Top 4

Josh Cribbs

Braylon Edwards

Phil Dawson

Derek Anderson

And

the

winner

is

from Kent State

JOSH CRIBBS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Suprise pick here I know,  you were expecting Braylon Edwards and while I love Braylon, Cribbs is insane.

1. Josh Cribbs

2. Braylon Edwards

3. Phil Dawson

4. Derek Anderson

Punt ReturnYearTeamGRetRetYAvgLngTD20+40+FCFUM2007Cleveland Browns 163040513.576T162103

Kick ReturnYearTeamGRetYdsAvgLngTD20+40+FCFUM2007Cleveland Browns 16591,80930.7100T249701

Thats right, sink it in. It takes awhile to absorb all that.

Cribbs had a tendancy to dominate games. Like the Steeler game in Pitt. Cribbs had over 200 total return yards and without him the score wouldnt have even been close. Teams dont bring him down on the first hit, no way. It takes about 4 guys to bring this man down and his 30.7 average per kick return really shows it. I really cant believe this guy.

Braylon  Edward 

REC

Cribbs has really earned this award and is one of the 2 Cleveland Brown representatives at the probowl with the other being Braylon Edwards. I truly believe that without Josh Cribbs this year, the Browns would not have even had 8 wins. Thats right, he is that much of a game changer and is the second best kick returner in the NFL to Devin Hester. Phil Dawson may be a little bit controversal, but he has drilled game winning field goals this season and Im sure we all remember the Ravens game. (Im sure Gu3 does)