- 02/19/2011, 02:47PM ET
PatsFan5012 said 02/19, 03:02 PM
My argument is that Jamarcus Russell is a bigger bust than Ryan Leaf or any other bust ever. I have several points to prove this.
First, the hype. He came out of college after a great senior season in which he threw for 3,100 yards, 28 TD's and 8 INTs and LSU beat Notre Dame 41-14 in their bowl game. He was 1st team SEC, 4X SEC Player of the week, & the winner of the Manning Award. Russell, a senior, left LSU with his best year and he got much praise in workouts. Mike Mayock and Mel Kiper both have said that his workouts were some of the better that they've ever seen from a QB. The workouts greatly moved Russell up the draft board and then the Raiders took him #1.
Second, the failure. Russell showed up to camp in poor shape and was never in shape. He then proceeded to throw for 4,000 total yards, a 65.2 rating, and a 18-23 record in 3 seasons in which he posted a 50.0 QB rating (lowest ever) in 2008, beefed with coaches and eventually got busted for "Purple Drank" on a terrible Raiders team. There was just so much hype followed by such failure that I say that there is no way that there has even been a bigger bust than Russell.
DJRoxalot said 02/19, 08:49 PM
I give you a guy that played in the Pac 10. Since you are so stuck on quality Conferences.
With even worse stats than Russell. Yes, it is true. If not shocking.
46.6%, 100.5ypg, 5 TD's to 13 INT's (2.8 INT %) with a 52.8 Passer Rating
70 carries for 371 yards, 5.3ypc, 16.9 ypg, 1 TD
Oh and a 3-14 record as a starter in the NFL.
Russell's REAL stats:
52.1%, 131.7ypg, 18 TD's to 23 INT's (3.4 INT %) with a 65.2 Passer Rating
40 carries for 175 yards, 4.4ypc, 5.6ypg, 1 TD
7-18 as a starter
As bad was Russell's accuracy was? He completed over 50% of his passes. The other QB I listed did not.
Ladies and gentlemen, I give you....
The Bengals passed on Daunte Culpepper who was drafted 11th. Can you imagine if they had taken Culpepper instead of Smith?
Or even Torry Holt who was drafted 6th by the Rams?
The Bengals could have used Culpepper or Holt and might have changed the Bengals fortunes.
DJRoxalot said 02/21, 10:54 AM
More on Akili Smith:
Jr year: 54%, 125.9ypg, 6.9ypa, 13 TD's to 7 INT's woth a 126.6 Passer Rating
Sr year: 58%, 342.1ypg, 10.1ypa, 30 TD's to 7 INT's with a 166.1 Passer Rating
He had one great season after transferring to Oregon from Grossmont Junior College.
He had bust written all over him and he certainly showed he was with his pathetic NFL performance.
He was the 4th best QB out of 29 available in the draft yet the Bungles chose him 3rd. Another in a long line of horrible decisions for their franchise.
Akili Smith was a bigger BUST!!!
- Awful Announcing
- Free Darko
- Pro Football Talk
- The Big Lead
- Joe Posnanski
- The Sporting Blog
- Big League Stew
- Bugs and Cranks
- Every day Should Be Saturday
- Mr. Irrelevant
- With Leather
- The Sports Hernia