FanNation | The Republic of Sport

Community

EliManning's#1Fan is 5-16 won the Throwdown.

DetroitFan* BS: Haha Harris!

Throwndowns: 20
Record: 5 - 15 - 0
Chesapeake , VA
All Throwdowns

Votes

Throwndowns: 150
Record: 134 - 9 - 7
The Big House, MI
All Throwdowns

Votes

The Giants Played Better In The Super Bowl

EliManning's#1Fan is 5-16 said 02/24, 07:44 PM
I say that the Giants played better in the super bowl for many reasons, one of which was the fact that Eli didn't get sacked FIVE times. Don't worry, I have more arguments.

DetroitFan* BS: Haha Harris! said 02/24, 07:51 PM
Hence the reason they won...

What are you trying to prove? I see, you are gloating that the Giants won, right?

Well, keep it in a blog, because this is a non-arguable issue.

How could you not say the Giants were better in the Superbowl? Before you make an argument, you need to look at both sides of the issue before you go ahead and speak your mind.

Do you win the Super Bowl if you played worse? No, you don't. Do you win the Super Bowl if you played better? Yes, that is the reason they won.

I am sure AT LEAST 99% of this website is aware that the Giants won the Super Bowl.

Who will argue with you on this?

You don't need more arguments. You need a new issue to argue on, because this one stinks... If you make something that someone will argue, others will take it.

Don't make silly topics like this one, please. Other people have throwdown ideas and would gladly share them with you.

However, how is this debatable?

EliManning's#1Fan is 5-16 said 02/24, 08:04 PM
Yes, I suppose I am gloating, but that is beside the point.

ACTUALLY, teams can play better and still lose, especially by luck. take for instance:

when the giants faced the patriots in the last game, it was widely agreed that the Giants inded played better than the Patriots. Eli's quarterback rating in that game, although not to speak for the whole team's playing, was a 161.2, compared to Tom Brady's 99.7 of that night. Yet the giants lost afterwards.

Of course 99% of this site will know of the iants Super Bowl win; this is a sports site.

As for when you said: "Who will argue with you on this? ",
You seem to be arguing me on this, so why ask that?

If this issue stinks, i suggest you plug your nose and grit with it- you decided to get into this against me, not anyone else.

and also, some hard-nosed Pats fan may come up against me on this if i were to use this topic again, because they are mad, and perhaps have another view on it entirely.

DetroitFan* BS: Haha Harris! said 02/24, 08:10 PM
The Giants played better? Then why didn't they win that game? Because the Patriots played better in the regular Season game... It was widely agreed that the Giants played well in that game, but they did not play better than the Patriots in that game.

See:

Better Offense:

Patriots - 38 Points
Giants - 35 Points

Better Defense, Giving Up Less:

Patriots - 35
Giants - 38

When I said who would argue this, I am not arguing on you at the fact that Giants played better. I am arguing that this topic is not arguable, which you know is true.

Plug my nose and grit with it? Why say this? Do you think I will really have someone try to argue this and get bashed for it? No.

I am a Die-Hard Tom Brady fan. Do you think THAT many people are still viciously upset, or do they have the brain to say it was a game, and let it go? I go with option 2...

How could anyone have a different view on it, if the Giants won?

EliManning's#1Fan is 5-16 said 02/24, 08:17 PM
When you said: "I am not arguing on you at the fact that Giants played better," you are going against this whole thing. that is the topic of this whole damn thing.

Second, I'm more liable to be bashed by folks like you than angry pats fans anyways.

most pats fans that i know actually are being little snubs about our win, claiming that "they" played better and "we" cheated, which is not true.

DetroitFan* BS: Haha Harris! said 02/24, 08:22 PM
Who would argue the other side?

Before you make the argument, you need to look at both sides and see if it is really arguable... Whoever else accepted this would probably say the same thing I am, even another Patriots Fan...

Your "Secondly" statement has nothing to be commented on...

Most Pat Fans you know? They must not be TRUE FANS, because a True Fan would understand they screwed up their chances, and the fault is the Patriots team, and theirs alone.

Who ever said the Giants cheated?

Report Offensive Throwdown

Comments (23)

Most Recent Comment Add Comment RSS

hi peoples

An SI.com and CNN Digital Network Site

Search

Already a member?

The Giants Played Better In The Super Bowl

DetroitFan* BS: Haha Harris! beat EliManning's#1Fan is 5-16 22 to 3

Add a comment