- 08:22 PM ET 09.24
- Share
- Views
- 340
- Comments
- 0
By Shaun Payne
Last week Chuck Johnson wrote an article for Dugout Central about hitter strikeouts. The article was rather negative towards today???s game and today???s hitters, front offices and coaches. Johnson wrote: ???Baseball is willing to accept an inferior attitude towards the game, and an inferior product, because that?s what the sponsors want.???
Do sponsors really accept an inferior product? If you were trying to sell something would you really pay advertising costs during inferior programming?
I suppose it???s human nature to long for the days of yore. I suppose we think because we were once young and vibrant and more graceful at one time that all the things of our youth were better. This simply is not true. In many aspects the past is worse than the present or the future. Yes, it can be scary that things will never be like they were when we were young. We feel threatened when things change, and we desire to hang on to the world around us. But progress can be a very good thing.
At any rate, back to the subject at hand. The true reason for more strikeouts is very simple: Weak contact doesn???t cut it and hasn???t in a while. And harder contact means swinging harder and missing more often, which of course leads to more strikeouts. But that doesn???t necessarily mean a lack of knowledge of the strike zone, not being able to recognize pitches and not being able to hit in certain situations, as Chuck implies.
Anyone who studies statistics realizes there is no correlation between team strikeouts and team runs scored. But there is a strong correlation between base runners and total bases and runs scored. A team accrues base runners by avoiding outs. So strikeouts aren???t good. But even if a hitter strikes out a ton, he???s not necessarily going to hinder his on-base/out-avoiding ability. A team accrues total bases by hitting the ball past or over defenses. In order to hit the ball past or over defenses, a hitter must generate great bat speed. This is going to lead to more swings and misses and more strikeouts.
In the past, a player could shorten up with two strikes and still have a decent shot to get on base. During Babe Ruth???s 1923 season (when he had a career-high 93 strikeouts) the Philadelphia A???s led the league with 517 strikeouts. This season the Mariners have 835 strikeouts ??? last in the American League. The differences between the AL in 1923 and 2008: in 1923 the AL slugged .388 while in 2008 they have slugged .420. In 1923 the best team had a .977 fielding percentage. In 2008 the worst team has a .978 fielding percentage. Better fielders means average or weak contact isn???t going to help a hitter as much now as it did in 1923.
Also, front offices have most likely realized how much of a mistake it is to be obsessed with hitter strikeouts. Let???s look at a team of the best hitters at avoiding strikeouts:
C Yadier Molina
1B Casey Kotchman
2B Placido Polanco
3B Marco Scutaro
SS Yuniesky Betancourt
LF Carl Crawford
CF Jacoby Ellsbury
RF Ichiro Suzuki
DH Garrett Anderson
Now let???s look at a team with the top strikeout hitters:
C Geovany Soto
1B Carlos Pena
2B Dan Uggla
3B Mark Reynolds
SS Hanley Ramirez
LF Luke Scott
CF Nick Swisher
RF Mark Teahen
DH Jack Cust
The high-strikeout team looks like the better one. The reason is simple: How often hitters make outs matters more than the type of outs hitters make.
Don???t get me wrong. Again, strikeouts are not a good thing in themselves. Strikeouts are outs. But in many situations strikeouts are no worse than other outs and sometimes they are a more efficient way for a team to make outs (a strikeout is better than grounding into a double or triple play).
Much like batting average, it???s time for us to change our thinking about strikeouts. Time to stop viewing them as the worst type of out in baseball. In baseball, outs are outs. Though a strikeout is embarrassing, it still counts the same as a routine grounder to short or a deep flyout to the centerfielder.
Send us feedback about the new site here
Send us feedback about the new site here
Recent Posts
- Randy Newsom: Leaving Venezuela With Regrets
- To the Yankees I Say, "Don't Swing Lowe&
- Jimmy Scott: When Brian Boehringer Fired His Agent
- Scott Jensen: Cubs Buy High With Dempster
- Jeff Moore: Yankees' Big Spending Ways Can Work This Year
- A Year Later: Pirates Better or Worse Under New Regime?
Web's Best Blogs
-
The Big Lead
Penn State Dominating Spartans
Nitanny Lions Spartans: Penn State enters halftime with a 28-7 lead over #15 Michigan State.…
-
Every Day Should Be Saturday
Edsbs raw: naked sushi buffet picks, week 13
Michigan @ #10 Ohio State ORSON, QUASI-RATIONAL. Two hypothetical scenarios…
-
Tirico Suave
Stuntin? With Brett: The First Joint From Favr-eezy ?Fuck Yea!? Productions
When Jay Feely hit a 34-yard game-winning FG to beat the Pats, I chugged a Bud Light, did a squat…
Stub Hub
The 2008 schedule has been released. Search for tickets!
Truth & Rumors
MOST POPULAR
-
1
Red Sox, Tigers talking deal
- Views
- 9209
- Comments
- 157
-
2
T.O. stands by Cowboys criticism
- Views
- 6494
- Comments
- 133
-
3
Notre Dame's bowl options
- Views
- 7655
- Comments
- 62
-
4
Knicks make room for LeBron
- Views
- 4005
- Comments
- 59
-
5
Marbury refuses to play, D'Antoni fumes
- Views
- 6347
- Comments
- 52
Most Active Users
Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns
Message Boards
-
MMA > Fight Club
A mockery, or publicity boost?
- Views
- 1438
- Replies
- 10
-
NCAAF > General NCAAF
Gameday Predictions: Texas…
- Views
- 179
- Replies
- 10
-
NCAAF > General NCAAF
ALL OF TODAYS BLOWOUTS
- Views
- 73
- Replies
- 5
Fantasy Plus
- Fantasy Musings: Chad Johnson's demise, rookie backs running aground, more notes
- Will Caroll: Bumps, bruises taking toll on workhorse backs
- Fantasy hoops roundtable: Who are the best sell-high candidates?
- NFL fantasy rookie report: Impending playoffs raise need for rookie handcuffs
- David Sabino: Week 12 NFL fantasy start 'em, sit 'em




Bar Refaeli
Melissa Baker
College Football, Top 25 Review

Comments (0) Add A Comment
Comment
Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.