Notes from the North
Views
405
Comments
2

On December 17, 2010, I wrote a blog suggesting that Troy Polamalu should be taken to task for his risky touchdown dive against Cincinatti. The title of that blog was "Polamalu's TD dive hurt the Steelers in the long run".

I opined that Polamalu did the Steelers no favours by hurting himself in his dive for the endzone. He and his team would have been better served if he had allowed himself to be tackled on the three yard line and not risk the injury. After all, Pittsburgh probably would have scored anyway and they needed their all-pro safety healthy for the playoff run.

Now, I'm the first to admit when I'm wrong. And I am wrong much more often than I am right. But the recent news that Polamalu was indeed injured in that dive and that his injury negatively impacted his performance throughout the playoffs has vindicated my position in that earlier blog.

Yes, there are a lot of ifs to my argument. Maybe if Polamalu doesn't dive into the endzone, Cincinatti's defence comes up big and Pittsburgh loses that game. And maybe that loss knocks them out of the playoffs entirely.

 It's also possible to argue that, even with an uninjured Polamalu, the Steelers still lose to the Packers in the Super Bowl.

But I'm not so sure. Polamalu was a complete non-factor against Green Bay and Aaron Rodgers did take apart the Steeler defense, especially in the first half. Maybe if Polamalu was more himself in that game, he makes a big play or two and the Steelers don't fall so far behind at the half.

Again, I'm not knocking Polamalu. He's an exceptional player and it's hard to question a guy who leaves it all on the field on every play. Who am I to tell him he should have thought before diving in the heat of battle?

But it just goes to prove once again that the difference between winning and losing in as competitive league like the NFL is razor thin: maybe as thin as a half-step in the speed of Troy Polamalu. Maybe as thin as the decision to dive into the endzone in a late season game and tweak an injury.

Comment #1 has been removed
 
March 13, 2011  04:59 PM ET
QUOTE(#1):

Was he showboating when he dove into the endzone? If not, what player doesn't want to score? do you really think a player is going to say to himself "don't dive, I might get hurt" when they have a chance to score a TD? Be real - - If he was showboating, you can crucify him again tomorrow. Otherwise, leave the holy water in the tank.

No he wasn't showboating. It was his desire to finish that play. This is a what if blog. Troy is the best safety in football to me. But he is one guy on a team. And the way to hurt the Steelers has been to spread them out and throw in the middle of the field. That's even with Troy on the field. He got hurt. And no one wants their best players to get hurt or miss games. But they happen. I don't want to go through to many what if scenarios. But you are right in making an argument for Troy and the Steelers.

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


Start Your Own Blog

Start Now

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Mavs shopping pick, eyeing Howard (and CP3)
    Views
    10239
    Comments
    923
  2. 2
    Donnie Baseball trying to get himself fired
    Views
    14413
    Comments
    607
  3. 3
    Careless Jets already steaming Ryan
    Views
    49295
    Comments
    84
  4. 4
    Oregon notified of allegations in December
    Views
    3050
    Comments
    71
  5. 5
    Alfredsson predicts series defeat
    Views
    6582
    Comments
    55

SI.com

Swimsuit

SI Photos