FanNation - The Republic of Sport

Cheezhead: Is Most Likely Gone said 06/27, 09:25 PM
Listen everyone, my CPU was lagging in our original throwdown so when I submitted my 2nd argument it also forfeited me somehow, don't ask me how though. So Cincy and I have decided to re-do this. I told the mods about the other one, maybe they can delete the throwdown. Anyway:



We'll list first so we have two even shots at one-another.

I'm going with Lawrence Taylor.

Good luck.

Cheezhead: Is Most Likely Gone said 06/27, 09:33 PM
The easiest way to show who played better is stats. So here's some numbers for you.

Lawrence Taylor:

13 seasons
1,088 tackles
142 sacks
9 interceptions

Mike Singletary:

12 seasons
1,488 tackles
19 sacks
7 interceptions


Sure, Singletary had more tackles (by 400, I'll let you decide how huge that is), but LT killed in the sacks column and had more picks along the way. But sometimes stats don't tell the whole story. That's when we get to accomplishments:


Lawrence Taylor:

10-time Pro Bowler
10-time All Pro
2-time Super Bowl Champion
Member of NFL 75th Anniversary All-time team
Member of 1980's All-Decade team
1981 Defensive Rookie of the Year
1986 NFL MVP
1986 Bert Bell Award
2-time NFC Defensive Player of the Year
3-time AP Defensive Player of the Year
Hall of Fame Inductee


Mike Singletary

10-Time Pro Bowler
9-Time All-Pro
One-Time Super Bowl Champ
2-time AP Defensive Player of the Year
1980's All-Decade Team
Hall of Fame Inductee


So, if the stats didn't favor my boy Lawrence Taylor, the achievements and accomplishments definitely give him the edge. Your turn, Cincy.

Cheezhead: Is Most Likely Gone said 06/28, 11:56 PM
If sacks, picks, and tackles don't really matter, what's left to tell us who the best linebacker is? You look for tackles and sacks in all of your linebackers, sometimes picks in certain ones. But since these guys weren't into interceptions, you can assume tackles and sacks are the deciding factor.

LT had the killer instinct. And you can see that when you look at his career sack column. He had so many sacks, and that is what distinguishes him from the rest of the all-time linebackers.

Taylor is also called by many the greatest defensive player of all time. I threwdown before in that subject saying White, and my opponent said LT. He won. In every other one that I saw, LT was used. I don't remember seeing Singletary too much. That might not seem like it matters, but a bunch of fans saying the same thing probably know what they're talking about.

Anyway, you can still see LT is better past the stat column. Just look at his list of accomplishments and achievments. Yes, Mike over there does have an impressive list, but when you look at LT's it's like comparing the Mac to the PC in those commercials that drive us crazy.

LT is the best linebacker of that era, and of all time.