Ny said 03/09, 08:32 PM
Pick first,argue second and third
Fred Davis USC
Bio1590 said 03/09, 09:11 PM
Dustin Keller, Purdue
Ny said 03/09, 09:22 PM
Lets compair numbers
Davis-62 rec,881 yards,8 tds
Keller-68 rec,881 yards,7 tds
Davis is the best pass catcher at the tight end position.He was a wide recier in high school and runs great routes.He has good speed and has the body size to compete in the NFL at 6'4 258 pounds,which gives him a sizable adventage over Keller.Plus Keller is not that fast so hes not going to be able to compete well with NFL linebackers.Even though Davis may not be a great blocker he is still the better player and will be a good player in the NFL
Bio1590 said 03/09, 09:33 PM
You realize Keller was also a WR in high school too, right?
Are you just pulling things out of your *** now? Keller doesn't have speed? Excuse me, who's the man who had the fastest 40 at the combine? Oh yeah, Keller with a 4.55, and some timed him at 4.49.
I know the combine should be taken with a grain of salt, but Keller was the fastest TE, had the highest vertical, the farthest broad jump, was 2nd in Bench Press reps (had 2 more than Davis), the 2nd best 3-Cone Drill, the best 20-yard shuttle, and the 4th best 60 yard shuttle.
Also, those numbers lie. Davis was without a doubt USC's #1 receiving threat this year. Keller wasn't.
Also, it's not like Keller is tiny. 6'2" 242 pounds isn't bad at all.
In fact, some predictions have Keller moving back to WR in the NFL. Davis? Not at all.
Comments (27)
I wanted to say Cottam but everyone would be like "omg omg omg inexperience vote left!"
Bio1590 | 03/09/08, 09:12 PM
Report Offensive Commentgood pick,i was chosing between Keller or Davis
Ny | 03/09/08, 09:13 PM
Report Offensive CommentI'm waiting for the arguments until I see arguments.
dyhard is Modern Guilt | 03/09/08, 09:20 PM
Report Offensive CommentI'm waiting for the arguments until I see arguments.
dyhard is Yovani Gallardo | 03/09/08, 09:20 PM
Untill I vote.
dyhard is Modern Guilt | 03/09/08, 09:20 PM
Report Offensive CommentWow, that isn't good.
dyhard is Modern Guilt | 03/09/08, 09:21 PM
Report Offensive CommentIsn't Dustin Keller an AWFUL blocker? But he isn't slow.
Lifer: A Special Boy | 03/09/08, 09:29 PM
Report Offensive Commenthttp://youtube.com/watch?v=28fZ0_-q1bA
Tell me he's slow now.
Lifer: A Special Boy | 03/09/08, 09:32 PM
Report Offensive CommentI meant Keller had the fast 40 time for a TE >_>
Whoops, haha
Bio1590 | 03/09/08, 09:33 PM
Report Offensive Comment"Isn't Dustin Keller an AWFUL blocker? But he isn't slow."
I wouldn't say AWFUL, but given Purdue's system he wasn't required to block a whole hell of a lot
Bio1590 | 03/09/08, 09:34 PM
Report Offensive CommentAmong the top rated TEs, he's still one of the worst.
Lifer: A Special Boy | 03/09/08, 09:37 PM
Report Offensive CommentJermichael Finley out of Texas.
Okay, maybe not, but Texas is one of my favorite schools, so I had to say him.
Big M... | 03/09/08, 09:38 PM
Report Offensive CommentVernon Davis wasn't known for his blocking.
Hell, I remember when the NFL Network was highlighting the 49ers training camp two years ago and their TE coach started to have a fit because Davis didn't know the blocking fundamentals.
Bio1590 | 03/09/08, 09:40 PM
Report Offensive CommentWhen did Vernon Davis become an elite TE?
Lifer: A Special Boy | 03/09/08, 09:44 PM
Report Offensive Comment. . .I was talking about the draft dude.
You're saying Keller should be knocked down because he's never been required to be a great blocker.
I'm saying Davis wasn't a great blocker coming into the draft either.
Bio1590 | 03/09/08, 09:45 PM
Report Offensive Commenthttp://youtube.com/watch?v=28fZ0_-q1bA
Tell me he's slow now.
LIFER: Proof is in the Pudding | 03/09/08, 09:32 PM
He isn't slow according to that video.
dyhard is Modern Guilt | 03/09/08, 09:50 PM
Report Offensive CommentWhen was he ever regarded as slow?
I personally found the combine great when they were showing TEs. Mayock pretty much called everything Keller did (as in winning the 40-yard dash, winning the vertical jump, etc.).
Also, TEs amaze me. Cottam is a monster. Almost 6'8" and a 4.6 40 time. WHAT THE ****!?
Bio1590 | 03/09/08, 09:53 PM
Report Offensive CommentJenna Haze...that girl has a tight end :-)
Jimmer69 IS Darth Caedus! | 03/09/08, 10:24 PM
Report Offensive Comment>_>
Totally unnecessary
Bio1590 | 03/09/08, 10:26 PM
Report Offensive Commenti swear i just heard that joke on TV today Jimmer. what a coincidence.
Nomarfan: Vacation | 03/09/08, 10:28 PM
Report Offensive CommentI remember reading it when the whole Romo-Simpson-Witten (as the third wheel) went to Mexico story surfaced.
Well Simpson having a tight end >______>
Bio1590 | 03/09/08, 10:33 PM
Report Offensive CommentAdd a comment
Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines