Chris Webber, 1993: Yes, he's been moody. Yes, he hasn't  been great in the clutch. But he may be the best passing big man of his generation, which went a long way toward transforming the Kings from NBA backwater to title contender.

8. Dwight Howard, 2004: After shooting better than 60 percent, scoring almost 18 points a night and grabbing more than 12 boards a game for the second consecutive season, the 22-year-old Howard is only giving a glimpse of the NBA's next dominant big man.

9. Elton Brand, 1999: How a guy who averages better than 20 points, 10 rebounds and 2 blocks per game can play in only one All-Star Game is a mystery. Maybe it has something to do with the fact that he's only led a team to the playoffs once in his career.

10. Yao Ming, 2002: After enduring seemingly endless Chinese national team duty for the first few years of his career, Yao has only recently demonstrated the kind of dominant play the Rockets envisioned when they drafted him.

11. Brad Daugherty, 1986: His eight years of service and relatively unathletic frame belied one of the league's most underrated centers, one who averaged 19 points and almost 10 rebounds a night.

12. Derrick Coleman, 1990: Did you know that DC averaged more than 16 points, 9 rebounds, almost 3 assists and 1.3 blocks per game for his career? Think about how much better those stats could have been if Coleman actually cared about playing.

13. Larry Johnson, 1991: Though a back injury robbed LJ of what he could have been, Johnson quietly transformed himself from low-post pillar to perimeter threat in his later years, extending his useful life as a player despite the fact the he could barely jump.

14. Andrea Bargnani, 2006: As last year's draft prize demonstrated in the playoffs, he already has the perimeter game under control. With a summer of workouts and more playing time, you'll see he has plenty of inside game, too.

15. Kenyon Martin, 2000: After his second microfracture knee surgery, his career is in serious doubt, but when he was healthy, his defense, low-post scoring and rebounding were key to sending the Nets to two straight NBA Finals.

16. Andrew Bogut, 2005: Handed the starting center job in his second season, Bogut didn't disappoint, but he didn't impress. And if a club is going to select you over Deron Williams or Chris Paul, you have to impress.

17. Glenn Robinson, 1994: The Big Dog may have dogged it on defense, but the former Boilermaker brought the goods on the offensive end, averaging among the more empty 20.7 points per game you'd likely see.

18. Joe Smith, 1995: Has he been the superstar most expect a No. 1 to be? No. But he's been a quietly productive power forward for 12 years, which is a lot more than you can say about the fellows who follow on this list.

19. Danny Manning, 1988: It wasn't as if Manning couldn't play -- he averaged almost 21 points, 8 rebounds and 1.2 blocks per 40 minutes of play; it's that he also averaged only 58 games a year.

20. Pervis Ellison, 1989: There's a reason that in 11 seasons, Never Nervous Pervis played for four teams, only one of which reached the playoffs.

21. Michael Olowokandi, 1998: When you're 7-feet, shouldn't you get more than 6.8 rebounds a game? When you're 7-feet, shouldn't you average more than 9.8 points a game more than twice in a career? When you are this big a bust, should you be allowed to make more than $37 million. Life isn't fair.

22. Kwame Brown, 2001: How many supposed franchise players do you know who make more headlines for allegedly throwing a birthday cake at a man on the street in the wee hours than for anything he's done on the court in six seasons?

 

May 22, 2007  11:40 AM ET

I think Olowokandi should be the lowest on this list. I think you were a little generous with Derrick Coleman as well.

May 22, 2007  11:43 AM ET

Nicely written, but I don't think you can discount someone for having only been in the league one year. Bargnani, for what he's shown so far, deserves to be above at least Daugherty, Johnson, and Coleman.

May 22, 2007  12:26 PM ET

Agreed, maybe guys up one or down one but pretty on target

May 22, 2007  12:39 PM ET

Yao Ming is better than Elton Brand and Dwight Howard. He should be higher up on the list. There is no way that David Robinson should be lower on the list than Patrick Ewing. Are you kidding me? I detect East Coast bias at play.

May 22, 2007  12:58 PM ET

Ewing over Robinson? Not a chance. The Admiral was a better player in almost every facet of the game.

May 22, 2007  01:30 PM ET

I think if you've never won a championship or at least PLAYED FOR ONE you can't be considered the best of anything. I'm so amazed by all the laurels layed upon LeBron James....how about this kid play dominant/championship level basketball for a few years before we actually crown this media creation.

May 22, 2007  01:34 PM ET

What about Hakeem "The Dream"

May 22, 2007  01:36 PM ET

Do you mean "AKEEM" as in "OLAJUWON"?? Was he a #1 Overall selection? Hmmm?

