Views
2020
Comments
145
  • 05/09/2011, 03:41PM ET

Should Bynum be suspended for his flagrant foul?

OlderthanDirt (88-37-13) vs Ogre: Batman (45-35-11)
24
Votes
21
Votes
24
Votes
21
Votes


Yes!

What he did was beyond frustration of losing consecutive games to the Mavs. The league cannot allow him to get away with this.

I understand that was their last game of the season and therefore he should be suspended, without pay for at least ten games beginning next season.

You think not?
Watch this.






You want to argue he should not be punished at least ten games? BRING THE ...........dang, forgot what it is you are supposed to bring....have to ask Dj.....be back in a minute.......
....OH YEA,......THE PAIN!


Should Andrew Bynum be suspended for his flagrant foul? Yes. But 10 games? That's excessive.

Andrew Bynum committed a flagrant foul. That much is a fact. He reached out, and shoved Jose Barrera as he came in the paint. However, it's not the first time in NBA history that someone has fouled someone in the paint hard in frustration. It happens, and quite frankly is almost a part of the game. Bynum has even committed hard flagrant fouls in the paint before, but he's certainly not alone.

In this same series, Artest threw a forearm at the face of Barrera as he was moving the ball up the court. He wasn't entering the paint or attacking the basket. And yet, Artest was only suspended for a game. Why? Because the NBA rules flat out don't call for harsh penalties on flagrant fouls. Their system for suspensions is as follows:

Player at 2 points commits a FFP2: automatic 1 game
3 or 4 points commits a FFP1: automatic 1
3 or 4 points commits a FFP2: automatic 2
5 points or more commits a FFP1 or FFP2: automatic 2

Bynum is along the guidelines for a 2 game ban. Why you feel it should escalate to 10 games is beyond me. I feel a 4-5 game suspension is much better suited.


Okay, I got the whole NBA automatic bit but we are talking about what SHOULD BE DONE versus what probably will be done due to the rules.

I disagree with your first point adamantly. Bynum did not "shove" Barea as he came into the paint. He gave him an elbow that would make Ric Flair give his best "Whhhoooo". It was a deliberate shot up towards the head area of Barea and quite frankly came out of it lucky that he did not cause any permanent injury.

I am berated on FN all the time because I say the NFL is wussifying the league with all their rules for protecting the players like they did this past season. And here we are trying to protect the likes of what happened last night in an NBA game? C'mon guys!

The whole point of the 10 games is meant to be "excessive". Somehow the league has got to "make it hurt" for the team if the players can't police up this crap.

Bynum is 7'0" and 285 lbs, Barea is 6'0" and 175. Bynum threw an elbow dead at his head instead of attempting to block the shot. That is BS!

Are you forgetting that this is not Mr. Bynums first time?



2 games suspension for that.

MMTC


A deliberate shot up towards the head area? If you watch the clip you posted from 47 seconds to 51 seconds, you can clearly see Bynum raise his arm after Barrea is in the air. He moves towards Barrea, and connects with his forearm/elbow in his chest which slides up to his armpit. There's no effort at a head shot.

What we have here is a witch hunt. Bynum, a center, defends the paint, as is his job. Hard fouls are a part of the playoffs; they have been and always will be. Bynum isn't the only NBA player to have a "history" of rough fouls, so don't try to overblow that. While I agree that Bynum could have gone about committing the hard foul in a different way, I disagree with the notion that Bynum had malicious intent to hurt Barrea. He extended his arm to send the message that even though LA is being blown out, you can't come into the paint and expect free points in the playoffs.

I'm not saying reward the man for what he did. It was a clear flagrant foul, and should be treated as such. However, this is no different than the countless other flagrant fouls that garner 2 game suspensions or less. If you want to teach a lesson, 5 is fine.


Bynym knew he had done wrong. He took off his jersey and headed for the locker room. It was malicious.

Evidently FN believe as you do that 10 games are too many. I am not changing my mind or my stance on this.

Using the 2 game suspensions as a guide line apparently does not stop this type of play. Most of FN seems to think that is part of the game. Maybe that is where I miss the boat. I however, was looking at it from my grandkids point of view as we watched the game.

I was left trying to explain to them "Why did he do that Papa?". What do I tell my grandkids? "Well son, you see they are pros and that is the way the game is played at that level but don't you even think about doing it in a game at school or playground". Now exactly how does that sound? Well, to a twelve year old it is bullshitte!

So, you guys that believe that a two or three game is enough go ahead and vote that way. But when this same thing happens and someone gets seriously injured don't say a frigging thing.

If it had happened to Kobe and he broke his neck the guy would be in jail. It is just a matter of time before someone is seriously injured if this is allowed to continue. Good TD Ogre tnks


Voting isn't about who is right or wrong or personal belief, it's about arguments. Or at least it's supposed to be.

Clearly you want to send a message with the suspension, which we both agree needs to happen. You seem to think jumping from the typical 2 games all of the way to 10, a HUGE leap forward, is justified. I feel that more than doubling the penalty, a suspension of 5 games, sends a clear message. Jumping to a 5 game suspension in itself would be new ground for punishment for flagrant fouls, there's no need to skip all of the way to 10.

Like it or not, hard fouls are a part of the game. While Bynum lost his cool and committed a hard foul (and immediately knew it), it wasn't as if he was completely trying to destroy Barrea. He pushed a player entering the lane, albeit hard. It's not the first time things like this have happened, and it won't be the last.

