Throwdowns > Completed
- Views
- 7
- Comments
- 23
- November 07, 2007 12:34 AM ET
- Share
Prove It - just commenting said 11/07, 12:34 AM
OK-here's my arguments
OSU is overrated
Oregon should be #2
The SEC is the best conference in the nation
NE is the best football team of all time
Oklahoma should play for the National Championship
LSU is overrated
The PAC10 is the best conference in the nation
The SEC is overrated
Peyton Manning is the best QB in the NFL
OSU hasn't played anybody
LSU should be #1
The winner ofthe Heismann this year should be
The most underrated team in the NFL is
The AFC is better than the NFC
And my best "Arguments"
1. NEITHER MISSISSIPPI NOR MINNESOTA WILL PLAY FOR THE NATIONAL TITLE THIS YEAR.
2. NO 7 LOSS TEAM WILL WIN A BOWL GAME THIS YEAR
Not really any point here. Just thought that if I listed all the top vote getters in Fan Nation that people will vote for without reading the discussion, I might just win 1.
Actually, I was winning 1 last night, but had to forefit or face loosing my pristine record.
if you have any more, post below and I will cut and paste them in my counter argument and make them my own without guilt (as if anyone reads the arguments anyway) but gotta make it short-I have already used most of my charac
Malc said 11/07, 12:44 AM
What the hell why not...
OSU is not overrated...going undefeated and just winning has all ready proved to be to hard for most teams...Bucks have done it. Setting a BCS rankings record takes many factors...Bucks doing it.
Cal isnt any good...Kentucky is ranked with a heisman candadate...number 3 is good for the ducks.
NE cheated and got caught...to bad...cause then I might agree...but they havent even completed the season so such a claim is unwarrented.
Ok is good..but will need help to get there.
LSU has beat some damn good teams...they are legit and have done it without a full strength team.
PAC 10 is good, SEC is good, Hell Big Ten is good...no one is way above the other.
Agreed on SEC.
Peyton is good...but didnt Brady just beat him?
Bucks in Washington, In Purdue, In Penn STate...all wins...and good wins.
LSU number one contradicts other statements of over rated.
I gave a shot at attempting to hit most of your points...but without one clear one...tough to hit em all.
Prove It - just commenting said 11/07, 02:56 AM
From Comments (12) Add Comment and Malc said
Bit to much to argue-Malc hasn't
Everyone has to agree-you got some issues
Too much reading! No kidding...
1.Miss State has one of the best baseball teams
I think its kind of messed up...
Can't Hawaii play? No team can play more
LSU number one
Bucks in
Peyton is good
Agreed on SEC
PAC 10 is good-they are legit
Ok is good but with twice as much experience
NE cheated and got caught
Cal isnt any good-they can go
OSU is not overrated
There, took your hard arguments
but without one clear one, my only other comment is
drop acid-What the hell-why not
Go Bucks! are in good shape to make another run
And a new best argument-
PI is the inverse ratio of the diameter to the circumference.
Prove It - just commenting said 11/07, 11:02 PM
Not any point-just goofing late 1 night. Didn't expect anyone to make a serious argument. Sorry to hook a fellow Buckeye fan
What the heck, if you want a point, I will make one up
1. 25%+ of the voters had their decision made before they finished my argument, doubt they got to my rediculous best "Arguments" probably decided when they read the title. Facts, arguments, debating skills, are useless here - just a nack for picking a good title, or knowing what titles to challenge will do
2. Entire 2nd argument was cut and pasted from your and others comments, yet looks similar to any other. Might be a handfull of original ideas concerning college football posted in a week in Fan Nation-if that
3. The concept that debate skills means anything here is rediculous-read the challenges-at almost any time you will find a challenger winning who agreed with the person making the TD
4. You can learn stuff here, but only indirectly. I was curious who the other top young teams were to watch in the coming years so I posted a rediculous argument and found out about Oklahoma-saved a lot of research. Otherwise TDs are useless except to goof
4 points-way over my limit here-Have fun!GL
Malc said 11/08, 09:10 AM
Well since your a buckeye fan..I'll just have to give you a pass.
Illnois this weekend should be a good one and then hopefully a nice beat down of the team up north to cruise our way back to the game that is best suited for Buckeyes.
I like the TDs...get some interesting facts and being a debater at heart..its fun to just argue ****...sometimes things you might not even be into. So for me...I like this site and the TD part of it.
Its close enough to the weekend...habba a good one.
Leaderboard
| Fan | W | L | T | Win % | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DetroitFan* BS: Start Stanton! | 132 | 9 | 7 | 91.6% |
| 2 | Porkins: Catches bullets | 138 | 13 | 1 | 91.1% |
| 3 | Baun-ded=PUCKHEAD | 52 | 5 | 1 | 90.5% |
| 4 | The Ram | 138 | 17 | 4 | 88.1% |
| 5 | Foosball | 68 | 9 | 2 | 87.3% |
| 6 | Philly-- www.sportsnoise.com | 74 | 11 | 4 | 85.4% |
| 7 | Hyped78 | 112 | 19 | 5 | 84.2% |
| 8 | Dookie: Here We Go Steelers | 117 | 19 | 8 | 84.0% |
| 9 | [The] Coach | 97 | 18 | 5 | 82.9% |
| 10 | BSchwartz07 | 129 | 27 | 6 | 81.5% |
Web's Best Blogs
-
Epic Carnival
Top 11 reasons to root for the Rays
-
Joe Posnanski
Sportswriting and Life, Part II
I spend quite a bit of my free time avoiding the show Around The Horn. Its like my hobby. I believe…
-
Tirico Suave
Extending An Invitation To Lil Wayne
Where Theres Always Plenty Of Schadenfreude To Go Around The Vault Top Ten Most Visited Suave…
Truth & Rumors
MOST POPULAR
-
1
Jerry tries to pep up sulking T.O.
