Message Boards

Trade Kolb for McNabb

Vick still has that lightning-quick change of direction--made some folks look silly.

If it was a popularity contest.. Kolb

But.. its not and for his sheer god given athletic ability, I'd start Vick. He looks to be back in Falcon shape or at least close and once again will give defenses nightmares.

QUOTE(#6):

Originally posted 05:25 PM ET  09.13 by EazyDozit

Yeah,especially too dogs................

At this point it would be egg in the face of the front office...they are paying Kolb like a franchise QB, and his plays says he should be in the UFL.

Simple choice...a three time pro bowl QB who has led his team the a Conference Championship game...or a QB with four career TD passes and 11 INT's...you do the math...

It is no comparison, with a limited run game and O-line problems the Eagles have, Vick's mobility helps out in all phases...IMO they are going to bench Kolb this week against Detroit who will be hapless without Stafford. If Vick lights up the Lions, you will then have a full fledge QB issue...

Is it still OK to crack pervert jokes about other teams QB's who have not finished paying their penalty for bad behavior? Couldn't resist it EZ ...lol

Vick proved he still has it. If I was Reid I'd go with Vick because Kolb didn't even look like he wanted the job.

QUOTE(#12):

Originally posted 08:57 PM ET  09.13 by EazyDozit

BGD,NP,You know how I feel about Dogs.[alot of them better than some People I've come across.] They are "Loyal",Like Family,No other Animal has this distinction[including Cats]People Shoot Deer for Sport and other animals,I don't need too hunt for food,and I don't hunt any Animals for sport.It is what is is...............

I feel the same way Eazy and a friend runs a no kill rescue for Pits out of his own pocket, I help him out from time to time and have witnessed first hand and up close the repercussions of dog fighting and the scars on some of these dogs are beyond imagination. Vick served his time and has his second chance and deserves it but it doesn't mean we have to be his fan and we are entitled our opinion either way.

QUOTE(#10):

Originally posted 06:49 PM ET  09.13 by BGDUECE

At this point it would be egg in the face of the front office...they are paying Kolb like a franchise QB, and his plays says he should be in the UFL.Simple choice...a three time pro bowl QB who has led his team the a Conference Championship game...or a QB with four career TD passes and 11 INT's...you do the math...It is no comparison, with a limited run game and O-line problems the Eagles have, Vick's mobility helps out in all phases...IMO they are going to bench Kolb this week against Detroit who will be hapless without Stafford. If Vick lights up the Lions, you will then have a full fledge QB issue...Is it still OK to crack pervert jokes about other teams QB's who have not finished paying their penalty for bad behavior? Couldn't resist it EZ ...lol

Good points he did play like a minor league QB.

I would not want him to watch my dog...but he is the best QB they have on the roster...

QUOTE:

Originally posted by

that is funny as hell !!!!

It's going to haunt them, and I think that it is already starting. Week 2 and there is a QB controversy brewing.

QUOTE:

Originally posted by

I thought it was a bad move, but it is good for McNabb, he always got way too much crap there.

I don't think McNabb ever got great receivers to match his talent. Sure he may have gotten a few single good receivers, but he never got a great pair of receivers to give him options.

QUOTE(#18):

Originally posted 04:08 PM ET  09.14 by LowCountryBrownsFan

It's going to haunt them, and I think that it is already starting. Week 2 and there is a QB controversy brewing.

Yep, they were dumb and put their eggs all in one basket. Kolb had a few decent games, but they never double checked the guy.

For now I'd give the reigns to Vick and wait till he starts fumbling and throwing interceptions. Buy then maybe Kolb will have settled down and you can switch back to Kolb.

QUOTE(#25):

Originally posted 08:32 PM ET  09.14 by narrator

For now I'd give the reigns to Vick and wait till he starts fumbling and throwing interceptions. Buy then maybe Kolb will have settled down and you can switch back to Kolb.

Flip flopping QBs almost never works out. Trust me, I'm a Cleveland fan.