Ranking all 32 quarterbacks

2009-07-30T16:02:59-04:00

2007-05-18T11:35:33-04:00

968

2008-09-10T06:40:24-04:00

2009-07-30T16:02:59-04:00

fredz

No City 820509

2 <a href="http://im_shoutcorner.web4free.org/site/">thanks for posting!</a> 6297444

2009-07-30T16:02:44-04:00

fredz

No City 820509

1 <a href="http://im_shoutcorner.web4free.org/site/">thanks for posting!</a> 6297456

2007-07-16T16:22:55-04:00

Leonard Weirich

Silver Spring 75595

I agree Peyton Manning is #1, but as far as #2 goes, Tom Brady had it too good for too long. If anyone deserves to be #2, it would be a toss up between Carson Palmer and Philip Rivers. I see P Manning at #1, Palmer at #2, Rivers at #3, and Ben Roethlisberger at #4. Brady? In my eyes, he is #15. 34753

2007-06-12T13:23:14-04:00

tiki51

Marion 7223

there is no way you can say that charlie frye is the worst starting QB in the NFL. he is a much better QB than JP Lossman. to say that young is the worst out the top three qbs drafted last year. did you even watch football last season. also romo is leagues ahead of vick and ben roethlisberger who is undoubtedly the most overated player in th nfl this year. 22943

2007-06-06T19:15:23-04:00

http://img.fannation.com/upload/user_profile/image/958/1/thumb/Reindeer.jpg 4838 IL

chrono8008: Gone forever!

A place 9601

There are a lot of comments on this. Wow. 20893

2007-06-01T09:11:02-04:00

Feva

Lawrenceville 32207

Look man... Donovan McNabb, WHEN HEALTHY is easily a top 3 QB in this league. I definitely concede to Tom Brady and Peyton Manning (even though McNabb has more playoff victories than Manning)... but there is no one who has done more in this league with less offensively than McNabb over his career. I wonder how many Super Bowls McNabb would have won up to this point with weapons like Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne his entire career like Manning has. We all saw where the Eagles went in '04 with a top notch WR. I totally agree that he needs to stay healthy from here on out but when he is indeed healthy... he's top 3, period. Case in point, he was having a MVP type season leading the #1 rated offense in the NFL last year and leading the league in TD passes when he got hurt. 20839

2007-05-30T03:35:26-04:00

steelersteve

No City 26163

John Kitna BLOWS!!!!!!!!!!!! 20440

2007-05-29T10:22:03-04:00

http://img.fannation.com/upload/user_profile/image/304/78/thumb/TROFIEZ.jpg 38 OH

midwestniner

Warren 30578

vick is garbage, instead of dismantling animals maybe he should improve his game...so no, not everywhere you go has "love for mike vick" 20100

2007-05-28T14:07:49-04:00

mathewmarie

Batavia 30357

you are a freakin reta rd if you think JP losman is 28th, but Lineart is twelfth. Vick? Cutler? Young? Rex Grossman? Are you smoking crack? How the f$#@ can you be a **** professional and be so stupid? Drop dead. Hope you get fired, ****... 18843

2007-05-24T16:06:03-04:00

http://img.fannation.com/upload/user_profile/image/266/01/thumb/browns-steelers-inside.jpg 8 XX

mjf10

Oshawa 26641

big ben higher than Phillip Rivers 18416

968

Like all great sports arguments, this debate began at a bar, with a number of SI.com colleagues earlier this week. The challenge: rank the 32 projected starting quarterbacks. The criteria: how will they perform in 2007, factoring intangibles such as winning and leadership along with statistics. Marc Bulger may have better numbers than Tom Brady, but that doesn't make Bulger more valuable. After No. 5, this gets very difficult, but if you disagree with any of my rankings, I'll gladly set you straight in a FanNation Throwdown at any time.<ol><li>Peyton Manning</li><li>Tom Brady </li><li>Carson Palmer</li><li>Drew Brees</li><li>Philip Rivers</li><li>Donovan McNabb</li><li>Ben Roethlisberger</li><li>Marc Bulger</li><li>Matt Hasselbeck</li><li>Michael Vick</li><li>Tony Romo</li><li>Matt Leinart</li><li>Jay Cutler</li><li>Vince Young</li><li>Brett Favre</li><li>Steve McNair</li><li>Alex Smith</li><li>Jeff Garcia</li><li>Jake Delhomme</li><li>Chad Pennington</li><li>Jon Kitna</li><li>Eli Manning</li><li>Damon Huard</li><li>Trent Green (assuming he's a Dolphin)</li><li>Jason Campbell</li><li>Rex Grossman</li><li>Byron Leftwich</li><li>J.P. Losman</li><li>Matt Schaub</li><li>Josh McCown</li><li>Tarvaris Jackson</li><li>Charlie Frye</li></ol> http://img.fannation.com/upload/user_profile/image/397/2/thumb/Perloff.jpg 684 NY

Andrew Perloff

New York 3992 2599