Community

Goodell: Welcome Back Peters! won the Throwdown.

Goodell: Welcome Back Peters!

vs

Big Ben68

Throwndowns: 932
Record: 549 - 336 - 47
NFL Headquarters, NY
All Throwdowns
2
Votes
Throwndowns: 42
Record: 38 - 4 - 0
Richmond, VA
All Throwdowns
10
Votes

The TOP 5 QB's to never win a SB!


IN NO ORDER. These are the top 5 guys and NO ORDER
1) Jim Kelly
2) Dan Marino
3) Fran Tarketon
4) Warren Moon
5) Dan Fouts
IN NO ORDER!


I guess I'll just make an order to this, seeing as I have no idea what you mean and I really feel like making an argument instead of allowing this to sit here unattended. Let's do it!

Okay, IN AN ORDER:
1) Jim Kelly would have to be up here because he went to four consecutive Super Bowls and lost to NFC East team after NFC East team. He just couldn't seem to win it. He had great stats over his career and played with another Hall of Famer in Thurman Thomas and his coach Marv Levy who is now the GM for the Bills. The closest he ever got to a ring was against the Giants in 1990 when his kicker missed the game winning field goal in the closing seconds. Very unfortunate for a great player. The next closest time was against the Cowboys, but the ???Boys made a huge second half comeback to win the Super Bowl 30-13 (13-6 at Halftime).

Next four coming soon.


Wow, you let it sit there unattended for all of 10 minutes. If you wanted to comment, then you should have let some one else take the throwdown and then you could comment. I dont get easy wins....15-31-1....thats a whole lot of easy wins huh????

Comments (24)

Most Recent Comment Add Comment RSS

What is there really to argue in this?

Report Offensive Comment

im with ben there is nothing to disagree about unless your just trying to get one of thouse cheap wins

Report Offensive Comment

I'm with both Big Ben68 and mizzy. There is no point to this throwdown because Jim Kelly, Dan Marino, Fran Tarkenton, Warren Moon, and Dan Fouts never won a Super Bowl. Trying for an easy win aren't you Roger Goodell

Report Offensive Comment

Wow!!!!!!!!!!! Nice ****.

Report Offensive Comment

Then why take the trhowdown?? Leave it up there for a day or two, see if anyone disagrees. Thats what throwdowns are about right?? If you cant argue it, then dont take it?? I dont get cheap wins there mizzy......look at my record!

Report Offensive Comment

No, I want to try and argue this...and I've submitted an argue and I'm waiting for you because I don't have enough characters to write even two of my overviews into the argument.

Report Offensive Comment

This is ridiculous..... Big Ben should argue or forfit. Let some one who actually want to throwdown make a comment. Im acutally offended that you think i want an easy win. If you look at any of my throwdowns, i have never taken the easy win!

Report Offensive Comment

I never even thought that you were trying to get an easy win. I POSTED A D*MN ARGUMENT!! Can you not read?

Report Offensive Comment

What the **** are you talking about? Make an argument and don't complain! I made an actual argument and you come back with that!?!?

Report Offensive Comment

Um....I agree that its rediculous, but that being said, how can Marino not be first on the list? The argument isn't "quarterback who came closest but didn't get it," the question is "who is the greatest who didn't get it," and that's Marino.

Report Offensive Comment

I think it is Kelly because he had four shots, but still couldn't get it done. Marino had one shot and nearly had it, but the Niners D put the crunch on him in the second half. And I was actually going to argue this, but then he forfeited...I'm still trying to figure out why!

Report Offensive Comment

Why talk about guys who couldnt get it done in the big game?

Have a throwdown about Namath, Montana, Elway, Brady, Manning, Young, Aikman, Bradshaw, Starr, etc.

Report Offensive Comment

Maybe to do something different?

Report Offensive Comment

if your not looking for cheap wins y didnt you add Payton Manning? He just beat Dan Marinos touchdown record!

Report Offensive Comment

Because Peyton Manning just won a sb. But this is a cheap throwdown.

Report Offensive Comment

wow! WHAT A F**KING STUPID ARGUMENT!

Report Offensive Comment

What's a stupid f*cking argument?

Report Offensive Comment

wow that was weird

Report Offensive Comment
 

What was weird? Stop speaking in strangely incomplete complete sentences!!!!!

Report Offensive Comment

Add a comment

Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines


or cancel

SI.com Photos

Faces at the U.S. Open
Back in Time: September 5
Former Athletes Turned Politicians
Visit SI.com for more photo galleries

SI.com Top 10 Headlines

Visit SI.com for more stories