pikesteve22's Blog
  • 09:50 AM ET  09.30
Views
576
Comments
3

All this debate about who the NL MVP is really makes me wonder what people think MVP really means. According to Philadelphia fans, it should be changed to PWHTMHR (Player Who Hits The Most Home Runs). For Mets fans, it's PWFSUATM (Player Who Finally Showed Up After Two Months). Silly me, though. I thought it stood for Most Valuable Player, i.e. the person who did the most to help his team win.

 And obviously I'll have a little bit of a bias, being from St. Louis. But nobody, over the course of the entire season, did more to help his team win than Albert Pujols.

 I recently saw this article online, saying why Howard should win:

http://www.democratandchronicle.com/article/20080930/SPORTS0101/809300339/1007/RSS02

Essentially, the argument comes down to the fact that Howard helped the Phillies make the playoffs, while the Cardinals missed out. I'm guessing this same writer said that Howard deserved the MVP in 2006, when the Cardinals won the World Series and the Phillies stayed home, even though Albert put up better across-the-board numbers than Howard that year, save for HR and RBI.

Any one of the candidates mentioned has had a strong season, but it's hard to say anyone's meant more to his team than Albert. Runs created. Wins created. Value over replacement player. Pujols is the tops in each of these categories, which are designed to determine which player holds the most value.

 To be somewhat objective, if Manny Ramirez had been with the Dodgers the entire season and put up the stats at the pace he did, it'd be hard to give the award to anyone but him. He rejuvinated their lineup, and his stats project to roughly a .396 average with 51 HR and 159 RBI over a full season, to go with a .489 OBP and .743 slugging percentage. Monster numbers.

But this was one of Albert's best all-round seasons, and I think he deserves it even more than he did in '05 when he won.

 As for the rest of the awards, I'd pick Tim Lincecum to win the Cy Young. Second lowest ERA, by far the most strikeouts, and had his bullpen not blown five saves for him, he'd have twenty wins, all for a subpar team. Sure, Webb had more wins and Santana had a (barely) lower ERA, but Lincecum did it with one of the worst offenses in the league (name two hitters in their starting lineup you'd be afraid to pitch to). Geovany Soto wins rookie of the year, even though he's a damn Cub. AL MVP should be Pedrioa (would have been Quentin had he not decided to hit his own wrist with a bat), and Cliff Lee for the Cy Young. Rookie of the year to me can't be anyone but Evan Longoria.

 Thoughts? Comments? "Steve, you're an idiot" insults? Let me know.

September 30, 2008  12:06 PM ET

Steve - as you know....I am biased like you toward Albert, but if you look at AP's On-base % and slugging percentage.......he finished far ahead of everyone else. The fact is, the Cards contended all year, finishing only 4 games out of the WC. Without Albert, the Cards probably would have been 10-15 games under .500. He's clearly the MVP.

I tend to agree with your pick of Lincecum, although I think Webb will win the Cy. Lincecum definitely paid for the Giants' feeble lineup.

I think K-Rod will get some MVP consideration, too, as well as Cy Young. I'd like to see Halladay get some Cy Young votes too. He deserves them, but typically gets overlooked.

September 30, 2008  12:39 PM ET

I am not biased towards Albert Pujols -- and it still isn't even a close race for me. Pujols is the N.L. MVP, whether or not they give him the award won't change that.

 
September 30, 2008  04:44 PM ET

I'm definitely on board with Pujols. I never thought the team had to make the play-offs to win individual awards. It would be a lot easier if they just gave an MVP to the best player on each team, most likely there would be less debate.

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


Coming soon: Log in with your Facebook account, send comments and Throwdowns to Facebook and more.

Start Your Own Blog

Start Now

The Si.com Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Stub Hub

The 2009 schedule has been released. Search for tickets!

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Ex-Eagle: Cowboys everything wrong about NFL
    Views
    64800
    Comments
    964
  2. 2
    Browns owner chasing Holmgren?
    Views
    8226
    Comments
    518
  3. 3
    Who will play shortstop for Red Sox?
    Views
    9397
    Comments
    309
  4. 4
    Mangini scaring off GM candidates?
    Views
    25996
    Comments
    168
  5. 5
    Friend: Cavs should fear LeBron leaving
    Views
    10119
    Comments
    167

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
    Porkins: F U to Hell, BCS
  2. 2
    RobertMenn: You stole my rake
  3. 3
    Perfectpats
  4. 4
    sign here
  5. 5
    Oso: Informative Sports. com

Message Boards

  1. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    Sports Illustrated says Pac 10…
    Views
    483
    Replies
    81
  2. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    Iowa's loss was good for the…
    Views
    463
    Replies
    75
  3. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    BCS Standings - Updated:…
    Views
    219
    Replies
    22

Blogs

SI.com

Swimsuit

SI Photos