- 12/01/2009, 10:33PM ET
JB: said 12/01, 10:33 PM
Carlos Dunlap, DE of the Florida Gators was arrested for drunk driving.
Carlos was suspended indefinetely by the University, and will not be playing in Saturday's SEC Championship game. But the debate will linger.. should he play in Florida's bowl game?
I say no.
Carlos "fell asleep over the wheel of his car and was stopped as several green lights went on". Florida has acted swiftly in suspending him for Saturday's game. But that does not answer the question of if he should play in the bowl game. Just because the inevitable BCS game is a month away, it doesn't mean that his suspension of one month will be sufficient. He would only miss one game.
It shouldn't matter what game they play if. If they lose Saturday and are awarded an at-large bid, I can see Florida keeping the suspension because it's a "less important" game. But he should also be suspended if the play in the title game. It shouldn't matter if they are playing Charleston Southern or Texas in the national championship game. He shouldn't play again this year.
YanksBillsSabres said 12/01, 11:45 PM
The way the NCAA handles punishment has been absolutely rediculous this year. I don't remember all of the names but look at the Oregon player that got suspended for punching out another player. What was is six weeks and he got reinstated? While on the other hand Dez Bryant a player who just talked to an NFL player got suspended for the season because he lied to protect his rep and college career. The suspensions are total
JB: said 12/02, 12:42 AM
My friend, you are terribly misinformed.
LeGarrette Blount, Oregon's running back was suspended indefinitely BY OREGON. The NCAA had nothing to do with it. He wasn't gone six weeks either. Try 10 weeks. And he was only reinstated after having to reach many academic and personal goals. Only then was he given the chance to suit up again. He has also yet to play in a game since his reinstatement. Two totally seperate issues.
And it's unfair to compare Dez Bryant to this situation. Lying to the NCAA about a meeting with Deion Sanders and drunk driving are two seperate issues.
Florida should not treat this any differently just because they are playing Alabama and then potentially for a national championship. If they were playing Charleston Southern and Florida International, Dunlap would miss both games. He also has to miss these two games. The action should have the same punishment regardless of who you are lining up against.
Dunlap should feel fortunate that he got no one hurt or killed, and that he'll be a first rounder next April and he'll be able to start an NFL career while this becomes part of his past.
YanksBillsSabres said 12/02, 05:52 PM
I'm giving examples to gage what punishment they should go off of. One that it is of lesser punishment of those 2 examples. I was just saying the way the NCAA deals with punishment is out of whack. Make an unarguable TD even worse. Just trying to pick one up maybe find a hole in it. In my opinion if no one got hurt, he lucked out. He should just be punished for the DUI. Not for the possibility of killing someone. The Oregon player punched someone, physically hurting them intentionally and that should be punished more than this case. There was no harm done suspend him for one game and we'll forget about it. Now also people saying I should use all my characters.... look hit enter at the wrong time and it submitted the argument without me finishing it. So look at the comment below where I finished it.
You said if they played 2 nobody teams they would've suspended him for the 2 games. Well any team would've. But any team would also want their best out there for their bowl game, regardless if it was BCS or not. Honestly I don't think you should ruin a college kids career over a DUI when no one/or thing was hurt except maybe his liver.
JB: said 12/03, 01:43 PM
Sorry.. but I'm not going to accept a draw. I understand that you tried your best, but it's 13-2.. a draw doesn't make sense.
I believe this actually is arguable. You brought up several key points about the inconsistency of the NCAA with handling suspensions.
But Dunlap's situation is different. People go to jail for drunk driving. I don't think Carlos should have any reason to think that he should play in the two games. Like I said, in a few months, he will be standing up on stage with Mr. Goodell holding up a jersey and smiling for pictures. Florida, NCAA, and Dunlap must all understand the severity of his arrest and suspending him for the rest of the year is appropriate.
- Fantasy baseball Prospect Watch: Miller looks like an ace
- Fantasy baseball Stat Focus: Cabrera's wOBA proves dominance
- Fantasy baseball Trade Tips: It's time to sell Rickie Weeks
- Fantasy baseball Roundtable: Is Cardinals' pitching slowing?
- Fantasy baseball Pitching Report: Odorizzi a worthy option
- Awful Announcing
- Free Darko
- Pro Football Talk
- The Big Lead
- Joe Posnanski
- The Sporting Blog
- Big League Stew
- Bugs and Cranks
- Every day Should Be Saturday
- Mr. Irrelevant
- With Leather
- The Sports Hernia