FanNation - The Republic of Sport

Goodell: Nov 4 is the day said 02/06, 06:39 PM
Choose a full 11 man offensive roster. Line-up is your choice but you must have 5 O-Linmen and 1 QB. The other 5 spots are up to you.

No players that have won MVP (NFL, AFL,SB, PB)

No active players(Modern Era only)

Use different players as much as possible

This may take a minute, so take you time

QB - Jim Kelly

RB - Curtis Martin

FB - Mike Alstott

WR - Cris Carter
WR - Tim Brown
WR - Andre Reed

OT - Anthony Munoz

OG - John Hannah

C - Dwight Stephenson

OG - Billy Shaw: Only person in history to play ENTIRE career in AFL, and be elected to HOF for the NFL

OT - Jackie Slater

Goodell: Nov 4 is the day said 02/07, 10:21 AM
Dont worry about how long it took you. It took me over an hour, and I made the rules...I had to sift through Wikipedia and NFL.com for a very long time

So we will go Maritn vs Dickerson...Curtis is one of 5 RB's in the history of the NFL to have 400 REC's and 10,000 yds rushing. The others are Payton, Thurman, Faulk, and Barber. Any time you are mentioned in the same breath as Faulk, Payton and Thurman...Your doin somthing right. Funny thing is all three of em have won a MVP honor.

Martin: Only RB in NFL history to gain 1000 yds in 10 consecutive seasons. 14101 yds, 90 TD's on the ground. 484 REC's for 10 more TD's. He's currently 4th ALLTIME in Rushing history

Dickerson is 6th all time rushing, but he only has 8 seasons over 1000 yds..

Martin > Dickerson = NO Brainer

Gene Upshaw v. Billy Shaw: Upshaw should lose points for the way he is handling the NFLPA issue's. Just kidding....well, not really but here we go. Both Shaw and Upshaw are HOF gaurds. The difference is Billy Shaw never played a snap in the NFL, yet voters deemed him worthy of HOF honors. Seeing how he is the only person in history to do so, that is a note worthy accomplishment

out of space

Goodell: Nov 4 is the day said 02/07, 03:07 PM
I wont waste anymore space on players we already did, But Martin is still better then Dickerson. Martin stayed CONSISTENT for a entire DECADE

Cris Carter & Andre Reed v. Steve Largent & Lance Alworth, this should be intersting.

Reed and Carter combine for:
8 ALL PROS
15 PB's
2052 career REC's....Yes, thats over 2000
27,097 yds REC
217 REC TD's

Allworth and Largent combine for:
15 All-Pros
14 PB's
1361 REC
23,355 Yds
185 TDs

Besides PB's and ALL Pros...Carter and Reed are much more productive then Alworth and Largent. All respect given to Largent and Alworth of course

Now, I dont really think this is fair, but Slater vs Shell is NO CONTEST. Beside's Munoz, Slater is the best OT in the history of the NFL. There are better linemen like John Hannah, but when it comes to OT's, Slater and Munoz are the best