FanNation

(Cincy) Eddie Vedder said 05/10, 08:00 PM
1B-Tony Perez
2B-Joe Morgan
3B-Pete Rose(he played 3rd at one point
SS-Dave Concepcion
LF-Sam Crawford
CF-Ken Griffey Jr.
RF-Frank Robinson
C-Johnny Bench

5 SP's

SP-Christy Mathewson
SP-Tom Seaver(I know you'll have him too)
SP-Eppa Rixey
SP-Rube Marquard
SP-Mordecai "three finger" Brown
RP-John Franco

Manager-Sparky Anderson

4 utility players
Sam Crawford
Kiki Cuyler
Al Simmons
Edd Roush

(Cincy) Eddie Vedder said 05/11, 05:13 PM
Tony Perez vs Eddie Murray,you have the edge in stats there.

Joe Morgan and Jeff Kent are similar in stats,Morgan won 2 MVP's to Kent's 1 breakout season in 2000,and Morgan had 689 Stolen bases.

Pete Rose vs Howard Johnson:Self explanitory

Dave Concepcion over Jose Reyes because Reyes hasn't played long,Concepcion was the leagues probable second best SS(Ozzie Smith).

Johnny Bench: 267 avg ,1376 RBIs,476 SLG,342 OBP,10 consecutive gold gloves,arguable best defensive catcher of all time
Gary Carter: 262 avg,439 SLG 3 gold gloves 324 HRs 335 OBP (forgot RBI)

Sam Crawford had excellent stats in the dead ball era:309 3B,309 avg,458 2B,452 SLG,362 OBP,366 SB,1525 RBI,1391 runs

Duke Snider:85 3B,295 avg,358 2B,(he had better slg),OBP was close,Snider might have had edge,1333 RBI,,1259 runs

Now the interesting one,The say hey kid,vs the kid.

Jr has 63 less homers in a few less seasons.They are both two of the greatest defensive players of all time.They both were 5 too players,but Mays had 2 prime years taken away from him during the war.

Frank Robinson blows away Richie Ashburn in the stats.

Pitching in next,(not enough room)

(Cincy) Eddie Vedder said 05/12, 09:19 PM
I'll just let this go on to your next arg.