KG Fan Anything is possible won the Throwdown.
Throwndowns: 155
Record: 60 - 87 - 8
Boston, MA
All Throwdowns
2
Votes
Throwndowns: 206
Record: 74 - 116 - 16
Detroit, MI
All Throwdowns
6
Votes

Make the best possible starting rotation using two letters ast the start of last name. List only in first argument.


S and P

SP- Jake Peavy

SP- Brad Penny

SP- Johan Santana

SP- C.C Sabahia

SP- John Smoltz


S and B

SP-Erik Bedard

SP-Josh Beckett

SP-Johan Santana

SP-CC Sabithia


Firt of all you only have four pitchers so not a full roation. Anyways differences are Peavy Bedard and Penny vrs Beckett.

Peavy vrs. Bedard- Jake Peavy benifits slightly from playing in the NL but still his stats are just overwhelming. He had a ERA of 2.54 to go with 19 wins and 9.67 K's per 9 innings. Don't say he is only good at Petco because he had a 2.57 ERA on the road. Bedard had a great year going 13-5 with a 3.16 ERA and 10.93 K's per 9 but not the year Peavy had. Bedard also beniffited from his ome park evident by his 3.47 road ERA to 2.81 at home.

Brad Penny vrs Josh Beckett- This one is very very close with Penny haveing a 3.03 ER, 9 hr allowed, and 153 K"s to Beckett's 3.27 ERA, 17 HR allowed, and 194 K's. Penny allowed fewer runs and HR while Beckett struck out more hitters. I would say this is a tie since Penny is in NL and Beckett is in AL .


Forfeited Turn


Why didn't you argue Dawgee when you were here evidenced by the fact that you left a comment


Forfeited Turn

dawgee you only have 4 pitchers....

Report Offensive Comment

dawgee is going old school :-)

Report Offensive Comment

F and J

1.Casey Fossum
2.Gavin Floyd
3.Josh Fogg
4.Jason Jennings
5.Edwin Jackson

Report Offensive Comment

oops, I meant to add John Smoltz

Are you serious Coletrain?

Report Offensive Comment

Yes.

Report Offensive Comment

Josh beckett
Josh beckett
josh beckett
josh beckett

Report Offensive Comment

Jim Bunning Hall of fame
Charles Bender Hall of Fame

Rollie FIngers Hall of Fame
Whitey Ford Hall of Fame

Tom Seaver Hall of fame
Warren Spahn Hall of Fame

Report Offensive Comment

Don Sutton Hall of Fame Bruce Suter Hall of Fame

Report Offensive Comment
 

How about the four S's all hall of Famers

Tom Seaver NY Mets Warren Spahn Milwaukee Don Sutton LA Dodgers Bruce Sutter

Report Offensive Comment

Add a comment

Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines


or cancel