Throwdowns > Completed

Views
10
Comments
31
  • April 29, 2008 10:38 AM ET

NMI Tourney III - Round IV (Semifinals) - Should FINA rescind its approval of Speedo's LZR Racer?

Bigalke (104-35-15) vs Porkins (138-13-1)
7
Votes
8
Votes
7
Votes
8
Votes


Swimsuit maker Speedo revealed a revolutionary new suit design in New York earlier this year, with phenom Michael Phelps helping introduce the new product. This suit, the LZR Racer, is designed to further reduce drag as a swimmer cuts through the water. Already, over 20 world records have been broken by swimmers wearing this suit in the three months since its release.

FINA, the international governing body of competitive swimming, approved the suit for competitive use... but some opponents have called for FINA to withdraw this approval, asserting that swimmers in the LZR Racer have a competitive advantage over swimmers in other suits.

Isn't that what advancing new technologies is all about? Like cyclists testing time-trial bicycle positioning in a wind tunnel to reduce drag, swimmers should have the same right to advance the technology of their sport. Swimming can only benefit from new technologies which allow these athletes to do even more with their bodies.

A suit can only do so much. Not even Speedo can quantify how much the LZR Racer reduces drag. FINA should keep approving Speedo's new design. In the end, swimmers gotta swim, and LZR Racers gotta race...


Good. It appears I am left to argue against the suit.

Generally, I favor technological progress, but every so often a sport is faced with an advancement that impacts the integrity of competition.

The Speedo LZR Racer is a marvel- its construction reduces drag and allows the swiimer to move more quickly through the water. In and of itself, it is merely an object- a tool to be used or ignored as a swimmer see fit.

The problem is that the suit is affecting the sport in a way that has never been seen. Are you ready for this?

Swimmers wearing the Speedo suit have broken more than TWENTY WORLD RECORDS since FEBRUARY!

Now I'm all for technology, but clearly the suit itself is having an extreme inpact on the swimming as a competitive sport.

Opponents of the LZR say that the suit is having too great of an effect on races.

If this suit is used in the Olympics by some, but not all racers, the results will forever be viewed with an asterisk.

When it's the technology, rather than the athlete himself (or herself) that is determining outcomes, then that technology must be regulated, or at least studied in greater detail before use.

More in #2.


One thing to keep in mind is that the "20 world records" number is slightly misleading... because athletes continue to best their own records and shave hundredths of seconds off. Second, it is not as though twenty scrubs put on the suit and suddenly became Olympic-caliber athletes -- the people breaking records with these suits were already some of the world's top talents BEFORE they ever put on a LZR Racer...

For example, the 200-m backstroke record fell to Kristy Coventry, the 2004 Olympic gold medalist. Alain Bernard, who set and reset the 100m freestyle record at the 2008 European Championships, was the 2007 gold medalist at the same tournament... WITHOUT a LZR Racer.

Who, anyway, is clamoring to have the Racer banned for competition? It is not racers; it is other swimsuit companies. And yet, even as they complain, they copy the design...

Arena International has spawned the first copycat. Others are sure to follow as companies realize the benefits of compression fabrics & unexposed seam welds. Other revolutionary suits have come and gone, each contributing more to swimsuit technology. Progress must continue forward; Speedo has inspired a new era in design for everyone...


Yes, it is the top racers who are breaking records, but find me another time in swimming history when 20 world records have been broken in only 2 months.

World records are NOT simple accomplishments, and the fact that so many have fallen since the advent of the LZR surely indicates the effect that it- and not JUST the talent of the swimmers- is having on competition.

You ask: "Who, anyway, is clamoring to have the Racer banned for competition?"

Not just rival companies, I assure you. Italy's Head Coach Alberto Castagnetti is staunchly opposed.

"This is going down a very dangerous road. It removes the purely competitive aspect of the sport and puts outside factors into play. Swimming has always been based on ability...It's like technological doping. It's not in the spirit of the sport."

-Castagnetti to the AP


Swimmers themselves have doubts as well.

"I don't know how to quantify how much faster it's going to make me, but I do know it will reduce drag, and for the other athletes not wearing a Speedo in that race, they are at a disadvantage,"

-World record holder Natalie Coughlin.

Limited space, but you get the idea. The LZR suit has crossed a line.


A new revolution in athletic technology must start somewhere. As I said before, this is not the first time full-body skinsuits have been introduced to skepticism and fears of unfair advantages. But technology cannot advance unless SOMEBODY releases it on the market and gets its copycats...

Speedo released the suit, & already companies are clamoring to replicate the results. By the Olympics, most every swim company should have their own version of this suit on the market for their branded athletes. Arena International already has copied the concept... more are sure to follow when they realize the benefits of this new technology.

