Views
1093
Comments
64
  • 12/21/2010, 02:25AM ET

Should Jackie Robinson's #42 have been retired by Major League Baseball?

HOOTZ (33-14-9) vs Mr. Nice Guy: Barry's a HOFer (9-23-5)
6
Votes
16
Votes
6
Votes
16
Votes


As we all know, in 1997 during the 50 Year anniversary of Jackie Robinson braking the MLB color barrier, MLB decided to retire Robinson's #42 throughout the entire leage.

The Grandfather clause allowed any player already wearing the #42 to keep wearing it until thier career ended.

Currently, 41 y/o Mariano Rivera is the only player that still be wearing the number,

Whenever I'm at Fenway Park I see the huge (42) displayed in the right centerfield bleachers along side numbers of the greatest Red Sox of all time. This has bothered me for many years. Robinson doesn't belong there.

I most assuredly am in no way trying to downplay the magnitude of Robinson's accomplishments on the field as well as for our society. But, the decision to get rid of the #42... fifty years later seems more like a publicity stunt than a unified act of compassion.

I know that this doesn't seem to bother anyone else but me. So, would someone who agrees that the retirement of Robinson's # was the fitting thing to do.......

Give me an argument stating your reasons why? Hopefully we can make a TD out of this.

Best of luck.


"But, the decision to get rid of the #42... fifty years later seems more like a publicity stunt than a unified act of compassion."

Having fireworks after a game, a concert after a game, or $1 hot dogs is a publicity stunt. Retiring the number of the first player to face the adversity that crossing baseball's color barrier entailed and doing it with the grace of a professional ballerina, definately isn't the same as $1 dog or pretty things that blow up in the sky night.

Not once going to a Twins game have I ever looked at the retired numbers of Oliva, Killebrew, Carew, Hrbek, and Pucket and thought, "Jackie Robinson's number doesn't belong there."

Whenever I've went with my parents to Cincinnati for family get togethers, my dad and I always go to Reds games. I've thought to myself before, while looking at the retired #'s of Bench, Robinson, Morgan, Perez, etc. "Man, Roses' #14 should be hanging up there." But I've never thought Robinsons didn't.

"A life is not important, except in the impact it has on others' lives." -Jackie Robinson

#42 is retired across all of baseball not only to honor Robinson but every black player that didn't get the chance before him.


During the mid 1980's I was lucky enough to obtain a 1956 Jackie Robinson baseball card for $100. To this day it's my most treasured card. It always will be. I have nothing but sheer admiration for him and I remember being very saddened when hearing the news of his death.

Robinson played on some of the greatest Dodger teams of all time. I'm not denying that fact. He earned his spot in baseball history.

But, his timing was right. Robinson didn't choose his timing. Branch Rickey chose it for him. If he hadn't broken into the Majors in 1947, some other young black man surely would have shortly thereafter.

This wouldn't have seemed inevitable in 1947. But, by the time his number was retired in 1997 it clearly seemed that way.

Here's my beef. By the year 1997 baseball had been around for over 100 years at the professional level. In those more than 10 decades of baseball, far better players had come and gone. We had seen better hitters, better fielders, faster base runners, more powerful throwers and players of more legendary status.

Yet, not any of them, not a single one has ever had their # retired by MLB. It seems odd that this one single man has been immortilized.


Major League Baseball retiring Robison's #42 was not only a tribute to him, but a tribute to every African-American player that came before him such as Rube Foster, Cool Papa Bell, Josh Gibson, and the scores of players that were skilled enough to play Major League, baseball but never got the chance because of the color of their skin. It was also a way to honor all the African-American players that have come along since Robinson broke the color barrier.

"Branch Rickey chose it for him"
He chose Robinson because he was a player that had the character traits, name recognition, and education to appeal to white America. Robinson graduated from UCLA where he was a football star and basically led the way for the desegregation of the United States Armed Forces, when he refused to take orders from a white officer that Robinson outranked.

Baseball is a pure American institution, and thus an arm of American culture. We don't have Abraham Lincoln, Franklin Deleanor Roosevelt, Thomas Jefferson day. We have Presidents day. We also lump Malcolm X, Walter White, Thurgood Marshall, etc. as part of Martin Luther King Jr. Day.

Out of room. More to come.


Baseball is a pure American institution, and thus an arm of American culture.

Well put CREEPY. It must also be the keeper of it's own house. I failed to recognize the symbolism behind the symbol.

I'm going to pass this back to you, should you have any final thoughts you'd like to share.

Thanks for taking this topic at face value and turning it into the debate I was hoping for. I doubt that anyone could have argued it better.

December 21, 2010  08:48 AM ET

Right is a Super Duper Hootz. Back out while you can

December 21, 2010  09:19 AM ET
QUOTE:

everytime I maturbate, I throw my pet turtle against the wall. I don't think he can take much more.He is not always in the room. sometimes I have to go find him.

