- 10/01/2010, 11:02PM ET
PCH said 10/01, 11:02 PM
i'll take the proven passer..
Vick was recently named nfc player of the month..
I think Vick will be running around a lil more with Orakpo n company coming for him..
McNabb probably won't win the game but he'll definetly have more passing yards..
McNabb has already had a 400+ passing performance this season..
Galbert-Kun said 10/02, 06:46 PM
Vick will have more passing yards.
While McNabb's receivers have put up good numbers thus far. McNabb has been up and down. That 400 yard game he had was good, but the next week he threw for almost 200 yards less. The Redskins are relying on McNabb's arm too much because the 'Skins running backs are aged. While he can still scramble, he does not have the mobility he once had.
Vick on the other hand, is fresh. The two years away from football was two years away from taking hits and punishment. Granted he took a year or so to get back to how he was before, he knows the Eagle's system. He has rapport with Maclin, Jackson, Avant and co, which results in the consistency of his passing yardages (175, 284, 291). He will throw for more yards because his running is going to set up the pass.
PCH said 10/02, 07:09 PM
thanks for that award winning paper, right cartman?
MCNabb vs Vick
Warren Moon vs Randall Cunningham?
tell me who's the better passer?
Galbert-Kun said 10/02, 11:30 PM
If I recall correctly, this throwdown is about who will have more passing yards between McNabb and Vick; in your first argument, there was no mention of Moon and Cunningham. I'm pretty sure you could've countered my arguments soundly, but I guess I was wrong .
PCH said 10/03, 01:01 AM
Great way to waste an argument..
The rushing game for the skins is in disarray..
Portis got benched lil after half time..
the back up showed a lil progress..
I believe McNabb will be down in the game.. seriously.. they are +6 on the game.. I think Santana Moss will have a 150 yard sor so..
McNabb has too much riding on this game and the rushing attack is at question..
McNabb does more with his arms.. Vick more with his feet..
u were expecting a **** 3rd argument .. weren't u?
Galbert-Kun said 10/03, 01:56 AM
While mention of the 'Skins running game is a good way to stimulate an argument, I am confused as to how the betting line of the game (+6) has any impact on which quarterback has more passing yards come Sunday...
I would suggest you watch ESPN News or another sports news outlet and listen to athletes' thoughts about playing against their former team. The media loves to make more of a storyline than what it should be, i.e. McNabb's return to Philadelphia. Its just another game for this quarterback whose team is currently 1-2 in a weak division (Dallas and New York are not playing well right now)
Vick is becoming more consistent as a passer and his running game is as good as ever. If Vick became a good passer to complement his scrambling abilites? Philadelphia will be a beast of a team.
- Awful Announcing
- Free Darko
- Pro Football Talk
- The Big Lead
- Joe Posnanski
- The Sporting Blog
- Big League Stew
- Bugs and Cranks
- Every day Should Be Saturday
- Mr. Irrelevant
- With Leather
- The Sports Hernia