- Views
- 6578
- Comments
- 1114
-
2
Brewers considering run at Sabathia
- Views
- 2915
- Comments
- 494
-
3
Lions will listen to offers for Williams
- Views
- 18221
- Comments
- 74
-
4
Media angers Cowboys coach
- Views
- 9183
- Comments
- 65
-
5
Kobe causes logjam at small forward
- Views
- 7878
- Comments
- 54
Message Boards
-
MMA > Fight Club
Kimbo Slice's loss ...…
- Views
- 5701
- Replies
- 23
-
MMA > Fight Club
What now for EliteXC?
- Views
- 1457
- Replies
- 10
-
MMA > Fight Club
Next face of EliteXC: Tito…
- Views
- 1018
- Replies
- 13
Fantasy Plus
- NBA fantasy preview: Potential sleepers for 2008-9 season
- Jeff Ritter: Seahawks' return to health and other news, views for Week 5
- Fantasy Musings: Time has come for Raiders' Al Davis to leave stage
- Gary Gramling: Jon Beason takes step back as Panthers' defense steps up
- Rookie report: First-year running backs charge into starting roles




Tracy Burns
Jessica Gomes
Comments (23) Add A Comment
Malc hasn't posted yet, but with twice as much experience as I (and able to actually win a TD) obviously a worthy opponent.
Prove It - just…
Total Comments (1028)
well thanks...and good luck to you....a bit to much to argue here but I'll do my best
Malc
San Diego , CA
Total Comments (193)
Everyone has to agree with at least 1 of my SEC and LSU statements.
...bt you shy away from my best "Arguments"....
Go Bucks!
Go Oregon!
Go LSU!
Go Oklahoma!
Go WVU!
(it never hurts to kiss up to the voters)
Prove It - just…
Total Comments (1028)
Prove It you got some issues
Spak- is straight e…
Gods Country, MS
Total Comments (931)
too much reading!
MH7KiNG
Los Angeles, CA
Total Comments (1224)
in regards to NO 7 loss team will make a bowl game and no kidding on your other one. Need 6 wins to get in and I dont think anyone plays 13 games...so your right...no 7 loss will win as they wont be playing
Malc
San Diego , CA
Total Comments (193)
1. NEITHER MISSISSIPPI NOR MINNESOTA WILL PLAY FOR THE NATIONAL TITLE THIS YEAR.
If by this year you mean this academic year then you may be wrong. Miss State has one of the best baseball teams in the country and they return all of their starting pitching and 7 starting position players from last years College World Series team and are in good shape to make another run.
Minnesota always has a good hockey team and another title for them would seem pretty likely
Spak- is straight e…
Gods Country, MS
Total Comments (931)
There, somebody took your " hard arguments "
Spak- is straight e…
Gods Country, MS
Total Comments (931)
New England got caught cheating in ONE game... whats the excuse for the other 8 they won. I dont really consider it cheating...i think its kind of messed up... makes you wonder how many other teams "cheat"...
My only other comment is about Peyton manning... I think there are a few quarterbacks who can be considered great in the league right now.... Brett Farve, and hey how about Tom Brady....
other than that...i dont know about anything else
Potato83
Salisbury , NH
Total Comments (10)
Can;t Hawaii play 13 games?
6-7 and they can go to a bowl
Done
Smurf Village, :)
Total Comments (89)
No team can play more than 12 regular season games including conference championships. So no, Hawaii can't play 13 games. Odd TD topic, BTW.
Favrefan also likes…
Pocatello, ID
Total Comments (3136)
drop the acid habit, Prove it.
Ruby salutes…
Los Angeles , CA
Total Comments (2885)
LOL................
djroxalot
Total Comments (15181)
oregon should be number 2
brady didnt beat peyton, peyton beat peyton
coltsfan18
Total Comments (55)
Hey Prove it, lay off the bong water......
Freebird is AWESOM-O
Biloxi , MS
Total Comments (876)
Funny stuff, but you included absolutely nothing about the Steelers so no vote for you.
T-fo is Medium…
Go (Insert Your Team Here)!, MD
Total Comments (4293)
Actually, the Pats beat the Colts. Don't think the win or loss goes solely to 1/22nd of either team.
Favrefan also likes…
Pocatello, ID
Total Comments (3136)
This is entitled FanNation not FANNATIC. Get a hobby dude, like this thing called...LIFE.
makmall
Total Comments (162)
the title alone will guarantee a lost! lol
Guru welcomes back…
Orange County, CA
Total Comments (3541)
Last plea for votes to be changed over (found out while goofing you can change them, so here goes):
Guru - Culdn't believe it took someone 5 minutes to accept challenge. Most voters don't get far past title.
Go Saints! Go Dodgers! Go Lakers! Go Tigers! Go Trojans! Go Ducks!
T-fo - go Steelers! Beat the Browns so we can move up in the draft (w could really use a defense)
freebird - hint from college (don't think i could deal with "Mind Expansion" now, would just sit on sofa like a log) replace water with Scope. Try it!
djroxalot - see, you got it! Sorry, you have too many favorite teams for me to chear on, but I covered a few above.
farvefan12 - thanks for noting the topis was something different
spak says - impressive knowlege of hockey - thought hockey was purely a northern border states - might as well be canadian - thing.
Prove It - just…
Total Comments (1028)
Comment
Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.