Throwdowns > Closed

Marlins Fan said 06/27, 12:09 AM
List first, using my same format, except you can swap a WR/TE/FB for the second RB/third WR if you prefer.


QB - Charlie Ward
RB - Warrick Dunn
RB - Greg Allen
WR - Fred Biletnikoff
WR - Peter Warrick
WR - Ron Sellers
LT - Alex Barron
LG - Jason Whitaker
C - Clay Shiver
RG - Jamie Dukes
RT - Walter Jones

LE - Peter Boulware
DT - Ron Simmons
DT - Corey Simon
RE - Andre Wadsworth
LOLB - Ernie Sims
MLB - Marvin Jones
ROLB - Derrick Brooks
CB - Deion Sanders
CB - Terrell Buckley
SS - LeRoy Butler
FS - Myron Rolle


Screw the kickers and punters. I have some really good ones but who wants to argue that crap...

Good luck, wanna get blank!!!

Marlins Fan said 06/28, 02:45 AM
Couple things; both of our teams are very stacked so the arguments here may seem like nit picking. Oh well, what can you do...

I like Ward over Kelly at QB. Ward was extremely mobile, and Kelly was a sitting duck in the pocket. Not only that but Kelly just wasn't a very good collegiate QB. Kelly played all four years in college, so his lack of stats isn't due to lack of opportunity.

Check out how poor Kelly's stats are:

He completed just 55% of his passes for his career.
He never threw more than 13 TDs in a single year, and the year he accomplished that he threw 14 INTs.
His collegiate career includes 32 TD passes and 28 INTs.
He never passed for more than 2,500 yards in a season.
In 4 years he managed a TOTAL of 5,228 passing yards.

Look at Ward's collegiate career:

In TWO season Ward surpassed Kelly's career's worth of passing yards, finishing with a total of 5,747.
Ward finished his two years with a TD/INT ratio of 49/22.
Ward completed 62.3 percent of his passes, including 69.3 in his Heisman-winning season.
Ward also ran for 889 yards in his career, along with 10 TDs.
Ward won the Heisman with over 3,300 total yards and 31 total TDs, and won the NC

Marlins Fan said 06/29, 01:59 AM
Here's the thing. Your team has a bunch of recent big NFL names, so headline voters are probably going to be in your favor. But I don't see how any of these guys' NFL careers have any bearing on this debate. This is about an All-Time football team from School A facing off against an All-Time team from School B. Not the NFL.

That said, my team is simply better. Like I already proved, my QB is way better. WAY better. The RBs are a push. The WRs are equal, as well. Don't believe me? Well there's a reason the award for WRs is named after Biletnikoff, and Sellers was one of NCAA football's best threats from back in the day. And you all remember Warrick.

My line is better than yours, significantly. Shiver is one of the best centers of all time; any generation. Jones and Barron were two of the most dominant tackles college football has ever seen.

My defensive line is as good as my offensive line. Wadsworth and Boulware were premium pass rushers; Simon and Simmons were unmovable rocks on the line. IMO the LBs and DBs are another push.

So we have defenses that are basically equal, but my offense is significantly better, primarily due to your scrub QB.

Good luck