Views
245
Comments
7
Solvability.

Ok. (this is also posted in the NMI)

Let me get one thing out in the open.

NMI as it was intended is dead- the ideas put forth for NMI are since the revamp of the site, mass exodus of people, infustion of the T&Rs, combined with Stowe's abdication and Number 2 Porkins discovering the value meal at Taco Bell, as well as my own wishes to be Warrick rather than Kind Henry IV.

Not anyones fault (other than Frank) just the way things are. This is not an indictment of Robert or anyone else.

NMI is simply an exclusive group, same as BVOF, SIFS and LODT

And I'm fine with that.

Here is what my thoughts are.

We recently have a "war" with the BVOF. I think it's a great thing with one issue.

Lets face it- The NMI has the Bulk of the power- no offense to any one- but given a 5 spot of Me, Porkins, Ram, D-Fan and Yoda- and we could lap the field of Fannation.

This is not a dig on ANY Tder- simply a statement of fact- If you had a 3 man team of Porkins, Ram and D-Fan same situation. Sorry If I step on your toes- but being top 5% of Fanntion does not mean you are top FIVE on Fannation.

Now looking over the Rosters (excel is wonderful) 4 of the 5 are on both listings- meaning if BVOF recruits better than they win most contests as well if they get the proper members

Bottom line

NMI has 50 Members (Half are in BVOF)

BVOF has 56 members (26 are in NMI)

What I propose is this.

Split the groups

Have the people in BOTH groups Drop 1. (or have a draft)

People in 1 group but not the other- stay in that group.

That gives BVOF 30 members and NMI 25

I think the purpose of BOTH groups should be to show FN what TDs are about- and competition between the groups could do that.

Part of the Problem we have now is that the "power Tders" are going to be forced to pick sides every month- and GOOD Tders like Gu3, Dyhard Etc will either never be asked or forced to pull an upset every month

and If I beat on GU3 every month, how long is he going to play? I'm not picking on him- If I had to face Porkins monthly- I'd get tired of losing to him. Going on Previous work- beating D-Fan once every 7 months is going to get a little boring for me.

We can use the FNC to push both groups and Tournament Throwdowns to host the "war" Tds

Thoughts?

I will be posting the SAME blog on the BVOF group- I propose that if 51% is in agreement- in BOTH groups- then we move forward.

please FANMAIL me your OFFICIAL Vote- below is simply for discussion and if you wish to make your vote public.

I will close the voting Dec 5th

I think we change the purpose of BOTH groups to make TDs BETTER this way.

November 26, 2008  01:05 PM ET

I'll make mine public, because I'm all for quality TDs with quality people. Winning stupid ones pads the record, but winning or losing quality ones is always satisfying. Just knowing I gave my best and received someone else's best is winning, regardless of the voting. I can't control that part.

November 26, 2008  03:02 PM ET

Although I do not TD I just realized that I am in both groups. Draft away. It sounds like a good plan.

November 26, 2008  04:59 PM ET

This really is a tough one... I was on board with NMI pretty soon after its initial launch... and the same goes for BVOF, as I was one of the ones whose writing helped build that less-private group as well... I would hate to be forced to choose between one or the other... BVOF has become what SIFS used to be to me, a place where my writing would reach a greater audience... and while NMI has changed drastically in its existence, I would be loathe to give up such status as well...

November 26, 2008  07:25 PM ET
QUOTE(#3):

This really is a tough one... I was on board with NMI pretty soon after its initial launch... and the same goes for BVOF, as I was one of the ones whose writing helped build that less-private group as well... I would hate to be forced to choose between one or the other... BVOF has become what SIFS used to be to me, a place where my writing would reach a greater audience... and while NMI has changed drastically in its existence, I would be loathe to give up such status as well...

I am in the same boat as well.

I am considering a joint group for Blogs and such ( and why are you NOT using the FNC anyway)

and use the NMI/BVOF for "war"

November 27, 2008  03:50 PM ET

I am a bit confused on the whole "War" thing. Would I be a lower seed since I only have 60 wins?

November 27, 2008  04:52 PM ET

I would say turn NMI into a TDing group --- and turn BVOF into a blogging group.

Simpler for everyone to understand and there would be clear goals.

 
November 27, 2008  04:53 PM ET

not really a Seed- more like a pick. I mean even if we went 10 on 10 - it would still be the Same people over and over again, Me and TripC have already faced off a dozen times- thing is- if we are on opposite sides- I'm not going to put him vs a "weaker" Tder and he is not about to let me face a weaker player either. - so me Vs him part 1,872


and there are TDers on here with FAR less wins than you that scare even the best- Yoda has less than 50 wins.

Its quality, not quantity- I only have a good rep because I have beaten everyone (but D-Cap)

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


Coming soon: Log in with your Facebook account, send comments and Throwdowns to Facebook and more.

Start Your Own Blog

Start Now

The Si.com Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Stub Hub

The 2009 schedule has been released. Search for tickets!

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Red Sox-Jays deal-killer?
    Views
    39385
    Comments
    1186
  2. 2
    Martz to jump-start Bears offense?
    Views
    14082
    Comments
    983
  3. 3
    Notre Dame cancels Weis' recruiting trip
    Views
    50261
    Comments
    314
  4. 4
    Miami: Less Gators, more Bulls
    Views
    8278
    Comments
    260
  5. 5
    Artest: Free agents 'scared' to play in NY
    Views
    52694
    Comments
    188

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
    Chico 2.0
  2. 2
    BBK - Now it's all football
  3. 3
    rstowe
  4. 4
    gigi_iv
  5. 5
    Never NDing Struggle

Message Boards

  1. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    Longhorns vs. Aggies…
    Views
    574
    Replies
    80
  2. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    Week 13 Predictions (Rivalry…
    Views
    200
    Replies
    15
  3. NBA > General NBA

    Surprises of the NBA - Part 3
    Views
    168
    Replies
    4

Blogs

SI.com

Swimsuit

SI Photos