Sports technology is always advancing... & those who are sponsored by the first company to release any technology enjoy the advantages of that technology before their competitors. But this is a worthwhile technology -- & anything worthwhile is destined to become widespread quickly as more athletes recognize the benefits of seamless suit technology and compression fabric.

Any company can create similar suits... and they are already in the works. Speedo has stimulated a new, faster AND fairer age as everyone jumps on the bandwagon...


"Any company can create similar suits... " I agree, but this isn't about a potential monoploy.

Look, I know very few people CARE about swimming. So let's put this in perspective.

Here's what one designer has to say about the LZR:

"That [core stabilizer] does two things. One, it reduces form drag...making you as tubeless a shape as possible...so it squashes things in. And two, it helps maintain the athlete's body position in the water."

-Speedo researcher Deb Yeomans

Ok- so the suit makes it EASIER to stay in position, which means less work for the athlete. It also CHANGES the athletes body to be better suited to the sport.

Where else have we heard about players using external means to physically change their bodies and improve performance? Oh yeah...didn't work out too well there either.

If there were a laser-guided bat, would MLB ok it? Would the PGA accept a golf club that helps keep your swing in perfect form?

Yes, technology is always adavancing. But it's not always good. Or allowable.

Coaches question it. Athletes question it. FINA needs to recognize the controversy, and at the very least take it off the table for the 2008 games.

April 29, 2008  10:38 AM ET

Sorry I'm late in starting this, Porkins... I look forward to a great debate!

April 29, 2008  11:58 AM ET

as always.

April 29, 2008  12:32 PM ET

Speedos FTL...always. I mean, come on, who wants to see that?

April 29, 2008  12:49 PM ET

I can't wait until the first Great White Shark swimsuit is invented. The swimmer is inserted into the stomach of the shark, the shark swims away, then the shark is caught and the swimmer is removed from the shark now the owner of every single swimming record known to man.

There has to be a line somewhere. I don't know if that line falls before or after this suit, however.

April 29, 2008  01:06 PM ET

And you sir (The Ram) have just crossed it.

April 29, 2008  01:07 PM ET

I don't know where I was going with that. Either way, Great White Sharks are freakin' awesome.

April 29, 2008  01:08 PM ET

Wait...I have an idea.....

April 29, 2008  01:17 PM ET

Much better.

April 29, 2008  01:44 PM ET

Nice suit, RobertMenn.

April 29, 2008  02:15 PM ET

Thanks. Just pick up up from Academy Sports and Outdoors.

April 29, 2008  02:20 PM ET

Now THAT is dedication to a TD. Very nice. And I'll bet you CAN swim faster now.

April 29, 2008  03:59 PM ET

Oh, I can. Clocked me in at a little over 30mph in short bursts.

April 30, 2008  11:49 AM ET

lol @ no votes.......

April 30, 2008  04:03 PM ET

Everyone loves swimming.

April 30, 2008  04:08 PM ET

Wow, these NMI events sure are exciting. I mean gosh, look at all the votes.

April 30, 2008  04:11 PM ET

come on tracy! you broke the tie!

April 30, 2008  04:12 PM ET

*cain stomps away*

April 30, 2008  04:13 PM ET

I think it should be allowed....Nike isnt banned from the NBA cause thier shoes make you run faster, or jump higher.

April 30, 2008  04:14 PM ET

I can't wear speedos, there's just no room for all i got goin' on down there.....

 
April 30, 2008  04:17 PM ET

Vote <--------

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


Leaderboard

  Fan W L T Win %
1 DetroitFan* BS: Start Stanton! 132 9 7 91.6%
2 Porkins 138 13 1 91.1%
3 Baun-ded=PUCKHEAD 52 5 1 90.5%
4 The Ram 138 17 4 88.1%
5 Foosball 70 9 2 87.7%
6 Philly-- www.sportsnoise.com 74 11 4 85.4%
7 Hyped78 114 19 5 84.4%
8 Dookie: Here We Go Steelers 117 19 8 84.0%
9 [The] Coach 97 18 5 82.9%
10 BSchwartz07 129 27 6 81.5%

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Witness: Pacman was yelling at girlfriend
    Views
    12685
    Comments
    1786
  2. 2
    Red flag on Teixeira
    Views
    8875
    Comments
    472
  3. 3
    Why Andruw Jones won't join Dodgers
    Views
    40551
    Comments
    81
  4. 4
    Browns DE trash talks Giants RB
    Views
    7390
    Comments
    77
  5. 5
    Huskies eyeing Mizzou's Pinkel?
    Views
    7286
    Comments
    69

Weekly Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9

Message Boards

  1. MMA > Fight Club

    Would you rather see Arlovski…
    Views
    561
    Replies
    6
  2. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    Around the Table
    Views
    116
    Replies
    52
  3. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    Who's got the best tailgate…
    Views
    57
    Replies
    13

Blogs