- 06/18/2011, 03:59PM ET
DJRoxalot said 06/18, 03:59 PM
First let me say I love the Lakers. I am a huge fan but have to call you out, my friend.
"Tim Duncan is a great player but don't ever try to class him MJ and Kobe. That's why I was thrown off. Its' MJ #1, Kobe #2 and Duncan somewhere from 15-25. Please don't do that again."
Class him MJ and Kobe? Let me give you a heads up. There is MJ in his own freaking class and everybody else.
Tim Duncan was a great player. It is difficult to compare a PF/C to a SG but Duncan was an absolute beast.
He was 4-0 in the Finals. Not many other people can claim being undefeated. MJ was 6-0 and he played during (roughly) the same time as MJ.
Duncan's numbers in the Finals?
1998-99: 27.4ppg, 14rpg, 2.4apg, 2.2bpg and 1spg while shooting 53.7% on FG's and 79.5% on FT's.
2002-03: 24.2ppg, 17rpg, 5.3ap and 5.3bpg while shooting 49.5% and 68.5%.
04-05: 20.6ppg, 14.1rpg, 2.1apg, 2.1bpg and 0.4spg
15-25? Are you freaking serious?
Oh and when mentioning TD? When talking about NBA? Stands for Tim Duncan.
rickford5150 said 06/18, 08:20 PM
Oh alright...why not? I've see guys like you before........right next to the ant farm ad in my old Richy Rich comic books!
KB8 or KB24 is for sure in the #2 slot and that's right now and not in 4-5 years when he racks up even more and retires.
Tim Duncan is a great player as I said before but he is NOT, nor should he ever be in MJ and then Kobe's class. Let me tell you why:
Fact: Timmy never had any range outside of 15ft
Fact: He has no left hand shot or dribble and rarely went left because he never PRACTICED it
Fact: He never averaged more than 25 PPG
Fact: More times than not when he went up against Shaq (the other dominant big man of his time) he was outsscored and out played
Look at Kobe:
Most all star MVP's ever and 13 time selection
13 times All NBA
All defense team - 11 times
5 time NBA Champ with 3 MVP's
2 time scoring champion
81 freakin points in a single game
Youngest ever to get 18,19, 20, 21 22, 23, 24, 25,26, &27,000 points
6th all-time scoring and closing quick, will be #2 or #3
The argument is not that Kobe is better than MJ but that Duncan should not be mentioned with those two. It's MJ #1 and Kobe is right there and we all know it!
DJRoxalot said 06/19, 10:25 AM
Never had any range outside 15 feet? 26 3-pointers.
"He never averaged more than 25PPG"
LOL. The old he never scored more than this many ppg argument? Weak sauce, my friend. There is more to the game than just scoring.
You want to talk accolades?
4 time NBA champion (again, 4-0 in the Finals)
3 time NBA Finals MVP
13 time NBA All Star
9 time All-NBA 1st Team
3 time All-NBA 2nd Team
8 time All-NBA Defensive 1st Team
5 time All-NBA Defensive 2nd Team
2 time NBA MVP
Kobe was the youngest to score those points because he came out of HS and he had a jump start on players that went to college.
The stupid statement "is Duncan is in the 15-25." And since this is an open TD with no clearcut title or headline that is the route I am going with this TD.
Many can argue TD as the best PF of all time while Kobe will never be argued as the best at his position. Better than MJ? Never.
Kobe? Played with another HOF'er in Shaq. Who he threw under the bus vs the Pistons. Kobe shot 38% and refused to defer to the big man who was making 63% of his FG's and simply unguardable.
rickford5150 said 06/19, 12:13 PM
Homeboy y'all gonna have to do better than that! I remember what it was like when I had my first beer, but don't post until your sober bro. Kobe is a lightning rod but if you actually are true to your heart we know KB is a far better player than TD!
Since this is my first time I'm guessing that bold lettering is supposed to make your argument stronger? LOL. Not going to help cause facts are facts and let's not try to change the argument cause a TD rookie is shaking your Sh iitz from the top of the key!
Kobe got a jump start on points because "he came from HS".. That's because he COULD but thanks for making my point.
TD also played with an HOF'er, so did MJ, Bird and Magic. What's your point?
KB could and does play forward. Does TD ever play guard?
Both are 21 and you got the 1st pick? You know the answer
26 total 3 pointers? What is that like 1.8 a year? The good news is he is only a 1,227 away from PF - Cliff Robinson. Puhleese he has no range. Thanks again!
As far as accolades go I just ran out of characters or I could have added another 50!
Bottom line: TD does not belong in the same category as Bryant. Can we just stop the madness or do you like pain?
DJRoxalot said 06/20, 09:53 AM
"TD also played with an HOF'er, so did MJ, Bird and Magic. What's your point?"
Kobe played with Shaq when he was in his prime and in beast mode and Kobe could ride his coat tails.
Duncan? Played with Robinson when he was at the end of his career and battling injuries. I would expect an NBA fan to realize that.
"Both are 21 and you got the 1st pick? You know the answer"
Depends on what you need on your team but players like Tim Duncan and Shaq do not come along that often.
Guys like Kobe and Wade come along a lot more often than a skil
"26 total 3 pointers? What is that like 1.8 a year?"
Don't remember what you said?
"Fact: Timmy never have anr range outside of 15 ft"
I love how you totally ignored Kobe sabotaging the Finals against the Pistons when he had to prove he could be the go to guy. Rather than be a "team player" like Mister Duncan who has always been the epitome of class and integrity.
Want to know some interesting numbers from the Finals?
99-00: 36.7% on FG's, 20% on 3's
00-01: 41.5% and 33.3%
07-08: 40.5% and 32.1%
08-09: 43% and 36%
Clutch? No. And most def? Not like Mike.
rickford5150 said 06/20, 12:30 PM
Since this is the close I find it fitting to talk about KB's leadership and ability to "close and kill" vs TD. In this KB is very comparable to MJ.
My opponent defends Duncan but in another current TD he defends Shaq versus Duncan. Does he even believe what he is arguing here?
Clutch NO? GM's and players beg to differ. Truth
Kobe is number #1 all time in game winning shots with 36. 11 more than MJ and 26 more than Duncan - Truth
A GM survey done on "who you would want taking the last shot"? KB "wins by a country mile" every time. (In a general-manager poll this season he earned 79 percent of the vote, his ninth consecutive blowout.) - Truth
Alvin Gentry said "He's the best closer in the history of the game if you ask me," - Truth
Even MJ says KB is the best player on the planet: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=21yiGz3Vgrw&feature=related - Truth
How many times have we seen KB be a leader in the 4th qtr when it counts? He is never afraid to fail (and has) but that's why he succeeds people! Duncan is not even close in closing skills and is passive at times.
Kobe's a polarizing figure and you may not like him, but TD (as great as he is), is NO Kobe Bryant
|6||JimJ77 Can't make it up||130||53||26||68.4%|
|10||Schad - Notorious Deadbeat||71||43||9||61.4%|
- Fantasy baseball Roundtable: Dissecting Myers, Wheeler debuts
- Fantasy football focus: Mendenhall among top 30 running backs
- Fantasy baseball Pitching Report: Bartolo Colon's monster year
- Fantasy baseball Injury Report: Tigers ailing as Sanchez, Avila hit DL
- Fantasy baseball Waiver Wire: Joyce's hitting lifted Rays
- Awful Announcing
- Free Darko
- Pro Football Talk
- The Big Lead
- Joe Posnanski
- The Sporting Blog
- Big League Stew
- Bugs and Cranks
- Every day Should Be Saturday
- Mr. Irrelevant
- With Leather
- The Sports Hernia