Views
970
Comments
84
  • 01/12/2012, 11:49AM ET

If the colts HAVE to decide, who should they choose, Luck or Manning?

HighwayCrossingFrog (175-847-63) vs DetroitFan2255 (3-5-0)
8
Votes
4
Votes
8
Votes
4
Votes


To me, this is a no brainer..
The colts must go with Luck..
Peyton turns 36 in 2 months, plus his neck injury sounds pretty serious..
I know Peyton is one of the greatest players to have ever played the game..
But sometimes you have to know when to dump somebody, if its going to help improve you in the Long term..
Luck, potentially gives the Colts a chance not to have to worry about the QB position for the next 15 years.. You have to pull the trigger NOW..

At the most P[eyton gives you 4 more good years..
Being realistic probably 3..
And if his neck is as serious as it sounds, maybe none..

Its hard to cut a legend, but that is what must be done for the good of the organisation..


The Colts will know if his neck is good to go or not, well atleast more than we will. But here is why I say keep Manning for atleast another year.

Yes Luck has everyone saying he is NFL ready and can step in and start. But some debated whether Luck should be #1 or Barkley. Barkley has to come out next year. The Colts could give Peyton another year and trade up for Barkley. Like what was said before you know what Manning brings to the table, you don't know about Luck. Here are some numbers to look at.

Player TD/Int Yards Conf

Luck Stan 37/10 3517 Pac-12

Barkley USC 39/7 3528 Pac-12
Jones OU 29/15 4463 Big-12
Wilson Ark 24/6 3638 SEC
Thomas Org 33/7 2761 Pac-12

These are next years seniors. I do not see where Luck rises above everyone else. Barkley had better numbers in the same conference. I'm not saying he isnt't going to be good but next year is a deep draft. Why not let Manning give one more year and if it doesn't work out you know there are QB's available. Then you give him the HC job.

MTC


Interesting argument..
I can see why its hard to let go of a legend..
The only problem with your argument, is that getting Luck is an automatic deal this year..
Next year with Peyton Manning at the helm, they will probably have a winning record, which would make things difficult to get a good QB..
I guess Matt Flynn would be an option too..

But the main problem with your opinion, is that if they dont get Luck..
And Manning hurts his neck again.. Then you have to go through another 2 win season..
Then Colts fans will sCream bloody murder.. And the GM will get fired, cause he had an excellent chance to get a highly thought of, potentially great QB in Luck..

When you look back on your life, you dont want to have any regrets, where you were in a situation, whereyou did not pull the trigger..

By not going after Luck, I know the Colts will live to regret their decision..
Last year was just too painful, and they really dont want to go through another nightmare season..


Yes the fans want/need a winning season, I know all about this. But look at all the problems the Colts had this year. They lost so many games for a few reasons, Peyton being #1, they ranked 16th in sacks allowed and 22nd in QB hits allowed. You can't let your QB get hit that much. I say trade the pick and shore up the OL to go with your picks from last year. If you can't protect Luck he will be usless.

Out of Luck's 10 Ints 9 of them came when the game was withing 7 pts and teams were blitzing. He panics under pressure and makes bad desicions with the ball.

Granted there is no promise of getting Barkley but his numbers are far better in the same situation. Out of his 7 Int only 1 of them came when the game was within 7 pts. Barkley handles pressure situations better.

And lets face it if the Colts dont improve that OL there will be pressure. And teams wont need to blitz to do it. Get players to go along with Costanzo and Ijalana. Protect your investment. If Peyton can stay healthy you will have a winning season and if not you have a good QB ready to be drafted. If Luck is as good as stated then they can get multiple picks and improve the whole team, not just one position.


Ok, stacking up the O LINE is always important..
And I respect your philosophy..

Me? I would rather pull the trigger on luck now..
It's slot harder to find a real deal quality QB than it is to find a great blocker that you can plug into the O LINE..

To me.. First you get the most important piece of the puzzle,
And then you build around it..

Look at Miami fins..
They have still been searching got that great qb,
Ever since Marino left..
That was over 10 years ago!

A lot of number one drafts turn out to be successes..
It's worth the roll of the dice in my opinion..

Luck is a pure pocket passer..
Petrine father said luck would be able to start in the NFL right away..
That's a pretty big compliment..

All dynasty's/empires have their moment in the sun..
And then they move on..
It's very sad, but it's time to move on with Peyton..

Good Luck, luck, ha ha!
Suck for luck is almost as good as gay for pay:)


I've never been a fan of putting a rookie QB into a starting role. Everyone thinks that Luck will step in and be a 10-12 game winner his first year. I dont see that happening.

Rookie QBs typically do not come in and do well. Roethlisberger holds the record for most wins by a rookie QB with 13 but look at the team he had around him. Flacco won 10 games his rookie year, again look at the team around him. Peyton came in and won 3 games....I repeat 3 games as a rookie. Peyton didn't have a great defense you need to win games as a rookie, niether would Luck. You say the Colts need a winning season and I agree, but they won't get it with a rookie QB at the helm.

