FanNation - The Republic of Sport

*LSU* is back said 05/28, 03:04 PM
C- *Yogi Berra, 358 Homers, 15 All-Star Games Three-time MVP (1951, '54, '55)

1B- Lou Gehrig, .340 AVG., 493 Homers, 1,995 RBIS
Two-Time MVP (1927, '36)

2B- Rogers Hornsby, 358 AVG., Hit .400 Three Times
Two-time Triple Crown winner (1922, '25)

3B- Mike Schmidt, 548 Homers, 10 Gold Gloves
Three-time MVP (1980, '81, '86)

SS-Honus Wagner, 3,420 Hits, 723 Steals, But I think that A-Rod will be here when he retires.

OF-Babe Ruth, .342 AVG., 714 Homers (3rd all-time)

OF-Hank Aaron 755 Homers (second all-time), 3,771 Hits
1957 MVP .

OF-*Willie Mays, 660 Homers, 12 Golden Gloves Two-time MVP (1954, '65)

DH- *Barry Bonds, All-time HR leader

Starting Pitchers

Nolan Ryan, all-time MLB leader in strike outs

Walter Johnson, 417 Wins, 3,509 Strikeouts
Won 20 games 12 times, 30 games twice

Warren Spahn, 363 WINS, 20-Game winner 13 Times
Most wins by a lefty, 1957 Cy Young Award

Roger Clemens*, 348 Wins, 4,604 Strikeouts
Seven Cy Youngs (1986, '87, '91, '97, '98, '01, '04)


Cy Young, Cy Young, PITCHER
511 Wins, 30-Game Winner Five Times, Winningest pitcher in baseball history .

Close- Dennis Eckersly not enough room for his stats

*LSU* is back said 05/29, 12:48 PM
Johnny Bench Vs Yogi Berra

You failed to mention that Berra had more league MVP's, and more all-star games.

And I don't see how it's relevant that some old geezer told another old geezer 50 years ago that he was a hall of famer, I bet Yogi Berra was told that he was a future hall of famer every other day.

Ted Williams Vs. Willie Mays

First of all I would like to point out that Ted Williams only hit over .400 once, also I seriously doubt Ted Williams had anywhere near 12 gold gloves and that's the main reason I gave Mays the edge here, because of the fact that he was a better power hitter, and a much better fielder.

*LSU* is back said 05/30, 10:15 PM
"Frank Thomas or Barry Bonds
I would like to point out that Barry Bonds is not a DH. Frank Thomas is the all time DH home run leader. Bonds didnt play DH so he doesnt count. "
Yeah but if he would of played in the Al we all know that he would of been a DH, and his whole time in San Fran he was basicly a glorified DH.

Also when congress finds some DNA samples or roder Confesses I will admit that Madux was better, but until then I would prefer to stay in my own fantasy world in which Rodger never took steroids and never had sex with someone my age.


I beleive that playing more seasons should contribute to your status because that proves that Berra had better longevity and that is a decideing factor when major leaguers are scouted.