I wonder what the turtle does to you after you fall asleep. Maybe you should sleep on your back from now on.

December 21, 2010  10:25 AM ET
QUOTE:

everytime I maturbate, I throw my pet turtle against the wall. I don't think he can take much more.He is not always in the room. sometimes I have to go find him.

LMAO

December 21, 2010  11:09 AM ET
QUOTE:

everytime I maturbate, I throw my pet turtle against the wall. I don't think he can take much more.He is not always in the room. sometimes I have to go find him.

Get a rubber toy turtle so next time it bounces of the wall, it will come right back to you and hit in your nut sack.

December 21, 2010  12:28 PM ET

A super Duper with that record???

December 21, 2010  01:14 PM ET
QUOTE:

The Red Sox were the last team in baseball, to break the color barrier. Maybe they are ashamed, and trying to make up for it.

Ha!

December 21, 2010  01:18 PM ET
QUOTE(#10):

Ha!

On second thought, not really a "Ha", more of a snorting chuckle.

December 21, 2010  03:39 PM ET
QUOTE(#9):

A super Duper with that record???

Exactly. My record is this bad because of the allegations too. It's funny, because anyone who has TD'ed against me knows I put up good arguments.

December 21, 2010  03:46 PM ET
QUOTE:

The Red Sox were the last team in baseball, to break the color barrier. Maybe they are ashamed, and trying to make up for it.

The Arizona Diamondbacks & the
Tampa Bay Devil Rays (now Tampa Bay Rays)
where the last MLB teams to break the color barrier.

December 21, 2010  07:40 PM ET
QUOTE(#13):

The Arizona Diamondbacks & theTampa Bay Devil Rays (now Tampa Bay Rays)where the last MLB teams to break the color barrier.

That might be one of the dumbest things I've ever read.

December 21, 2010  07:51 PM ET
QUOTE(#14):

That might be one of the dumbest things I've ever read.

Would you please be nice.

December 21, 2010  08:02 PM ET
QUOTE(#15):

Would you please be nice.

Since you asked so nicely. Maybe.

December 21, 2010  08:09 PM ET

There isn't anything fun about being nice though.

December 21, 2010  08:16 PM ET
QUOTE(#16):

Since you asked so nicely. Maybe.

Thank you.

December 21, 2010  10:55 PM ET
QUOTE(#17):

There isn't anything fun about being nice though.

This is the reason people vote against you. You come off as a d0uche sometimes.

That said, voting right on this one.

December 21, 2010  11:25 PM ET
QUOTE(#19):

This is the reason people vote against you. You come off as a d0uche sometimes.

I would not have put it in quite those terms but those are essentially the facts.

December 22, 2010  01:00 AM ET

CREEPS, I'll finish this off tomorrow. You've put up a nice argument. Thanks for taking this.

December 22, 2010  01:02 AM ET
QUOTE(#1):

Right is a Super Duper Hootz. Back out while you can

tdbubba...this one man crusade can stop. Creepy isn't a dupe.

December 22, 2010  01:03 AM ET

I'd prefer if they retired the last name Robinson instead, retiring 42 in all of baseball is a bit shall we say unnecessary . Should they retire the number of the first Latino, Japanese , Canadian, and gay player?

 
December 22, 2010  01:04 AM ET
QUOTE(#22):

tdbubba...this one man crusade can stop. Creepy isn't a dupe.

he may be an arsehole........but his arguments are solid for the most part.

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


Leaderboard

  Fan W L T Win %
1 fvkasm2x 193 58 12 75.7%
2 7#bag _ Com 997 338 74 73.4%
3 HOOTZ 33 14 9 67.0%
4 Marlins Fan 156 78 31 64.7%
5 Argos. 184 101 29 63.2%
6 Goodell: Fannation Savior 644 430 71 59.3%
7 J-Business 78 66 19 53.7%
8 Highway... 175 852 64 19.0%

The Si.com Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Clippers, Warriors exchange barbs
    Views
    710
    Comments
    431
  2. 2
    Time to penalize NHL's perennial losers?
    Views
    826
    Comments
    267
  3. 3
    Report: Raiders to release Terrelle Pryor on Monday
    Views
    1212
    Comments
    59
  4. 4
    Will NFL owners blackball Donald Trump?
    Views
    1012
    Comments
    54
  5. 5
    Packers lovers have own dating site
    Views
    935
    Comments
    43

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
    Robataille
  2. 2
    ~Mother-Marge~
  3. 3
    TxHeat
  4. 4
    buddhaa.luck
  5. 5
    Deep Creek

Message Boards

  1. NBA > General NBA

    Toronto Raptors: No time to…
    Views
    39
    Replies
    2
  2. MLB > Seattle Mariners

    HOUSTON (5-14) @ SEA (7-11) …
    Views
    6
    Replies
    2

Blogs