• 11/04/2013, 05:13PM ET

Best in each Division and Best in each conference 1 month in

kalbrecht17 (16-11-5) vs Sir Loin (4-4-1)

Atlantic- lightning have "looked" the best but i'll go with Det
Metro- Pitt
Central- Colorado (tempting to go with the Hawks, but Col's performance thus far has been incredible)

Atlantic: Tampa. Detroit has a -1 goal differential. Not good. Tampa is +12, and has the same amount of points as the Wings with 2 less games played.

Metro: Pens - no contest. This division is weak.

Central: St. Louis. Only one loss at home and one on road. They have 3 games in hand over the Hawks, but are only 4 points behind. Colorado has started incredibly hot, but it won't last.

Pacific: Anaheim. They have the most points in the NHL right now. SJ is cooling off, like they always do. Anaheim has balanced scoring, good D, and a surplus of good goaltending.

TB vs. Det it is then.

To be honest, I just can't see TB keeping up this torrid pace. On offense, sure Stamkos and St. Louis are fantastic players. no doubt about it. But currently (although less so recently) guys like Val Filppula (currently .79 ppg vs .52 career and .63 the last 3 years) and Alex Killorn (.86 ppg) are contributing at high levels, but I can't see them sustaining it. Currently TB sits at 6th in GPG, but I don't see it continuing with their lack of firepower up top to keep pace against the higher scoring teams unless there's a malone resurgence.

On the back end, I can't see Bishop holding serve for a full season. Its his first year and he's been light out thus far, but how will he handle the every day grind as the year goes on? and given inexperienced lindback behind him, I don't like those odds.

I picked Det because their European style fits the east. They are extremely fluid with the puck and have solid skaters 3 lines deep. My X factor is Det's highly skilled young guys like Andersson, Tatar, and Abdelkader providing the secondary scoring TB lacks in addition to howard's superior talent in net.

Just see Det as a little deeper w/ better tending.

Are you abandoning your suggested format?

And, are you arguing who is the best team in each division after one month, or who you expect to be more successful over the course of the season and possibly playoffs?

If I had to pick between the Wings and TB - who will finish higher at the end of the season, or who will go farther in the playoffs - I would pick the Wings, but if we're arguing who is the better team right now, it's TB. Detroit's defensive play has been soft, Howard's play has been lower than his usual. And, like I said, they've allowed more goals than they've scored. The best team in a division can't have a negative goal differential. Period.

But anyways - back to your suggested format.

Best team in the East is Pittsburgh. Loaded with talent, they have arguably the best two players in the game, and Fleury is playing well.

Col vs StL

Col vs Stl is an interesting matchup. In my eyes, kind of a conflicting set of styles but both undoubtedly are happy to have gotten rid of Det (not in terms of rivalry, but just as a nemesis). They both have some outstanding players offensively (Duchenne, Landy, MacKinnon vs Steen Backes and Oshie). and judging by them being 4th and 2nd in GPG, its pretty much a wash. Really what this comes down to is differential. Stl is doing well at 7th in GAPG but Col is 1st. No one's doing it better and they're +23 differential shows that. Also their PK is lights out and when you're that potent 5 on 5, that's a huge asset to have.


SJ is 1st in GPG and 3rd in GAPG. ANA at 6th and 9th. The biggest difference in why I see SJ as the better now both now and in the future is on ST. SJ PP and PK are 11th and 10th vs 30th and 28th for ANA. That is just brutal from ANA. And we all know that many a game are decided on ST. ANA is still trying to get past the departure of Bobby Ryan on the PP and its showing. And we've seen that Hiller is prone to crumple at times a la the Det playoff series last year. Sharks have only lost once in regulation this year get the edge

So, you ignore goal differential when you pick Det over TB, but then you claim "it really comes down to" it when comparing Col vs Stl?

Colorado is allowing two more shots per game than they're taking. That's not a good trend, and their record will normalize soon enough. They don't have the type of clampdown defense that STL has, and STL has the better goaltender in Halak.

Anaheim's special teams are way off the average, but that will return to the norm over time. What they're better at, and what is a better indication of the type of team they are, and will be come playoffs (where penalties are called much less than in regular season) is 5 on 5. They fact that their power play and penalty killing has been so off, yet they have still accumulated the most points in the NHL shows how dominant their 5-on-5 has been. And, have you seen Anaheim's schedule? They've only played 5 games at home and 11 on the road, yet they've still accumulated the most points in the NHL.

November 4, 2013  05:14 PM ET

will post something if someone wants to take this one.
Structure will be:
list 1st
Argue the East 2nd
Argue the West 3rd.

Let's get some NHL action on the board

November 4, 2013  10:13 PM ET

Alabama Crimson Tide.

End TD.

November 4, 2013  10:51 PM ET

Alabama Crimson Tide.End TD.

nhl but sure why not.

November 5, 2013  12:57 AM ET


November 5, 2013  12:57 AM ET


November 5, 2013  12:57 AM ET


November 5, 2013  10:02 AM ET

I'll join. Definitely a lack of NHL action here.

Comment #8 has been removed
November 5, 2013  12:45 PM ET

i'll dc which ever one of you doesn't get to this first

November 5, 2013  12:47 PM ET

i can dc both of you guys if you want

November 5, 2013  03:28 PM ET

good choice of Tampa. to me it's a 3 headed race in the Atl w/ TB, Bos, and Det with no one other than pitt in the metro. so much for competitive balance

November 6, 2013  10:12 AM ET

Don't count out Toronto and Montreal. I would say the division top 3 will end up being Boston, Detroit, then Toronto. The ATL will definitely get 5 playoff slots, with the Metros only getting the minimum 3.

November 6, 2013  10:17 AM ET


What does Frostburg State University have to do with hockey? They don't even have a team! ;o)

November 6, 2013  11:04 AM ET

Don't count out Toronto and Montreal. I would say the division top 3 will end up being Boston, Detroit, then Toronto. The ATL will definitely get 5 playoff slots, with the Metros only getting the minimum 3.

you'll see in 2nd arg why i argued it the way i did

Comment #15 has been removed
November 6, 2013  12:50 PM ET

and just to clarify loin in case you didn't get it, but i meant argue the best in each division then dispute the differences we have in the east followed by the west

November 6, 2013  12:51 PM ET

and yeah best overall in the east is the pens. but i yet again can see that getting slapped around in playoffs. still don't have those physical guys to grind it out like you need

November 6, 2013  04:11 PM ET

yeah - didn't get it. Initially thought the format was best in each division in round 1, then best in each conference in 2 and 3.

November 6, 2013  04:59 PM ET

Wrong school.

I'm not aware of any other school with those ititials (in Div III).

November 7, 2013  02:19 AM ET

What does Frostburg State University have to do with hockey? They don't even have a team! ;o)



Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


  Fan W L T Win %
1 fvkasm2x 193 58 12 75.7%
2 7#bag _ Com 997 338 74 73.4%
3 HOOTZ 33 14 9 67.0%
4 Marlins Fan 156 78 31 64.7%
5 Argos. 184 101 29 63.2%
6 Goodell: Fannation Savior 644 430 71 59.3%
7 J-Business 78 66 19 53.7%
8 Highway... 175 851 64 19.0%

The Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Truth & Rumors


  1. 1
    Kerr 'absolutely expects' Knicks offer
  2. 2
    No return timetable for Lightning MVP
  3. 3
    Yankees, Mets, Red Sox among Hanrahan hopefuls
  4. 4
    Smush Parker allegedly punches high schooler
  5. 5
    Tuukka Rask takes blame for Bruins' Game 1 loss

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
    Deep Creek