Posted by:
How 'bout 'em

I love the bowl season because it gives us wonderful non-conference action.  The bowl season is the one time where conference judgment is almost objective.


I’ve devised a formula to help make sense of all 34 bowl games and how the conferences stack up respectively.  A team and its conference gets one point for making it to a bowl but not being able to get that W. (It’s all about that W, right?) Winning a crappy bowl is little better than losing in a bowl, so I allotted the points as such.  For a team with a win in a third-tier bowl, they get 2 points.  For a team with a win in a second-tier bowl win, they get 3 points.  For a team with a win in a BCS game, they get 4 points. (except for one BCS bowl; can you guess which one?)  For a national title win, that team and respective conference gets five points.  Then I take all of the points and add them together and compare the scores (don’t worry; I’ll do this again once the bowls are over). So even if team A wins the national title, team A’s conference will need their other teams to perform well to win my bowl conference challenge.


To decide between the tier of the bowls, I usually used the records for both teams.  For instance, if both teams’ records combined for 12-14 wins (before the bowl game), then they were definitely in a 3rd tier bowl.  If the teams combined for 15 wins, then it was a gut call as to whether they were 3rd or 2nd tier. 16 combined wins and up usually got you a 2nd tier bowl game spot (the only exception was the Texas Bowl for obvious reasons).  I have only 2 more 2nd tier than 3rd tier.


Here’s a list of where I placed each bowl:

Third Tier:

Eagle Bank (Wake Forest-Navy), New Mexico (Colorado St.-Fresno), Saint Petersburg (Memphis-USF), New Orleans (Southern Miss.-Troy), Hawaii (Hawaii-Notre Dame), Motor City (FAU-Central Mich.), Independence (NIU-Louisiana Tech), PapaJohn’ (NC State-Rutgers), Humanitarian (Maryland-Nevada), Texas (W. Mich.-Rice), Armed Forces (Houston-Air Force), , Insight (Kansas-Minnesota), Liberty (Kentucky-E. Carolina) [Kentucky being 6-6 and E. Carolina being from the conference USA hurt this bowl’s tier at 15 combined wins], and International (Buffalo-UConn)

Second Tier:

Las Vegas (BYU-Arizona), Poinsettia (Boise St.-TCU), Meineke Car Care (WVU-UNC), Champs Sports (Wisconsin-FSU), Emerald (Miami-Cal), Alamo (Missouri-Northwestern), Holiday (Oklahoma St.-Oregon), Sun (Oregon St.-Pittsburgh), Music City (Boston College-Vanderbilt) [This is the biggest one I was teetering with at 15 wins combined pre-bowl, but this game was very interesting to me with the ACC&SEC match up and it being Vandy's first bowl in a long time.] Chick-fil-a (LSU-Georgia Tech), Outback (South Carolina-Iowa), Capitol One (UGA-Mich. St.), Gator (Nebraska-Clemson), Cotton (Ole Miss-Texas Tech), GMAC (Ball St.-Tulsa) [I'm tempted to put the GMAC lower, but their records are too good to pass up.], and finally the Orange Bowl (Cincinnati-Virginia Tech)

I had to put the Orange bowl in the 2nd tier because it was such a bad BCS game.  It’s almost like the BCS decision makers just lumped these two ugly-ducklings together because they had no other place to go except for the “Outcast BCS Bowl.” I could put the Orange Bowl in the BCS section, but I wouldn’t like it.  Did you see the crowd for that game too? It wasn't even half capacity.


Rose (Penn St.-USC), Sugar (Utah-Alabama), and Fiesta (Ohio St.-Texas)

National Title:

BCS title game(Florida-Oklahoma)


As of 1/3/09 at noon, the conferences stack up like this (with potential win points in parentheses but one point will be awarded for losing anyways):

  1.  SEC - 16 (5)
  2. ACC and Pac 10 tied - 16
  3. [ACC and Pac 10]
  4. Big 12 - 10 (4,5)
  5. Mountain West - 10
  6. Big East - 9 (2)
  7. Big 10 - 8 (4) [Iowa was the Big 10's saving grace.]
  8. Conference USA - 8 (2)
  9. Sun Belt and WAC tied - 5
  10. [Sun Belt and WAC]
  11. MAC - 4 (2,2) [Poor ol' MAC is winless right now, but they have 2 more chances.]
  12. Independents - 4



Let me know if it needs any tweaking before the finalized version comes out.


Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.

Start Your Own Blog

Start Now

Truth & Rumors


  1. 1
    Woodson's next job
  2. 2
    'Melo wants to be wooed (like, Howard wooed)
  3. 3
    Lee on the Yankees' radar (Burnett, too)
  4. 4
    Farrell defends Fenway's 'sleep room'
  5. 5
    Rangers pegged as unsportsmanlike divers

SI Photos