wildbill21475's Blog

Well its that time of year for the Major League Baseball playoffs. People are talking about the Twins-White Sox game that happened today. Twins fans are complaining that they had to play the game in Chicago when they had a better head to head record than the White Sox. Well I think it is time for the professional sports leagues to consider altering their playoff formats.

Baseball takes 8 teams to the post season every year. How many years though are the 8 teams that go to the playoffs the 8 best teams in baseball though? Well this year I can tell you that it wasn't split evenly. Before today's game with the Sox and Twins the 8 best teams record wise were Angels at 100 wins, Cubs at 97, Rays at 97, Red Sox at 95, Philies at 92, Brewers at 90, Mets at 89, and the Twins and White Sox at 88. So we would have still needed a tie breaker for the Twins and Sox. Well the Sox won that game so we would say they are in.

Instead of making a National League/American League playoffs the teams should just be seeded 1-8 and let them go at it. It would alter the traditional, but hey its the 21st Centuray lets get with the program and keep moving forward. We would be treated to first round matchups this year that would include. Angels vs. White Sox, Cubs vs Mets, Rays vs. Brewers, Sox vs. Philies. I think all those series would be better matchups than what we are going to have out of the first round now. It would make the All-Star game truely an exhibition game again. Oh well the Dodgers would be out with the Mets would be in. At least that way its the 8 best teams in baseball being rewarded, and not a mediocre division champ like we have in the Dodgers.

Lets look at how the landscape would have been different for the NBA now. Playoff teams would have been:

 Boston with 66            Detroit with 59

Lakers with 57             New Orleans with 56

San Antonio with 56     Houston with 55

Pheonix with 55            Utah with 54

Orlando with 52          Dallas with 51

Denver with 50           Golden St with 48

Cleveland with 45       Washington with 43

Portland with 41         Toronto with 41

This line up of the top 16 teams by record in the NBA would have left out teams that made the playoff with losing records such as Atlanta and Philly and included teams with .500 records or better Golden State and Portland.

First round matchups if teams were seeded 1-16 would have given matchups like:

Boston vs. Toronto            Detroit vs. Portland          Lakers vs. Washington

Hornets vs. Cleveland        Spurs vs. Warriors           Rockets vs. Nuggets

Suns vs Mavericks             Jazz vs Magic.

Rewarding losing teams by giving them playoff births while winning teams stay home because they are in strong conferences is mind boggling to me because the playoffs are there to reward the best teams and give the best teams a shot at the championship. How can the NBA have the 16 best teams in the playoffs if there was 2 teams with losing records in the Eastern Conference in the playoff while 2 teams were at 500 or better from the Western Conference sitting at home. So what it may not be Eastern vs. Western Conferences in the Finals 7 game series should end making the two best teams in the league in the finals which by record this year would have been Boston vs. Detroit going by the records.

Now I am going to try it with the NHL last year and see what the differences would have been.

Detroit with 115          San Jose with 108      Montreal with 104        Pittsburgh with 102

Anaheim with 102       New Jersey with 99     Minnesota with 98        Rangers with 97

Dallas with 97            Philly with 95             Colorado with 95          Washington with 94

Ottawa with 94           Calgary with 94          Boston with 94            Carolina with 92

This wouldn't affect the NHL as much as the other leagues as the switch would be Carlina in with Nashville out. The Matchups though would be drastically different with:

Detroit vs. Carolina       San Jose vs. Boston     Montreal vs. Calgary      Pittsburgh vs. Ottawa

Anaheim vs. Washington   New Jersey vs. Colorado   Minnesota vs. Philly  Rangers vs. Dallas

There would end up being some across the country travel but I think the matchups in the first round are better than the ones we had and could generate a lot more excitement for hockey fans.

Now I am going to see how the NFL playoff would shake down using my idea using last year as an example. The only difference would have been the Browns would have been rewarded for their 10-6 record and be in while the Redskins and their 9-7 record would have been out. Using my matchup idea though lets see how the first round pairings would have changed.

Seeding based on record would look like this:










10. Giants


12. Tampa

Under the current format the Pats, Cowboys, Colts, and Packers would have had the first round bye just like last year. The WildCard matchups would have been. Tampa vs. San Diego, Browns vs. Jaguars, Giants vs. Steeler, and Titans vs. Seahawks. The lowest remaining seeded team then goes on to play Patriots, second lowest goes on to play Cowboys, third lowest goes to Indy, and the fourth lowest would go to Green Bay. This to me would add suspence and intrigue to the playoffs as it would no longer be AFC vs. NFC in the Super Bowl. Well it could be but its not a certainty. I think it would be a lot of fun for the fans as well as the players.

Tie breakers for teams with identical records would be in order division champ or not, head to head matchup, conference record, division record, then lastly records against same opponents. I think it would be interesting thats for sure. Plus it puts the 12 best teams in football against each other. Thats the way playoffs should be. The NFL doesn't have as big a problem as the other leagues do with it in my opinion. My sample size was just last year but I am sure if I went back even further I could have found years that would have been drastically different as far as what teams went to the playoffs especially in basketball. I welcome all comments from those that agree and disagree. Just keep it civil and intelligent.   





Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.

Start Your Own Blog

Start Now

Truth & Rumors


  1. 1
    Irving: Fans don't deserve the Cavs
  2. 2
    Red Sox dodged two injury scares
  3. 3
    D'Antoni's newest 'blunder'
  4. 4
    Trump taking a legit run at the Bills
  5. 5
    Baseball's top 2015 free agent


SI Photos