FanNation - The Republic of Sport

Please accept and argue. Dont ruin the TD by saying Vick hasnt done anything in Philly. Thats obvious but the man also hasnt been given much of an opportunity either.

You pretty much nailed this to me... I am thinking about it, and the only change I could really do off the top of my head is switch what team I'd think he's go to and use the same three teams. Possibly 2 other teams could be used but i might have a harder time arguing it. I will keep thinking and come up with an angle, if i get something prior to anyone accepting i will take it.

Good old Rawk.

I know a team that will that you didn't list.

I havent lost it yet, Rawk.

Took a brief hiatus and back with my latest.

Right has a way with words, but I have to go with the reasoning on the left.

I was also thinking Raiders...and Seattle.

Right? you picked Tampa one game after thier rookie they drafted this past offseason has his first start and threw a pretty good game upsetting Greenbay? Any team that uses a 1st round draft pick and has now started that player is a clear cut no... thye would be more inclined to give this guy some more proctection with upgrades in the O-line and give him more WR threats than replace a 1st round pick at QB with a Vick who has not played any significant role in the NFL in years and no one really knowing how much hes got left.

QUOTE(#7):

Originally posted 08:56 AM ET  11.10 by DP: RIP UGA VII

I was also thinking Raiders...and Seattle.

I was thinking the Raiders and SF(MAYBE), Seattle is not a bad pick either, however I see Vick wanting to stay on the east coast. but if i had to take this i would have switched clevland with oakland and picked buffalo as where he went because his mentor is probably trying to convince him to go there.

QUOTE(#9):

Originally posted 09:03 AM ET  11.10 by Rawkstar

I was thinking the Raiders and SF(MAYBE), Seattle is not a bad pick either, however I see Vick wanting to stay on the east coast. but if i had to take this i would have switched clevland with oakland and picked buffalo as where he went because his mentor is probably trying to convince him to go there.

His mentor? I was thinking Seattle because Hasselbeck is a decent QB when healthy, Wallace is a decent back-up, and Vick has played on Mora's team before. They didn't "get along great", but Vick is "a new man."

QUOTE(#8):

Originally posted 08:57 AM ET  11.10 by Rawkstar

Right? you picked Tampa one game after thier rookie they drafted this past offseason has his first start and threw a pretty good game upsetting Greenbay? Any team that uses a 1st round draft pick and has now started that player is a clear cut no... thye would be more inclined to give this guy some more proctection with upgrades in the O-line and give him more WR threats than replace a 1st round pick at QB with a Vick who has not played any significant role in the NFL in years and no one really knowing how much hes got left.

Vick is a back up.

QUOTE(#10):

Originally posted 09:07 AM ET  11.10 by DP: RIP UGA VII

His mentor? I was thinking Seattle because Hasselbeck is a decent QB when healthy, Wallace is a decent back-up, and Vick has played on Mora's team before. They didn't "get along great", but Vick is "a new man."

Yes his mentor... Tony Dungy.

Tony has already said himself that Buffalo is a "Dark Horse" landing spot for Vick next season. Since Dungy has much to do with why Vick is even in the NFL at all this season has a big impact over what Vick decides to do and probably finds that as the best team where he could land a starting position.

Seattle is not a bad choice, but I think Vick would prefer to stay on the east coast which he has said before due to family.(he is from VA)

STL could be an interesting fit, so would CLE, OAK and maybe SF. But if Vick wanted to join a team with any chance of winning and have a starting position I think Buffalo is that team.

TB was not a good choice in this TD to me and ultimately is why i voted for DJ, It would take some very compelling arguments to have me switch.

QUOTE(#11):

Originally posted 09:15 AM ET  11.10 by SillySal

Vick is a back up.

Thanks for the hot tip Quincy!!

Funny how all this buildup for Vick coming to Philly that he was going to enhance their offense and until I read this TD I forgot that he was back in the league. Shows how important he was...NOT. I guess this is a better punishment for him barely playing for a team that gets his hopes up on playing and finding out that he was never going to play more than 3-4 times a game.

QUOTE(#12):

Originally posted 09:19 AM ET  11.10 by Rawkstar

Yes his mentor... Tony Dungy.Tony has already said himself that Buffalo is a "Dark Horse" landing spot for Vick next season. Since Dungy has much to do with why Vick is even in the NFL at all this season has a big impact over what Vick decides to do and probably finds that as the best team where he could land a starting position.Seattle is not a bad choice, but I think Vick would prefer to stay on the east coast which he has said before due to family.(he is from VA)STL could be an interesting fit, so would CLE, OAK and maybe SF. But if Vick wanted to join a team with any chance of winning and have a starting position I think Buffalo is that team.TB was not a good choice in this TD to me and ultimately is why i voted for DJ, It would take some very compelling arguments to have me switch.

Good points. I was leaning towards Oakland but like you said Rawkstar, unless right makes some compelling arguments, I'm leaning left at the moment.

My list thoughts are Raiders, Buffalo..then Cleveland. I feel that the Raiders are desperate enough and would use Vick to light a fire under Russell. The Bill brought in TO so are clearly willing to take great risks to see rewards. And the Browns, well nothing has worked there in years. I just don't see the Rams as an organization that would want this.. I could be wrong. There are three arguments left and right has not said much yet, but lefts comment: The Rams offense is lacking and could afford Vick the opportunity to develop back into the player Well, you could swap Rams with all the other aforementioned teams.

QUOTE(#16):

Originally posted 09:58 AM ET  11.10 by Pickle_T.Johnstone

My list thoughts are Raiders, Buffalo..then Cleveland. I feel that the Raiders are desperate enough and would use Vick to light a fire under Russell. The Bill brought in TO so are clearly willing to take great risks to see rewards. And the Browns, well nothing has worked there in years. I just don't see the Rams as an organization that would want this.. I could be wrong. There are three arguments left and right has not said much yet, but lefts comment: The Rams offense is lacking and could afford Vick the opportunity to develop back into the player Well, you could swap Rams with all the other aforementioned teams.

Agreed. I think St Louis is out of the picture. They are already looking at a top 5 draft pick right now, and I don't see that changing. With the group of outstanding QB's, I see STL finally picking up a QB with their first pick. No room for Vick, if you can still have Bulger take a few snaps before the kid is ready. Vick would be a great fit in Oakland, dump that overpaid moose that they have at QB and install Vick. Browns, well who knows WTF they are going to do and if it will even work. They are a mess. Buffalo is a good option for Vick also

Voting for DJ only because those teams are reasonable. The only team I could see from KenyBoy's list is Oakland. No way does Jerry Jones bring him into Dallas and the Bucs aren't going to bring in anyone that would hinder the development of Josh Freeman.

It would have to be a team with good pass catching TE's and a solid run game. The Titans and 49er's come to mind.

rights list is horrible, that is one bad list right must be an idiot!