NCshvDavid Throwndowns: 1000 won the Throwdown.
Throwndowns: 1021
Record: 746 - 228 - 47
Princeton , LA
All Throwdowns
4
Votes
Throwndowns: 153
Record: 134 - 15 - 4
Pittsburgh , PA
All Throwdowns
6
Votes

30 Teams . . . 30 TDs 3 Rules - Minny 1 challenge


1. No stealing my idea
2. No Pushing- pick a side and argue
3. If you don't LIKE the TD concept- then go start your own TDs and get the SMURF offa mine.

Will the W/L of the Minnesota improve or Decline

My Pick IMPROVE


18 hours and no one is up to this TD? Well, I won't hide from a challenge.


The Vikings will Decline.

How much better will the Vikings running game be in 2008 than it was in 2007? They had the number 1 rushing attack in the league and they STILL only got 8 wins.

They had the number 1 rushing defense in the league and still only got 8 wins.

They got every lucky break possible scoring 8 special teams and defensive touchdowns and still only got 8 wins.

Their entire O-Line and D-Line were healthy and almost every starter played 16 games (Their RG missed 4, LDE missed 1, and RDE missed 5), and they still only got 8 wins.

What does that say about the rest of their team?

How can they possibly improve in these areas over what they did in 2007? It took herculean efforts by these units just to drag the team to 8 wins.

They had the worst secondary in football, and drafted a rookie corner to fix it. Yeah, that'll work.

Their starting LT, Bryant McKinnie, is facing 4 felony charges for bashing a bouncer over the head with a metal pole. Left Tackle isn't important, is it?

Of course not! Because Dr. Z has them in the Super Bowl so they have to do great, right?


Ok, First I want to say this was intended for someone else, who ASKED me to challange them on it when I got to the NFC north.

and then RAN like a COWARD from it.

Oh Well.

On to RAM/David part 7!

First off the Offense

QB- Jackson has a Full Year in a new offense under his belt- plus has an improved Receiving threats out there. Jackson was also 8-4 as a starter. - They do have Gus Frerotte, who is as old as Stowe but a much better QB incase they need him.

RB- Peterson and Taylor both had a MASSIVE yards per carry average behind that line- A better management by the coaches should keep both healthy

WR- Berrian caught 71 passes for 951 yards in that wide open Bears offense- after years chasing Grossmans passes- Berrian is going to think he;s got Aikman back there at QB. and watch Rice there as well.

OL- Since he got out of the Love Boat scandal and did even have to pick up trash on his lawn- I am not worried about McKinnie missing any NFL time.

Like the Chargers this team started 1-3 and then went to 2-5 before getting hot. This season they build on that- they play the Colts week 2- If they win that . . .

Dr Z might get one right.


Tarvaris Jackson, at his best, is one of the worst starting QB's in the NFL. You can't hide from that. Should injuries hit any part of their line or their running backs (very real possibility), do you really trust a guy with 11 career TD's and a 69.0 passer rating to carry the team?

The addition of Berrian makes their receiving corps improve from god-awful to, what? Just plain old awful? And going from Griese/Grossman to Jackson is a DOWNGRADE both statistically and in reality. Jackson = Aikman? Please.

Their first 5 games are at Green Bay, Indy, Carolina, at Tennessee, and at Nawlins. At best they're looking at 2-3, more likely 1-4.

The Vikings are appealing to the masses because they fit all the cliche's of what a "good team" should do. But cliche's don't win games. #1 rush D is irrelevant if everyone can just throw at will on you. That they were #1 in both rush O and rush D in 2007 and STILL finished 8-8 should be enough proof of that. Any NFL team could play 11 men on the line of scrimmage and finish #1 in rush D...and lose every game by 100 points.

"they play the Colts week 2- If they win that"

Satan would need ear muffs and a parka.


I will be MORE than happy to trust my offense to a guy that is 8-4 in his first year as a starter - lets keep in mind that in his first year as a starter Steve Young went 5-5 as a starter

Now I am not saying TJ is going to be Young- but even hall of famers struggle the first year they get the reins

TJ tossed 9 TDs and 12 Picks
Rex Tossed 4TDs and 7 Picks
Brian went 10 Tds and 12 Picks

How exactly is this off base - considering Brian is at Year TEN and Rex is in year FIVE and NEITHER are getting better!

