FanNation Goes Out To The Movies

As SI.com commemorates the 20th anniversary of Bull Durham, we've spent the week tossing around our favorite sports movies. Coming up with a list of your top five is harder than it seems: I still can't believe classics like The Hustler, The Bad News Bears, Caddyshack and The Karate Kid didn't make mine. (Not to mention Point Break.) As a rule, we opted to leave out documentaries, which precludes masterclass works like the heart-rending Hoop Dreams, the soul-stirring When We Were Kings, and the experimentally poetic Zidane: A 21st Century Portrait.

After much deliberation, here's my short list:

* Breaking Away: This criminally underappreciated coming-of-age flick tracks four friends from a state college town searching for a sense of purpose at the tail-end of adolescence. An opportunity for validation comes with the Indiana University Little 500 bike race, when the townies decide to take on the frat boys at their own game. Dennis Quaid and Daniel Stern turn in strong performances. But veteran actor Paul Dooley -- Cheryl's dad from Curb Your Enthusiasm -- steals the movie as the earthy, old-school father befuddled by his son's whimsical obsession with Italian culture.

* Hoosiers: Thoroughly human performances from Gene Hackman and Dennis Hopper elevate this no-frills genre film to all-time classic. But I've always thought Hoosiers didn't get enough credit for its meticulous production design, as a beautifully executed period piece recreating Midwest America circa 1951. Hackman's hardscrabble Norman Dale imparts lessons on teamwork which transcend the hardwood: Five players on the floor functioning as one single unit. Team, team, team: no one more important that the other.

* Raging Bull: Martin Scorsese's character study tracking the rise and decline of former middleweight champion Jake LaMotta remains a savagely beautiful work. Robert DeNiro, who famously gained 60 pounds mid-shoot to portray the bloated LaMotta later in life, has never turned in a better performance. Raging Bull was edged by Ordinary People for the Best Picture Oscar in 1980 but is frequently listed as the best American film of the eighties.

* Chariots of Fire: No film has captured the complex and multi-faceted nature of the Olympic spirit more effectively. This true story tracks two British athletes with vastly different backgrounds and motivations as they train for the 1924 Summer Olympics: Harold Abrahams, who is Jewish, is driven by anti-Semitism and class prejudice; Eric Liddell, the son of Scottish missionaries, uses his talent to showcase God's glory. Reckoning comes at the Paris Games, where the teammates and rivals achieve success on their own terms.

* Rocky: Frequently dismissed as sentimental and kitschy, Rocky works simultaneously as undemanding popcorn movie and Whitmanian ode to the individual. It's a genre movie, but its expressions are rendered with arthouse complexity. First-time screenwriter Sylvester Stallone wisely played aging palooka Rocky Balboa with a sensitivity missing from other gritty '70s antiheros like Popeye Doyle and Travis Bickle, and the choice paid off in one of the cinema's most memorable characters. But it's the little brushstrokes of brilliance which make Rocky one of the all-time great movies: from the emotional honesty of Rocky practicing jokes in the mirror to the way the snap of Creed's ribs in the climactic 14th round which takes us back to the cold meat locker -- where Rocky honed his left-handed missiles on sides of beef.

Agree? Disagree? Chime in with your picks for the best sports movies of all-time in the comments.

Can't argue with Raging Bull and Hoosiers.

Report Offensive Comment

Where would movies like Coach Carter and White Men Can't Jump rank on yours, Bryan?

Report Offensive Comment

Sorry, movies about running and biking just don't make it into my top 5:

Pride of the Yankees
Rocky
Hoosiers
Raging Bull
too close too call: bull durham/caddyshack/field of dreams

Report Offensive Comment

Although Chariots and Breaking would make the top 10....15 at the worst.

Report Offensive Comment

Major League, baby!

Report Offensive Comment

Excellent list. It would be tough to knock one of those off and replace it with generally accepted "fan favorites". I like them all and wouldn't change any of them. They may not be my top 5 but that is a heck of a list nonetheless.

Report Offensive Comment

G.O.A.T.: White Men Can't Jump probably wouldn't crack my top dozen, but it's a better movie than people tend to remember. Interesting side note: Ron Shelton has written and directed no less than *five* sports films during his career: White Men Can Jump was the second and Bull Durham was the first.

SI.com's Richard Deitsch did a Q&A with Shelton for our BD package. You sports cinephiles should make sure to check it out: www.si.com/2008/writers/richard_deitsch/06/01/shelton.qa/index.html

Coach Carter wasn't anything special: your standard par-for-the-course sports movie. I did appreciate its positive message but thought it was a little too preachy for my tastes.

Report Offensive Comment

I pared mine down to 5

Hoosiers
Rudy
Pride
Rocky
Remember The Titans

Report Offensive Comment

My five:
1 Bull Durham
2 Hoosiers
3 Field of Dreams
4 Slap Shot
5 White Men Can't Jump
Very under appeciated movie:Bingo Long & The Travelling AllStars
No one wants to admit to: Brian's Song

Quick note: Sports movies today are cookie cutters. Remember The Titans, Glory Road, Pride. Team doesn't get along. Team listens to song, sings along to it. Team unites against ignorant people. Team wins.

Report Offensive Comment

Another great doc I didn't mention in my intro: Pumping Iron.

Report Offensive Comment

Is that the one about steroids?

Report Offensive Comment

In the final scene of Hoosiers, the extras got so into the role that when Hickory won the state championship, they stormed the court, just like in that era. It wasn't in the script but the directors stuck with it because it so good.

Report Offensive Comment

My favorite sports movie of all time is without a doubt Major League

Report Offensive Comment

Considering I can only go off of ones I've seen...

1. Hoosiers
2. Rudy
3. Field of Dreams
4. Rocky
5. Major League

Report Offensive Comment

The only list that i would put "Chariotrs Of Fire" on is a list of worst Academy Award winning movies. "The Narural" would make a nice replacement movie for it on your list.

Report Offensive Comment

My bad...Of course, I meant "The Natural". The "Narural" was a completely forgettable film about farming in underdeveloped nations.

Report Offensive Comment

1. Raging Bull
2. Pride of the Yankees
3. Pumping Iron
4. Hoop Dreams
5. Hoosiers

Report Offensive Comment

By Sport -

Baseball: Field of Dreams, The Natural, The Rookie, Bull Durham
Football: North Dallas Forty, Brian's Song, Rudy
Basketball: Hoosiers
Hockey: Slapshot, Miracle
Golf: Caddyshack

Report Offensive Comment

I can't believe no one has even mentioned North Dallas Forty.

Report Offensive Comment
 

Never mind. I guess I should have read the comments more closely. Yes, I am in fact an idiot.

Report Offensive Comment

Add a comment

Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines


or cancel