Moreover, I believe Bynum is being cast in a bad light because of his postgame comments. Since then, Bynum has owned up to his mistakes and apologize, and has attempted to contact Barrea multiple times.

A lesson has been learned. Send a message, yes. But don't jump to extremes. 5 games is fine.

May 9, 2011  03:44 PM ET

cannot believe FN did not jump all over this...unless of course I missed it earlier....

May 9, 2011  03:52 PM ET

10 games?


3 games. Max.

May 9, 2011  03:54 PM ET
QUOTE(#2):

10 games? 3 games. Max.

Way to steal my thought!

May 9, 2011  03:54 PM ET

3-5 games. It was a horrible foul, but 10 games is a bit much - that can alter the outcome of a team's record.

Comment #5 has been removed
May 9, 2011  03:56 PM ET
QUOTE(#3):

Way to steal my thought!

Sorry Ogre. You still have to argue it though. haha

May 9, 2011  03:58 PM ET

Bynum is a p*ssy! His punishment shoudl be 3 rounds against Kimbo Slice. Or someone else that would knock the s--h--!--t outta him.

May 9, 2011  03:59 PM ET
QUOTE(#7):

Bynum is a p*ssy! His punishment shoudl be 3 rounds against Kimbo Slice. Or someone else that would knock the s--h--!--t outta him.

**s-h-o-u-l-d

May 9, 2011  03:59 PM ET

waiting to see the argument. GL Ogre...good to see ya on here!

May 9, 2011  03:59 PM ET
QUOTE(#7):

Bynum is a p*ssy! His punishment shoudl be 3 rounds against Kimbo Slice. Or someone else that would knock the s--h--!--t outta him.

lol

May 9, 2011  04:01 PM ET
QUOTE(#4):

3-5 games. It was a horrible foul, but 10 games is a bit much - that can alter the outcome of a team's record.

part of my arguments will address this very thing...

May 9, 2011  04:02 PM ET
QUOTE(#10):

lol

Although I'm being a total smarta** right now about him fighting I truly am disgusted with Bynum's action last night. And I hope the NBA makes an example outta him. $150,000 AND 10 games next year should be his punishment.

May 9, 2011  04:02 PM ET
QUOTE(#6):

Sorry Ogre. You still have to argue it though. haha

Well I changed it to 4-5 games, but you get my point.

May 9, 2011  04:03 PM ET
QUOTE(#9):

waiting to see the argument. GL Ogre...good to see ya on here!

Good luck to you too, glad to have the opportunity.

May 9, 2011  04:04 PM ET

What Bynum did to me is one of the worst plays ever in NBA playoff history. And let's not let Odom off the hook. He was totally classless also.

May 9, 2011  04:12 PM ET

He should be suspended for 10 games because he was a punk about the Foul. I mean to shove the smallest guy on the court when he driving to the basket is very cowardly. But i see a 3-5 game suspension coming.

May 9, 2011  04:14 PM ET
QUOTE(#15):

What Bynum did to me is one of the worst plays ever in NBA playoff history. And let's not let Odom off the hook. He was totally classless also.

Odom's is a little more excusable. He got the ugliest of all the Kardashian girls. He had some built up frustrations in the first place.

May 9, 2011  04:18 PM ET

Rooster: About to head out soon, have some stuff to do. I'm not sure if I'll get an argument in today. If I don't, then I will around 3 tomorrow.

May 9, 2011  04:20 PM ET
QUOTE(#12):

Although I'm being a total smarta** right now about him fighting I truly am disgusted with Bynum's action last night. And I hope the NBA makes an example outta him. $150,000 AND 10 games next year should be his punishment.

That is about right. That was what I was thinking as well. If the league can't take the ugliest play in playoff history and make an example of him they have no business staying in business.

 
May 9, 2011  04:20 PM ET
QUOTE(#18):

Rooster: About to head out soon, have some stuff to do. I'm not sure if I'll get an argument in today. If I don't, then I will around 3 tomorrow.

That's cool. take care and see ya tomorrow

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


Leaderboard

  Fan W L T Win %
1 fvkasm2x 193 58 12 75.7%
2 7#bag _ Com 997 338 74 73.4%
3 HOOTZ 33 14 9 67.0%
4 Marlins Fan 156 78 31 64.7%
5 Argos. 184 101 29 63.2%
6 Goodell: Fannation Savior 644 430 71 59.3%
7 J-Business 78 66 19 53.7%
8 Highway... 175 852 64 19.0%

The Si.com Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Tuukka Rask takes blame for Bruins' Game 1 loss
    Views
    2277
    Comments
    230
  2. 2
    Smush Parker allegedly punches high schooler
    Views
    1806
    Comments
    139
  3. 3
    Joel Quenneville's Midnight Hawk favored to win Illinois Derby
    Views
    448
    Comments
    88
  4. 4
    Quarterback freefalling down draft boards
    Views
    6606
    Comments
    88
  5. 5
    Accuser's lawyer calls for Florida State to charge Jameis Winston
    Views
    2838
    Comments
    27

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
    Robataille
  2. 2
    ~Mother-Marge~
  3. 3
    TxHeat
  4. 4
    buddhaa.luck
  5. 5
    Deep Creek

Blogs