I've seen a few of these on this site and others. I'll add my own personal list. I try to look at more then just last season. I try to take into account the last few years to try and eliminate one year anomolies. I also included only players I thought would be starting QBs. It makes it easier this way regardless since I won't have to project how good a pro Russell or Quinn will actually be.
1P. Manning2T. Brady3D. Brees4C. Palmer5M. Bulger6D. McNabb7M. Hasselbeck8J. Kitna9P. Rivers10B. Favre11C. Pennington12J. Delhomme13S. McNair14B. Roethlisberger15T. Green16T. Romo17J. Cutler18M. Vick19E. Manning20V. Young21M. Leinart22A. Smith23J. Garcia24R. Grossman25D. Huard26B. Leftwich27M. Schaub28J. Losman29J. Campbell30J. McCown31C. Frye32T. Jackson