Great players. They have come from different times, different cultures. Great players are hard to come by. The greatest baseball players of all time are on this team, the All-Time Baseball Team.
C- Yogi Berra, New York Yankees. Arguably the greatest of all-time. Yogi was a beast during his years in the majors. A fifteen-time All-Star, Yogi once led the high-powered Yankees in RBI in seven straight seasons. He won 3 MVP awards on a team with legends Joe DiMaggio and Mickey Mantle. The greatest catcher of all-time. Period.
1B- Lou Gehrig, New York Yankees. This was an easy choice. When you think Yankees, you might not think of Gehrig right away, but if you lived during his time you would. The Iron Horse was a six-time All-Star and set the record for consecutive games played. He won 2 MVPs and won the Triple Crown in 1934. He set so many unbelieveable feats, he is the greatest one right here.
2B- Rogers Hornsby, St. Louis Cardinals, St. Louis Browns, New York Giants, Boston Braves, Chicago Cubs. He was a hitting monster. This man led the National League in average, on-base percentage and slugging percentage for 6 consecutive seasons. He's second in career batting average all-time. What's more, he won two Triple Crowns. Definitely the greatest second baseman of all-time, could make a case for greatest contact hitter.
3B- Mike Schmidt, Philadelphia Phillies. The greatest hitter at 3B of all time and one of the best fielders. His 536 career homers are the most among third basemen. He won ten Gold Gloves, which proves that he is one of the best all-around players. Schmidt won 8 NL home run titles. That shows Schmidt is the greatest at the hot corner.
SS- Honus Wagner, Louisville Colonels, Pittsburgh Pirates. This is an obvious choice. He hit over .300 in 17 straight seasons. That's something. In eight of those seasons he won the NL batting title. His career average of .329 will stand as one of the best. Wagner was versatile, playing every position except catcher. He's one of the greatest players in history, and greatest shortstop, no doubt.
OF- Ty Cobb, Detriot Tigers greatest hitter of all-time. There is proof. He has the highest career batting average, and won the batting title a record 11 times. Cobb won the Triple Crown in 1909 and hit 9 home runs that year, and, unbelievably, all were inside-the-park. He was amazing, unstoppable.
Babe Ruth, Boston Red Sox, New York Yankees Many consider him to be the greatest baseball player of all-time. He hit 714 home runs, a record that stood until Henry Aaron hit his 715th. I really don't have to say anymore about him. He was a leader and a hero.
Willie Mays, New York/San Francisco Giants, New York Mets. The Say Hey Kid is fourth in career homers with 660. He also tied a record when he appeared in his 24th All-Star game. He won an amazing 12 Gold Gloves, and was part of the first all-black outfield in baseball. Now that's something. Actually, it's all something.
P- Walter Johnson, Washington Nationals/Senators. He was definitely the most dominant, the best. A total of 3,509 career strikeouts has him ninth on the all-time list. He had 12 20-win seasons, and 2 30-win seasons. His 417 wins rank second all-time. 3 time he won the Triple crown for pitchers, and he won AL MVP twice. He is definitely the greatest pitcher of all-time, and now, I have finished my work here. I'd appreciate any feedback.


Cheney Larschied
Anne V



Comments (11) Add A Comment
Great team. You should add an entire team, with a bench and rotation and bullpen. But great choices already.
DJTG_2010
Total Comments (5120)
Thats a good idea but i was just doing the best team for one game, you know?
jeterfan
Poopy, NJ
Total Comments (80)
i'd take Bench over Berra.
thejetstolehome:…
Cos Cob/Storrs, CT
Total Comments (2915)
No, I think Berra's good there.
erwin: Bye, ****.
The Big House, MI
Total Comments (2172)
Pretty good. I moght have taken Bench,too.
And Maybe Cy Young as the best pitcher.
Coletrain
Total Comments (10830)
I think Jimmie Foxx over Lou at first, but that's a hard call to make. I'm pretty pleased with the rest of the team.
Andrew_J
Lincoln , NE
Total Comments (126)
Christy Mathewson.
G.O.A.T. is back?
Scranton, PA
Total Comments (12359)
Christy Mathewson.
THE MVP |
hell yes.
thejetstolehome:…
Cos Cob/Storrs, CT
Total Comments (2915)
nice choices
zesty nachos!
Pittsburgh , PA
Total Comments (58)
My all-time team has always looked like yours with the exception of Josh Gibson as cather rather than Yogi. Gibson was reportedly not a great defensive catcher, but IMHO, by far the greatest offensive catcher. According to the Baseball Hall of Fame, he batted .426 in recorded at bats against Major League Pitching. While he may not have hit "close to 800" home runs, he did have a HR/AB ratio in the league of Ruth, McGwire and Bonds. And the home runs he did hit went a long way. A lot of 500ft.+ shots and possibly the only shot out of Yankee Stadium according to Giants infielder Jack Marshall. Alas, much of this is unverifiable nowadays. When I put Gibson on my all-time teams, the mystique is certainly attractive.
In a few years time, once Alex Rodriguez has played more third base, I believe he will surpass Schmidt at third.
Also, I honestly believe Rickey Henderson should be considered in left field. He was clearly the best lead-off hitter in baseball history with all-time records in walks(broken by Bonds), runs, and stolen bases. Though, a person cannot go wrong with Cobb, or Williams.
At pitcher, if you wanted to win a single game, as you said, then there are a lot of options. Does a person consider a player who had a few unhittable years, like Koufax, Gooden, Martinez? W. Johnson is always in my starting 5, so I can't complain.
I'd say your team is as good as it can get. Growing up playing Baseball Stars on the NES, my team was exactly the same as the one you have listed.
cclause
Saint Paul , MN
Total Comments (1)
i might even take Babe Ruth at starting pitcher.
RHATER is Gone.
Total Comments (3468)
Comment
Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.