May 22, 2007  01:46 PM ET

Hakeem should be 2nd on that list, He won 2 titles and a mvp and is a top 4 center of all time. Hakeem was better then Duncan in his prime and was Shaqs equal, especially after he swept shaq in the nba Finals in 1995

May 22, 2007  01:46 PM ET

Hakeem was the number 1 pick in 1984 (before Sam Bowie and Michael Jordan). This list is a joke without him. He should be at least number 3 on this list. For God's sake, the man won 2 NBA championships, destroying David Robinson in his MVP year and Patrick Ewing.

May 22, 2007  01:47 PM ET

I would put David Robinson at #4. The man had 71 points in a game, one of only four players to record a quadtruple double, win a scoring title, win Defensive Player of the year, MVP, Rebounding leader, Shot Blocks leader, and many more various awards. But most of all, he took Duncan under his wing and showed him the ropes.

May 22, 2007  01:48 PM ET

I watched the Glenn Robinson years in Milwaukee and I'm sorry he never got the credit he deserved. 17 come on!! He is the second leading scorcer in Bucks history, always was getting double teamed, and had one of the sweetest 18 foot jumpers in the game. I think why he isn't higher on the list is because he preferred to keep as low a profile as possible. Also Bogut sucks (ask any Bucks fan), DC never played hard, Larry Johnson was always hurt same with Martin and Glenn would have killed Andrea Bargnani....Robinson averaged 22 ppg his rookie year. How many rookies do that? holy crap this list sucks

May 22, 2007  01:50 PM ET

What about Magic?

May 22, 2007  01:56 PM ET

Good to see Brad Daugherty on the list as high as he is. Its ashame he had all those back problems that cut his career short, cause if he was healthy, there is no doubt he is a hall of famer. He kept up with the likes of Robinson and Ewing. Olajuwon definitely should have been in the top five. One of the greatest centers ever to play.

May 22, 2007  01:57 PM ET

Hakeem Olajuwon would be very high on that list, but for the fact that this list is about draft LOTTERY picks. The operative word being LOTTERY. Hakeem was drafted before the lottery system began. So was Magic.

May 22, 2007  01:57 PM ET

Wait, we're forgetting that this list is since the lottery was established, which iI don't think was until '85. Are we all dumbasses, or can we just not read well?

May 22, 2007  02:03 PM ET

hakeem wasn't in the lottery. for all time, NO ONE could go against kareem abdul jabbar. he led the milwaukee bucks in their SECOND YEAR of existance into the championship. i heard he did something with the LA Lakers also.

sychar

May 22, 2007  02:08 PM ET

yes, i believe there are players drafted after number 1 that was better. aka MJ. lew alcinder/kareem rocked as far as number 1 pick.. by the way, kwame brown screams as the poster boy for the new one year of college rule.

May 22, 2007  02:26 PM ET

You are also mentioning the biggest pre-lottery bust: Larue Martin, a center taken by the just-off-expansion Portland Trailblazers in 1972. I never got to see him actually play, which was a merciful thing. Pretty nice guy, by all reports, but couldn't play a lick.

Of course back then, NBA players didn't make millions of dollars just for signing a contract, and nobody got endorsement money.

 
May 22, 2007  02:29 PM ET

MJ wasn't a No. 1 pick. Also the lottery was instituted after Hakeem's year. Ewing was the first No. 1 in the lottery era (and generated the conspiracy theory).

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


Coming soon: Log in with your Facebook account, send comments and Throwdowns to Facebook and more.

Start Your Own Blog

Start Now

The Si.com Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Stub Hub

The 2009 schedule has been released. Search for tickets!

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Cowher to Bears or Texans?
    Views
    70311
    Comments
    3106
  2. 2
    Yankees to cut down on spending
    Views
    10317
    Comments
    1163
  3. 3
    Red Sox-Jays deal-killer?
    Views
    16037
    Comments
    895
  4. 4
    Disrespected Ryan takes dig at Moss
    Views
    11732
    Comments
    723
  5. 5
    Martz to jump-start Bears offense?
    Views
    7728
    Comments
    443

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
    Chico 2.0
  2. 2
    BBK - Now it's all football
  3. 3
    rstowe
  4. 4
    gigi_iv
  5. 5
    Never NDing Struggle

Message Boards

  1. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    Longhorns vs. Aggies…
    Views
    433
    Replies
    72
  2. NFL > General NFL

    New England-New Orleans
    Views
    168
    Replies
    30
  3. NFL > General NFL

    Teams nooooooobody wants to…
    Views
    130
    Replies
    22

Blogs

SI.com

Swimsuit

SI Photos