- 07/09/2012, 10:04AM ET
Atro SYB said 07/09, 10:04 AM
Last week we found the email for Fan Nation's Editorial Manager. We sent him an email asking him if he was aware of the technical and procedural problems with the website, and this is what he said via his iPhone:
"Thanks for the note--I understand your frustration with the issues on FanNation, and hope you can be patient. We are working with our technical team to smooth the difficulties and improve the experience on the site. Besides the things you point out, any specifics you can provide around other issues you encounter would be helpful."
He sounds like a nice guy and he seems receptive. So let's use this Throwdown to list the issues with FN and send them on to him. And let's not waste space with stuff like "FN SUcks" and other nonsense. Maybe we can really accomplish something here.
YODA said 07/09, 11:05 PM
The combination of apathy and incompetence of this site's "staff" has been disgraceful.
You'd think even one damn SI employee would log in and USE FanNation occasionally (perhaps from home on a user account) so they'd have at least some idea how exasperating it is.
Today was a prime example of the site "unusability". I could barely log on. Pages took an ungodly amount of time to load. And trying to go through the thread comments was futile.
Virtually every other website runs smoother. Long-time FN users grow frustrated and leave. Newbies think they've time-warped back to 1998.
Generally there's ZERO communication from SI.
If a bumbling staffer or mod (or former mod who still has admin codes) does speak up, they act like they're hearing about an issue for the very first time. Whether it's spam, technical issues, or idiotic dupe accounts, SI staffers do nothing except offer hollow platitudes about how they "understand" and "care about the user experience".
It's reprehensible. And insulting.
For Christ's sake, Mr. "Editorial Manager", if you're actually reading this, show some basic respect for the users and for your brand. Do something.
Atro SYB said 07/10, 09:57 AM
So far we've had a lot of good suggestions, ideas and valid complaints. And then there's Redfoot, who's so busy massaging strawberry compote into his **** he hasn't found time to say anything on point.
But anyway, keep it coming, folks. We'll compile the good stuff at the end of the week.
YODA said 07/11, 02:21 AM
1. SITE FUNCTIONALITY
* trying to log in
* the lag
* spinny thing
* double/triple posts
* Extra sluggishness via multiple streaming video/banner ads
2. SPAM: Very weak attempts at addressing this.
3. TD SECTION: The broken timer creates multiple problems (a TD area clogged up with outdated trash, for instance). TDers and commenters have been driven away.
4. MOD/STAFF COMMUNCATION: Rare, bumbling, unprofessional, erratic, and dishonest.
Why isn't there even something as simple as a weekly blog from the staff with general site updates?
5. DUPES/TROLLS: Very easy to track. Deal with these losers rather than banning regular contributors who occasionally curse.
6. T&R SECTION: Who's in charge of these interns?
The stories chosen are weak, outdated, or even rehashed clones of a prior week's T&R update. The editing and transcribing is also scattered and sloppy.
7. DJ'S DAILY BANS/TIME-OUTS.
I have to be fair and give credit where credit is due. FanNation is doing an excellent job with this one.
It's not just the funds given to incompetent staffers; it's the money they're pissing away on lost opportunities. It's too bad.
Atro SYB said 07/11, 11:35 AM
Good stuff, Yoda. But I'm not so sure the daily "timeout" bans are such a great idea . . aren't they supposed to "teach him a lesson" or warn him against further such perceived abuses in the future? Dude's been banned 75 times or so, if there's a message being sent, I don't think he's getting it. Perhaps more severe repercussions are in order.
That being said, nothing personal, DJ. Just thinking analytically about the whole concept of temporary bannings in general.
I read this thread and there's great information here. This should be quite the list for the Editorial Director. I'm sure he'll sit right down on Saturday morning and read it while eating his Corn Flakes.
- Awful Announcing
- Free Darko
- Pro Football Talk
- The Big Lead
- Joe Posnanski
- The Sporting Blog
- Big League Stew
- Bugs and Cranks
- Every day Should Be Saturday
- Mr. Irrelevant
- With Leather
- The Sports Hernia