Views
536
Comments
26
  • 12/05/2011, 02:47PM ET

16 Team College Football Playoff

kaos444 (2-6-0) vs DGrizzle2013 - Go Cavs! (1-16-4)
3
Votes
1
Votes
3
Votes
1
Votes


The NCAA should have a 16 team playoff instead of an 8 team playoff for more at large berth teams.

This is how the first round would look:

1 LSU (SEC winner) vs. 16 Northern Illinois (MAC winner)

2 Alabama (At Large) vs. 15 Southern Mississippi (C-USA winner)

3 Oklahoma St. (Big 12 winner) vs. 14 TCU (MWC winner)

4 Oregon (Pac 12 winner) vs. 13 Michigan (At Large)

5 Stanford (At Large) vs. 12 Michigan State (At Large)

6 Arkansas (At Large) vs. 11 Clemson (ACC winner)

7 Boise State (At Large) vs. 10 Virginia Tech (At Large)

8 Wisconsin (Big 10 winner) vs. 9 Kansas State (At Large)

The playoff system should be like this so the lesser conferences get a chance to upset a big dog like LSU or Alabama and wouldn't just have LSU and Bama play against each other for the title. This would be the best way to handle the whole BCS debate.


The C-USA and MAC champions? You've gotta be kidding me....

The BCS is geared for ratings and money, now why would the NCAA put a MAC or C-USA school against and SEC school? Northern Illinois and Southern Mississippi have small fan bases and adding them to a game like this would be just like a regular cupcake game for LSU and 'Bama.

But I kind of understand where you're coming from, but you have to realize that these are college kids. Where would the games be? How would it affect they're schooling? What if a team like Michigan can't make it to the game due to weather and they're airport is down?

I think your idea just causes trouble for students and fans.

I hate the BCS just as much as the next guy but it's what we have and we're going to have to get used to. Ideas of a playoff my seem cool but there are a lot of things that factor into it.


Lets go look at the NCAA baketball tourney where you have a number one seed in Duke playing a team like UNC ashville in the first round, the first round is supposed to be a cakewalk for the team but there is a chance for that close game that would get everyone watching. I agree those games would be blowouts but you don't want them going up against a team like Clemson or Va Tech in the first round.

The games would be like the NCAA tourney where they have a set location for Sweet 16 and Elite 8 and then another location for Final 4 and Championship game. I don't think the traveling would be an effect but the games could be on a Friday and Saturday every week and then have the teams stay in the city and then get ready for another game the next week.

This idea would be great for fans considering you would get great games instead of only a couple good bowl games and then the bowl games where you have nobody watching them because of the teams. In this system you have them competing to keep their season alive and getting to the championship.


This would add 3 extra weeks to the season for those teams, football is already a rigorous sport and towards the end of the season injuries catch up with the players.

Also.. do the other teams go to a bowl game? Or is it just the top teams and conferences winners who play the tournament? If that is so, do the losers just go home? I'm sure a lot of coaches and sponsors would not agree with this...


To the NCAA this is three more weeks of revenue coming in from the games. Now in the NFL they play 16 weeks and still play in the playoffs for a few more weeks so a few extra weeks for the NCAA couldn't hurt them if they would want to play in the NFL.

For the other teams that get snubbed out or just aren't good enough they can do what they do again for college basketball. In college basketball, all the teams that don't get invited to the tourney go and play in the NIT and other tourneys that they get invited to. Why can't college football have another 16 team tourney for the other teams that don't make this playoff system.

Now I'm pretty sure the coaches and sponsors would like this playoff because they get to prove their team can play against anyone with them playing against multiple teams. The sponsors would love this because of all the money they would be receiving from the TV deals and sponsors from the game.

Comment #1 has been removed
Comment #2 has been removed
December 5, 2011  03:24 PM ET

And this gives you 15 games and can somewhat eliminate having a bunch of 6-6 teams playing in the something like the Joe's Body Shop Bowl.

