FanNation

I meant 1 return*

Bio1590 | 06/29/07, 10:40 PM

if drew was better how come he did not win rookie of the year or lead his team to 7 wins in a row ?

KentuckyFan#1 | 06/29/07, 10:44 PM

. . .Because everyone's on VY's jock including EA.

VY also fumbled 12 times, compared to MJD's 1.

And VY also barely completed 50% of his passes and threw more INTs than TDs.

Bio1590 | 06/29/07, 10:47 PM

im wit aliminumbatboy on this one, VY led his team out of their bad contention to almost playoff contenders, devon hester speaks for himself

THIS PAGE HAS BEEN HACKED | 06/29/07, 10:50 PM

And Drew contributed all year long. The NFl just likes to make QBs the ROY whenever they can, even if it is a reach to do so.

Fan...Favre Fan | 06/29/07, 10:50 PM

Drew set the record for most combined yards in a game by a rookie. He had 303 All-Purpose yards against Indy.

Bio1590 | 06/29/07, 10:56 PM

Based on individual stats alone, Jones-Drew crushes Young.

hyperRevue | 06/29/07, 11:02 PM

what about colston?

pHiLLy_FooTbALL | 06/29/07, 11:20 PM

MJD beat him in yards and TDs.

Bio1590 | 06/29/07, 11:28 PM

What!!!!!!Young would of made the playoffs if fisher would of started
him sooner

packer* BS | 06/29/07, 11:30 PM

As usual, no love for the big guys. Mangold stepped right in at center and led the Jets to the playoffs.

Devin Hester is a great kick returner, but he couldn't touch MJD or Bush for overall production.

As to VY, the most important stat is in the win column and the botttom line is he just wins baby.

mattmillen4president | 06/29/07, 11:48 PM

I find it funny that Hester had only 3 less TDs than Bush on 0 offensive touches.

Bio1590 | 06/30/07, 12:02 AM

I can't believe nobody has mentioned Marcus McNeill, left tackle for the Chargers. He paved the way for LT on the left side last year.

TimLincecum CY Young | 06/30/07, 12:06 AM

everyone knows that RB is THE EASIEST position for rookies, and QB is the hardest. I'm happy for Drew, but there's a reason VY was rookie of the year, and the first rookie QB pro bowler since Dan Marino...Because he was the BEST and will be the best qb in the league very soon. Now if Tenn will ever spend some money, maybe the team will actually contend again.

vedderisbetter | 06/30/07, 12:30 AM

. . .*looks at Young's 12 fumbles and 13 INTS*

Yeah boi.

</sarcasm>

Bio1590 | 06/30/07, 12:36 AM

and uh, vedder. . .MJD put up those numbers as the #2 RB. . .

Bio1590 | 06/30/07, 12:37 AM

colston all the way

tigerbait | 06/30/07, 12:37 AM

What other rookie was close to SCORING 16 TDs?
MJD had more TDs than any rookie(by a margin of 7).
He had the highest ypc last year for ANY RB with over 100 carries.
He had a higher yards per rec than Bush. He also had as many rec TDs as Bush while getting half the recs.
2nd in rookie rushing yards(while getting 60 less carries than addai-who had the help of peyton manning)
3rd in the NFL in kick returns
Tied for 3rd in scoring.

mikeyfarley | 06/30/07, 01:10 AM

On top of everything MJD did he wasn't even supposed to split time at RB his rookie year. He got a combined 4 carries his 1st 2 games. He still ended up out rushing Maroney and Bush. Getting more rec yards than addai and Maroney.

mikeyfarley | 06/30/07, 01:17 AM

Although MJD got to play the Colts twice, and that'll pad anyones stats.

mattmillen4president | 06/30/07, 01:49 AM