FanNation

This is not the Pimp you want said 07/24, 10:02 PM
Not a WHOLE lot of wiggle room here

Paja
18.2 ppg 5.0rpg 1.9 apg 0.1 bpg 1.0 spg

Walker
17.5 ppg 7.7rpg 3.5 apg 0.5 bpg 1.2 spg

So I'll trade 0.7ppg for 2.7rpg, 1.6apg, 0.4 bpg 0.2spg

My OTHER pick is at PF

Shareef Abdur-Rahim

18.1 ppg 7.5rpg 0.8bpg 2.5apg 1.0spg

O'Neal

14.4 ppg 7.7rpg 1.9bpg 1.5apg 0.5spg

3.7 ppg 1.0 apg 0.5 spg I'll take over 0.2rpg and 1.1bpg

so there is 2 diff for you.

This is not the Pimp you want said 07/26, 01:38 PM
Jermaine O'Neal VS Shareef Abdur-Rahim

You state that O'Neal has played more playoff games that SAR had

Lets see, O'neal was drafted to the Wallace,Rider and Kenny Anderson Blazers- and sat on the bench- then got sent to the Pacers with Reggie Miller and Jalen Rose - until he developed

SAR went to that POWERHOUSE known as the Vancouver Grizzlies, then went to that Dynasty known as the Atlanta Hawks- then off to portland for a cup of coffee and now to the Kings- where he is admittedly the 3rd option on that team.

So who do YOU think had the harder road to his playoff games? O'neal got 20 games of Playoff XP while in portland averaging 10 minutes a game.

Lets breakdown the scoring shall we?

Years scoring LESS than 5ppg

4 years for O'Neal - That would be ZERO for SAR

Years scoring between 5-10 PPG

0 O'neal - only his final year playing only 6 games for SAR

Years scoring between 10-15 PPG

2 O'neal - and only his NEXT to last year for SAR

Years scoring between 15-20 PPG

2 O'neal - EIGHT YEARS for SAR - and SIX of those are 18-19 PPG

Years scoring between 20+ PPG

4 years compared to 2 years for SAR

as Far as D is concerned NEITHER have made the All D teams

This is not the Pimp you want said 07/26, 11:18 PM
Well I have 2 arguments left, and 2 people to argue.

Figured I'd go one at a time.

Peja vs Walker

Peja
18.2 ppg 5.0rpg 1.9 apg 0.1 bpg 1.0 spg

Walker
17.5 ppg 7.7rpg 3.5 apg 0.5 bpg 1.2 spg

Walker came into the ML Carr and Rick Pitino years- and with Peirce lead the Celtics to the Eastern Finals

Now you may think that Walker was only a scorer- but during the start of his career he was a much more complete player-

For example in 1997-98 NBA he was 12th in the MVP voting

Don;t sound like empty points to me

Peja on the other hand, was part of a MUCH more talented team in Sac-town and did JACK in the playoffs

Consider that 27% of all of Peja's shot attempts are 3s

Nothing like having a Forward hang around outside and bomb 3s

Let me ask you a question-

Who between the 2 has a top 10 finish in Rebounds?
That would be Walker


Who between the 2 has a top 10 finish in Steals
That would be Walker

Who has not one but TWO top 10 finishes in Points Per Game?

Peja has NONE of these- but he does have one top 10 finish

and is currently THIRD in TURNOVERS PCT- including leading the NBA last year.

Career wise- Walker is better across the board.