In response to Perloff's article, here's mine (feel free to challenge me to a throwdown).
1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady
3. Drew Brees
4. Carson Palmer
5. Matt Hasselbeck
6. Donavann McNabb
7. Marc Bulger
8. Phillip Rivers
9. Tony Romo
10. Vince Young
11. Matt Leinart
12. Ben Roethlisberger
13. Jeff Garcia
14. Michael Vick
15. Jake Delhomme
16. Damon Huard
17. Brett Favre
18. Alex Smith
19. Jay Cutler
20. Steve McNair
21. Eli Manning
22. Chad Pennington
23. Jason Campbell
24. Matt Schuab
25. Jon Kitna
26. Trent Green
27. J.P. Losman
28. Rex Grossman
29. Travaris Jackson
30. Charlie Frye
31. Byron Leftwich
32. Josh McCown
Jullie Henderson
Oluchi Onweagba
How the Oklahoma Sooners got here
Pop Culture Hot List
Comments (7) Add A Comment
Much better the Perloffs list, maybe move a couple guys up a couple or down a couple but pretty much on target
dcalamari
New York , NY
Total Comments (641)
Jake Delhomme,Jeff Garcia, and Damon Huard better than Alex Smith? They didn't even play as much as Smith. Smith started all his games last year and is poised for a breakout season in his third year with the Niners. Delhomme, Garcia, and Huard are all way over there 30's while Smith is only 22. Other than that, your list is pretty much on target.
J-Mack(sssc)
Sacramento , CA
Total Comments (53)
Why is Drew Brees no. 3 and Brett Farve No. 17? thats crazy talk
Downey
Seymour , IN
Total Comments (54)
I'll tell you why Brees is 3 and Favre is 17. Brees went 10-6 while playing very well, and Favre went 8-8 and played VERY bad. You do the math.
Colts fan
Total Comments (48)
Also Brees went to the NFC championship game.
Colts fan
Total Comments (48)
Colts fan, I agree with your quarterback rankings, except Jeff Garcia is a little too high, Michael Vick is a little too high and Chad Pennington should be much higher. I would keep Tom Brady and Peyton Manning as 1A and 1B(you pick the order) and I think that Matt Hassleback is one of the more overrated quarterbacks in the NFL, but I agree with them for the most part.
Bah Humbug
Raleigh , NC
Total Comments (853)
favre should be top 15.
Otherwise, pretty decent list.
Lana
Total Comments (2219)
Comment
Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.