FanNation

No way should Kirk Gibson be ahead of Ryne Sandberg for #23. Gibson was never even an all-star. And putting K-Rod ahead of Johan Santana (CYA winner) at #57 is almost as bad.

playa_hayta | 05/05/08, 11:56 AM

Tom Glavine should be the guy for #47. 300 wins. Two Cy Youngs and 95 World Series MVP. Fourth-winningest lefty of all time.

mark lyle | 05/05/08, 01:11 PM

K-Rod over Santana? That is just wrong. Santana may end up as a Top 10 all time pitcher...K-Rod, great closer, but will not be making that list any time soon.

silentsportsguru | 05/05/08, 01:50 PM

K-Rod over Santana is a mistake. As is Scott Shields over Joba Chamberlain (not even mentioned).

Sciorsci | 05/05/08, 03:15 PM

Ryne Sandberg is a Hall of Famer. Kirk Gibson is not.

adrenalynn | 05/05/08, 04:13 PM

K-Rod couldn't even carry Johan Santana's shoes.

dennisreep | 05/05/08, 05:27 PM

Ridiculous that you'd put Derek Jeter in front of Jimmie Foxx.

thehemogoblin: Hemo Hate Me | 05/05/08, 05:35 PM

You should have #84 in there for JT Snow... wearing it in honour of his father, Jack Snow (WR)

redwing19 | 05/05/08, 07:07 PM

nomar, worthy of consideration? not even close

finchman44 | 05/05/08, 09:22 PM

I'm a Yankee fan, and I still find this outrageous. Derek Jeter over Jimmie Foxx? Let me put something into perspective... Jimmine Foxx, 534 HR, 1922 RBI, 1571 runs, .325 AVG .428 OBP .609 SLG. Derek Jeter, 195 HR, 949 RBI, 1394 runs, .317 AVG, .388 OBP, .461 SLG. It's amazing what 4 world series wins gets ya. Did I mention that Foxx won the MVP award 3 times, to Jeter's 0. Jeter's carear isn't done, but the only number here that he has a chance in passing is runs, and his average will probably only go down as he declines.

Ryujin Jakka | 05/05/08, 10:08 PM

YOGI YOGI YOGI!!!
Ripken? okay but not ahead of yogi

mcelt91 | 05/05/08, 10:26 PM

Character counts. Banks over Rose any day.

drabguy | 05/06/08, 12:19 AM

Mariano Rivera is a better #42 than Jackie. Robinson was a great player but Rivera is the greatest reliever/closer ever.

mlbguy08 | 05/06/08, 12:31 AM

Mariano Rivera is a better #42 than Jackie. Robinson was a great player but Rivera is the greatest reliever/closer ever.

mlbguy08 | 05/06/08, 12:32 AM

The #1 goes to Ozzie Smith, Oh played in Japan with a very limited no. of teams, even more limited talented pitching. You put him in the MLB and his no.'s fall fast. Ryan Sandberg over Kirk Gibson any day.

STL#6 | 05/06/08, 01:44 AM

Juan Encarnacion (43) is 'worthy' of consideration but not Jimmy Edmonds (15) or Scott Rolen (27)? I mean, COME ON. They have FIFTEEN Golden Gloves between them. Juan was lucky if he could use his.

unohav_1 | 05/06/08, 02:48 AM

Gibson over Sandberg for #23 is absurd, ridiculous, and wrong. Sandberg is a hall-of-famer, and Gibson didn't even get enough votes to stay on the ballot after the very FIRST ONE!!!

jbau | 05/06/08, 03:43 AM

8=Cal
33= Eddie
NO MORE QUESTIONS!!!

riggo44diesel2000 | 05/06/08, 08:13 AM

Jeter over Jimmie Foxx? Chipper Jones has almost surpassed all of Andre Dawson's records already and he is still playing for #10. One of the greatest switch hitters of all time, and still has lots of years ahead of him. Tom Glavine should be the #47 as well.

Dashlok | 05/06/08, 09:53 AM

ttttttt

Tommie E | 05/06/08, 10:14 AM