The trade is his Peyton Manning for the other guy's Joseph Addai, Kurt Warner, and Reggie Wayne.
This trade really depends on what other players you have. I'm going to have to say yes on this one.
Peyton Manning is a GREAT and consistent fantasy QB, but he has consistently been putting up average numbers this year. In order to trade Manning, you must get a lot for him and with this trade it is just the right people. Joseph Addai is doing fantastic this year and has emerged as an elite fantasy back. Wayne isn't very skilled, but he does have Peyton Manning throwing to him, and any one who has Peyton Manning throwing to him can do well. Good fantasy player, bad skilled player. Wayne will also benefit from Marvin Harrison getting double covered. I've always liked Kurt Warner and I think he still got it. Heres what I like about him, his team constantly throws. He will have games with over 40 attempts and Whisenhut is a genius and can figure out how to get the ball in the end zone. Warner will put up stead numbers. Not like Manning's, but with the two other people you are getting, you can afford to give up Manning.