FanNation - The Republic of Sport

GO*Jord on a 18-2-6 run*CANUKS said 03/27, 09:09 PM
well, you have a pretty good list, so i have on difference:

PF - Tim Duncan - Karl "Mailman" Malone

GOOD LUCK!

GO*Jord on a 18-2-6 run*CANUKS said 03/28, 03:57 PM
So your going to change your pick after your first argument? Whatever, Ill compare both then

In your title, you said FANTASY team, so all of those All Star selections and championships mean nothing at all.

Karl Malone vs. Tim Duncan - Since this is a FANTASY comparison, stats should be the thing being used for this, so here it goes. (All stats are career and per game)

Karl "Mailman" Malone:

Points: 25.0
Rebounds: 10.1
Assists: 3.6
Field Goal %: .516
Free Throw %: .742
3 Point %: .274
Blocks: 0.8
Steals: 1.4

Tim Duncan:

Points: 21.7
Rebounds: 11.9
Assists: 3.2
Field Goal %: .508
Free Throw%: .684
3 Point %: .192
Blocks: 2.4
Steals: 0.8

All of these stats are generic in most fantasy leagues, and as you can see Malone wins every single category except for rebounds and blocks. Now, If I had to pick the best team for a season possible, I would take Duncan over Malone anytime, but since this is for a fantasy team, statistics are the main thing to look at, and if you look at them, you can clearly see that Malone is more valuable to a fantasy then Duncan

* Kareem Abdul-Jabber vs. Wilt Chamberlain next argument

GO*Jord on a 18-2-6 run*CANUKS said 03/29, 05:13 PM
Kareem Abdul-Jabber vs. Wilt Chamberlain - Well, I should technically not be making this comparison, but you changed your pick in your second argument, so here it goes. Again, since this is fantasy, I'll go to the stats to help me out here. (All stats are career and per game)

Wilt Chamberlain:

Points: 30.1
Rebounds: 22.9
Assists: 4.4
Field Goal %: .540
3 Point %: N/A
Free Throw %: .511
Blocks: N/A
Steals: N/A

Kareem Abdul-Jabber:

Points: 24.6
Rebounds: 11.2
Assists: 3.6
Field Goal %: .559
Free Throw %: .721
3 Point %: .056
Blocks: 2.6
Steals: 0.9

(* blocks, steals and three point % were not calculated in Wilt's days)

So, Wilt wins this 3-2. This also includes the best rebound-per-game total (22.9), and second best point-per-game total (30.1), only .002 behind the all-time leader, Michael Jordan (30.12). Also, although he lost the Field Goal % category, he does have the two top field goal percentages in season of All-Time, so he did have the capability to put up a huge number in the category for a fantasy season