Now if they do draft Luck they need to figure out a way for him to sit behind Peyton for a few year. Much like Rodgers did behind Farve. This is why i say trade the pick to a team that already in a rebuilding stage that is in need of a qb such as Miami (just an example). See if you can get Long and their 1st and maybe 2nd round pick. You get a better OL and you still get to draft a decent QB to sit behind Peyton such as Keenum, Moore, Weeden, Tannehill, Cousins. Not as good but would be willing to sit a year or 2.

GL HCF

Comment #1 has been removed
January 12, 2012  11:53 AM ET

Neither, I say they shock the league and draft RG3, true double-threat!

Comment #3 has been removed
January 12, 2012  11:56 AM ET

i cannot believe Fannation took away my dang TD. It was perfect, maybe the title gave it away: "I think Casey Anthony is more cold blooded than Joran van der Sloot!" That was going to be a Great Debate!

Comment #5 has been removed
January 12, 2012  12:00 PM ET
QUOTE(#5):

This TD is based on if Manning threatens to leave if the colts draft a superstart QB..And he tells management "its either him or me, not both"..

I have to say, you must look into the future. Colts will always hold a near and dear spot in their heart for Manning, but "All men fall, its but time and method"-Asher (Spartacus blood & Sand). Peyton has had a successful career run, he cannot be mad at them for wanting to keep their franchise alive with fresh blood. vote <---------

January 12, 2012  12:03 PM ET

Future: Luck, Past: Manning.

Comment #8 has been removed
January 12, 2012  12:35 PM ET

I will get an argument up tonight, I am at work and they frown upon this kind of thing here lol.

Comment #10 has been removed
January 12, 2012  12:44 PM ET
QUOTE(#8):

Ideally keep both for a couple years..But maybe thats too expensive to do..

If Manning were willing to restructure his contract, it could work. Rookie salaries aren't like they used to be. And Lord knows Manning has a ton of money in the bank from endorsements alone.

January 12, 2012  12:59 PM ET

Did Manning suck? Ever? he didn't look like he had lost anything the last time i saw him play...dump him? Why?

January 12, 2012  01:00 PM ET
QUOTE(#9):

I will get an argument up tonight, I am at work and they frown upon this kind of thing here lol.

Because aparently riding the dog around the house like a horse is frowned upon in this establishment.

Comment #14 has been removed
January 12, 2012  02:33 PM ET
QUOTE(#12):

Did Manning suck? Ever? he didn't look like he had lost anything the last time i saw him play...dump him? Why?

Cause with that bad neck Payton may never play a down in the NFL again. No he never sucked BUT if he can't play anymore and there is a good chance he's done for good then you gotta move on.

January 12, 2012  03:42 PM ET
QUOTE(#4):

i cannot believe Fannation took away my dang TD. It was perfect, maybe the title gave it away: "I think Casey Anthony is more cold blooded than Joran van der Sloot!" That was going to be a Great Debate!

Uuuhhh....told ya

January 12, 2012  03:44 PM ET

Draft Luck and trade Not Eli to Arizona.

January 12, 2012  03:46 PM ET
QUOTE(#11):

If Manning were willing to restructure his contract, it could work. Rookie salaries aren't like they used to be. And Lord knows Manning has a ton of money in the bank from endorsements alone.

Luck's first few years would not require a potfull of money, he and Peyton both could still benefit from being on the same team. I think Peyton is going to have to restructure whether they get Luck or not OR>..even if Peyton goes somewhere else, I don't think he is going to draw the salary his current contract is written for.

January 12, 2012  04:39 PM ET

If it's possible, keep Manning for a year to help ease Luck into the starter role. Not a lot of first overall QB's have a huge amount of success their first year.

 
January 12, 2012  04:40 PM ET

I've been saying it all along that the Colts need to pick Luck, and trade Manning for 3-4 (two #1's, and one-two #3's) picks to teams like the Redskins, Jets, or Cowboys. Draft well, and become a perennial playoff team again after Luck's first two seasons. No one should feel sorry for this situation, because Manning and the Colts gave us many years of great games. It all has to end sometime.

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


Leaderboard

  Fan W L T Win %
1 Darth Maim 76 21 7 76.4%
2 fvkasm2x 193 58 12 75.7%
3 7#bag _ Com 996 338 73 73.4%
4 HOOTZ 33 14 9 67.0%
5 Marlins Fan 156 78 31 64.7%
6 Argos. 183 101 29 63.1%
7 Goodell 2.0 643 429 71 59.4%
8 J-Business 78 66 18 53.7%
9 Highway... 175 847 63 19.0%

The Si.com Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    D'Antoni's newest 'blunder'
    Views
    1571
    Comments
    865
  2. 2
    Baseball's top 2015 free agent
    Views
    1558
    Comments
    526
  3. 3
    The NHL's model franchise?
    Views
    1638
    Comments
    134
  4. 4
    Cup drought weighing on Sid
    Views
    1394
    Comments
    106
  5. 5
    Smith won't play for San Fran in 2014
    Views
    3211
    Comments
    62

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
    Robataille
  2. 2
    ~Mother-Marge~
  3. 3
    TxHeat
  4. 4
    buddhaa.luck
  5. 5
    Deep Creek

Blogs