TJ is at the end of year ONE

So Yes I will say Berrian is going to have ANY hope for a DECENT QB - it will be in Minny MUCH more than in Chi-town


Lets also add that they added Jared Allen to a decent D and he is ONLY 26- entering the PRIME years as a speed rusher- Minny's D is not that complicated- and the fact that the Vikings have a MUCH better coach than they do in KC- is only going to help his acceration.

Indy in week 2

1. I said IF
2. Harrison and Manning may not be 100%
3. They are at HOME
4. Anything can happen - did you see the Super Bowl?


Jared Allen - I can't decide what is more likely:

1. After having a career best season in his contract year (coincidence?) and getting a dump truck full of money, he follows Shaun Alexander and 100 other NFL players by never giving an ounce of effort for the rest of his career.

2. He gets his FOURTH DUI and the MANDATORY year-long suspension that comes with it now that he's on the "Love Boat" team and finally has enough money to pipe Jack Daniels into his house instead of water.

As for McKinnie: "Love Boat" happened under Paul Tagliabue. 4-felony bouncer clubbing? Under Sheriff Goodell. Big difference.

While it is true that even HOF QB's stuggle early in their careers, guess what?

Sucky QB's that never amount to anything in the NFL struggle, too.

For every HOF QB YOU have that sucked then succeeded, I have 500 that sucked then sucked worse. Watch:

Tim Couch first season: 2447 yards, 15 TD's, 13 Int's, 73.2 QB rating.
Joey Harrington, David Carr, Akili Smith, Jim Druckenmiller, etc.

You stick with your "anything can happen" and "Jackson for Canton" fantasy land. I'll stay here in reality where the Vikings are a team with glaring, unaddressed flaws.

** GIVEN that BRETT IS NOT THE QB**

Report Offensive Comment

Let's do one on the Dolphins... (hahahahaha)

Report Offensive Comment

I'm waiting on tampa. Feel free to challenge me directly David.

Report Offensive Comment

Tampa... Decline

Report Offensive Comment

Detroit - Major Improve . . . ?

Report Offensive Comment

Dammit...why can't I vote left yet?

Report Offensive Comment

HAHAHA Brett....LMFAO! Improve! <-------------

Report Offensive Comment

Kinda tough to argue against Minny improving on 8-8 in a weak division.

Report Offensive Comment

LOL... they should be good this season, no doubt. Word from some minny vets were that TJ was looking better and more confident in the minicamps. They got to 8-8 despite his poor performance and the ubiquitous WR drops...I expect them to dominate with his increased performance.

Report Offensive Comment

Sorry...I agree...gotta decline

Report Offensive Comment

I seriously see them as a legitimate 11-win team.

Report Offensive Comment

You're probably going to have to get more specific A throwdowner named NCshvDavid. I believe its a consensus that the Vikings will improve, seeing as how they signed one of the best defensive players and upgraded their receiving corps (not to mention underachived last year.

Maybe pick how many wins better they will be?

Report Offensive Comment

Wow.....outstanding opening salvo from Ram...

Report Offensive Comment

the pick is to improve, but Ram's opening argument is very strong

Report Offensive Comment

David is sneakily going for easy wins. How can anyone say the Chargers will win only 10 games next year, or that the Vikings will win less than 8?

Report Offensive Comment

David is sneakily going for easy wins. How can anyone say the Chargers will win only 10 games next year, or that the Vikings will win less than 8?

NYGiantsSBXLIICHAMPS


Idjit, I was ASKED to CHALLANGE someone on this one- 30 teams, 30 TDs- and uh since there are 32 teams in the NFL- and I am doing a better w/l series

you would think ONE I am NOT doing is the Pats

any IDEA who the other one might be? Maybe a team that IS getting better by 99.9% of people? Huh? Maybe?

But some one ASKED for it, so they GOT it.

Report Offensive Comment

I don't think Jackson is as bad as made out to be...I'm leaning left at this point.

Report Offensive Comment

Everyone needs to knock off the easy win accusations. That's crap.

Also please vote based on the arguments presented rather than preconceived notions.

Report Offensive Comment

going right by a slight margin.

Hanging the team improving on Jackson/berrian just doesn't do it for me.

Report Offensive Comment
 

It seems like you've done Minny 2 or 3 times already

Report Offensive Comment

Add a comment

Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines


or cancel