December 5, 2011  03:57 PM ET

i will pick winners on second argument

December 5, 2011  04:15 PM ET

You forgot the Sun Belt.

December 5, 2011  04:15 PM ET

Oh, and the WAC too.

December 5, 2011  04:15 PM ET

Not to mention the Big East.

December 5, 2011  04:25 PM ET

Not sure is he wanted me to simulate the games or what. So I just made my own argument

December 5, 2011  04:36 PM ET

I think N. Illinois could upset LSU...if they were given an eleven touchdown lead.

December 5, 2011  04:39 PM ET

Go NIU!!!! Huskies baby!

December 5, 2011  04:39 PM ET
QUOTE(#9):

I think N. Illinois could upset LSU...if they were given an eleven touchdown lead.

hey assface NIU could beat any team on this board! WHAT WHAT!!??!!

December 5, 2011  04:47 PM ET
QUOTE(#7):

Not to mention the Big East.

The Big East plays football???? <I don't think so, they're just a b-ball league now.> Or will be real soon!

December 5, 2011  04:52 PM ET
QUOTE(#9):

I think N. Illinois could upset LSU...if they were given an eleven touchdown lead.

Not if LSU visits a tatoo parlor first. :^D

December 5, 2011  04:52 PM ET

little confused as to how Clemson is behind V Tech in this as far as rankings. Clemson has beat V tech twice and won the ACC.

December 5, 2011  05:11 PM ET

What if a team like Michigan can't make it to the game due to weather and they're airport is down?



How is that any different from the current Bowl system?

December 5, 2011  06:27 PM ET

I don't like the idea of playoffs in NCAAF, and a 16 team playoff is completely unrealistic, 8 would be the most, and 4 is far more likely, and any playoff setup that involves every conference winner including the Sun Belt and MAC should be automatically shot down.

December 5, 2011  08:38 PM ET

Why would it be harder for the FBS to organize a playoff than its been for the FCS all these years?

December 5, 2011  09:09 PM ET
QUOTE(#17):

Why would it be harder for the FBS to organize a playoff than its been for the FCS all these years?

That's the funny thing.

- Division II and Division III have had a playoff system since 1973.
- And FCS has had a playoff system since 1982.

Yet somehow playoffs are a radical concept that would never work at the highest level of college football.

December 5, 2011  09:26 PM ET

Yes you do want a LSU VA Tech match up in the first round, otherwise what's the point of the playoffs if the best teams STILL aren't playing?

 
Comment #20 has been removed

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


Leaderboard

  Fan W L T Win %
1 (Un) 101 18 8 82.7%
2 Darth Maim 80 20 6 78.3%
3 DO_WORK... 76 30 13 69.3%
4 :CubanM... 63 27 7 68.6%
5 Olderth... 86 35 17 68.5%
6 JimJ77 Can't make it up 130 53 26 68.4%
7 Marlins Fan 150 66 33 66.9%
8 HOOTZ 31 14 11 65.2%
9 Argos. 177 103 27 62.1%
10 Schad - Notorious Deadbeat 71 43 9 61.4%

The Si.com Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    LeBron lacking key champion component
    Views
    2705
    Comments
    1373
  2. 2
    Youkilis headed in reverse
    Views
    7939
    Comments
    214
  3. 3
    Garden ice under fire
    Views
    2647
    Comments
    105
  4. 4
    Tide's room gets a waterfall
    Views
    8111
    Comments
    101
  5. 5
    Was Crosby robbed of Hart?
    Views
    5400
    Comments
    94

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
    Em Em Aye
  2. 2
    Mickey Bad Arse
  3. 3
    BigSlick74
  4. 4
    Otis B. Driftwood
  5. 5
    heat champ/raptors redeemed

Message Boards

  1. NBA > General NBA

    NBA: Lots of rumors about the…
    Views
    113
    Replies
    0

Blogs