Throwdowns > Closed

U. Wrex said 07/03, 08:54 PM
Please wait until my opponets second argument to vote

Build a NFL team full of players 25 years old or younger. They must be 25 today so if they turn 26 tommorow they are okay. So must of been born July 4 1985 or sooner.

Either style of defense as long as the player fits it. Offense needs 5 linemen, 1 QB, 1 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE and one skill position of your choice(RB, WR, or TE).

My extra position is WR

QB-Josh Freeman-23

RB-Jamaal Charles-24

WR-Calvin Johnson-25

WR-Mike Wallace-24

WR-Hakeem Nicks-23

TE-Jermichael Finley-24

OT-Ryan Clady-24

OG-Josh Sitton-25

C-Jeremy Zuttah-25

OG-Andy Levitre-25

OT-Michael Oher-25

My defense is a 3-4

DE-Ndamukong Suh-24

NT-BJ Raji-24

DE-Sedrick Ellis-25

OLB-Clay Matthews-25

MLB-Jarod Mayo-25

MLB-Lawrence Timmons-25

OLB-Brian Orakpo-24

CB-Devin McCourty-23

CB-Joe Haden-22

S-Eric Berry-22

S-Earl Thomas-22

Good Luck and please make sure the site that you get the players age is updated.

Please wait until my opponets second argument to vote

U. Wrex said 07/03, 10:47 PM
RBs:

Charles=2x 1000yarder. Foster=one year wonder.

Foster has more yards because he has nearly 1.5 times as many carries but Charles is the more productive runner.

Charles had only 149 less yards on 107 less carries. Charles had 45 runs of 10+ yards compare to Fosters 42. 19.6% of his runs were for more than 10 yards. Foster broke a 10+ yard run every 12.9% of his runs. That's a huge difference.

70 out of his 230 runs were for first downs. Thats 30.4%. Foster had a first down on 27.2% of his runs. That's a big difference.

Foster got more TDs because Jones came into the game in the redzone for KC. In the redzone Charles averaged 4.1 ypc and had 4 TDs on 20 attempts(20%). Foster had 13TDs on 66 attmepts(19.7%) averaging 2.1ypc.

Charles only had 4 games over 100 yards but he only averaged less than 4.0ypc in one game. Foster averaged under that in 7 games.

Charles only had 3 games with 20+ carries. He had over 100 yards those games. Foster had 7 games with 20+ carries reaching 100 yards in 5 of them.

Charles has allowed 11 pressures the last 3 years. Foster allowed 10 this year.

So Charles is a more productive RB and better blocker.

Nicks v Johnson next.

U. Wrex said 07/04, 10:02 AM
Charles has played one more year than Foster.

Also the QB actual helps Foster. Sqhaub is a better Qb with better WRs that takes more pressure of the run game

Now Nicks vs Johnson

Nicks played in 3 less games.

In those games he had 3 less receptions, 21 less yards, and 1 more TD. Had he played the full season he would easily have had more catches and yards.

Nicks is also the better deep receiver. On passes thrown 21 or more yards he caught 8 pass for222 yards and 4 TDs. Johnson had 2 catches for 70 yards and 2 TDs.

Nicks also had 20 plays of 20+ yards. Johnson only had 11.

Johnson caught 82 out of 142 passes thrown his way. That's 57.3%.
Nicks caught 79 out of 128 passes thrown his way. That's 61.7%.

Johnson also had 13 drops last year so you can't blame the Qb for his lower catch percent.

I can't find Nicks since he wasn;t in the top 15 or bottom 15 in drops. He is somewhere inbetween but has better hands than Johnson.

Again Nicks is a better deep receiver and has better hands. He scores more, averages more yards per game, and is an overall better receiver.

Good TD.