FanNation

'Ey Capernicus said 01/24, 06:17 PM
Based on this season, not including the playoffs, Second place teams include: Bills, Jaguars, Browns, Broncos, Giants, Vikings, Cardinals, and Panthers. Only your list first and arguments in second and third.

Use the same format as me.

QB: David Garrard, Jaguars
RB1: Adrian Peterson, Vikings
RB2: Fred Taylor, Jaguars
WR: Larry Fitzgerald, Cardinals
WR: Braylon Edwards, Browns
WR: Brandon Marshall, Broncos
TE: Kellen Winslow, Browns

I only put some positions because I didn't have much time.

'Ey Capernicus said 01/24, 07:15 PM
Okay, like I said, I don't have time for the rest of the team, but I'll try.

Garrard may have less yards and touchdowns, but he had nearly 200 less attempts. Garrard also had 16 LESS INTs! He also had a QB rating that was 20 points higher along with a much higher completion %. Another thing was Garrard's receivers are much, much worse than Anderson's

I had a tough time with Marshall and Burress. I chose Marshall because he had more yards and receptions. Marshall really stepped up when Javon Walker went out and helped his team greatly.

I can only change a few.

Chris Harris over Darren Sharper. Sharper was a member of the worst passing defense in the league. He did have 4 picks, 3 more than Harris, BUT Harris had 34 more tackles and 7 MORE FORCED FUMBLES.

Champ Bailey over Antrel Rolle. Bailey may have two less picks, but he is the most feared corner throughout the league and he is avoided. He also defended 4 more passes than Rolle. Another thing, Bailey had 23 more tackles.

'Ey Capernicus said 01/24, 07:40 PM
Garrard didn't have as many yards and touchdowns because he had so many less attempts than Anderson. Derek Anderson has one touchdown for every 18 attempts while Garrard has also had one touchdown for every 18 attempts. Therefore Garrard would throw the same number of TDs while throwing less INTs. Also, you didn't say anything about the better receivers.

I actually said in my argument that Bailey had less interceptions, but ok. Bailey has defended more passes and had more tackles while being thrown away from. And no him getting more tackles doesn't show that he is getting the ball more because Bailey is CAPABLE OF STOPPING THE RUN TOO.

One game for your argument about Burress? Plaxico is bigger and stronger than Harris. Harris is physical and presses, therefore Plaxico overpowers him and easily gets open. Marshall had around 300 more yards and 32 more receptions!