FanNation - The Republic of Sport

PHIMan hates school said 11/17, 10:53 AM
Randy Moss
Reggie Wayne
Braylon Edwards
T.J Houshmanzadeh
Chad Johnson

As you all know, Randy Moss is having an insane season so far. He has 56 catches for 924 yards and 12 touchdowns. He leads the AFC in yards and Touchdowns for WR. He averages 102.4 yards per game. He averages 16.7 yards per catch. He has accounted for 42 1st downs.

Wayne has 59 catches for 870 yards. He is 2nd in yards in the AFC. He also has 6 touchdowns. He averages 96.7 yards per game. He averages 14.7 yards per catch. He has accounted for 40 1st downs.

Edwards has 43 catches. That might not seem like a lot, but he has 752 yards which is 4th in the AFC and 10 touchdowns. He averages 83.6 yards per game and 17.5 yards per catch. He has accounted for 33 1st downs.

Housh has 68 catches for 719 yards. He leads the AFC in receptions. He also has 10 touchdowns. He averages 79.9 yards per game and 10.6 yards per catch. He has accounted for 40 1st downs.

Johnson has 51 catches for 852 yards and 3 touchdowns. He is 3rd in receiving yards in the AFC. He averages 94.7 yards per game and 16.7 yards per catch. He has accounted for 46 1st downs.

PHIMan hates school said 11/17, 11:38 AM
Alright you picked Hines Ward, so I will argue against him. Here is a comparison between Johnson and Ward.

Yards
Johnson- 852
Ward- 382

Catches
Johnson- 51
Ward- 35

TD
Johnson- 3
Ward- 4

AVG YPC

Johnson- 16.7
Ward- 10.9

Yards Per Game
Johnson- 94.7
Ward- 54.6

1st Downs
Johnson- 46
Ward- 23

So as you see Johnson beats Ward in every category except for 1 and that is TD and Ward only has 1 more TD than Johnson.

Johnson has way more yards and more catches. Johnson has gained more 1st downs and has a better YPC and yards per game. Ward has 0 100-yard games and Johnson has 3 100-yard games. The most yards Ward has received in a game is 88 yards and Johnson has received for 209 yards in one game.

You were talking about Ward having other good WR teammates. Well Johnson also has Houshmanzadah on his team. Housh has been a Top 5 WR this year. So they both have other good WR on their team.

Ward is a great blocker, but his receiving numbers just have not been there this year, well they have not been like Johnson's numbers. So when looking at the comparison I would have to say that Johnson has had the better season so far.

PHIMan hates school said 11/18, 08:22 AM
First of all, you said that I was calling Ward a cry baby. Where in my arguments did I call Ward a cry baby because I did not call him one.

Now you are calling Chad Johnson a cry baby because I do not think he is. If you can get me a video on where he is crying, then I would believe, but since I do not have proof I do not believe it.

The Super Bowl that the Steelers won does not matter in this throwdown. If you see the title it says ???Top 5 WR in the AFC so far this season???. It says nothing about 2 years ago or last year.

Now why are you talking about Andre Johnson, Chris Chambers, and Lee Evans when they are not involved in this throwdown what so ever. They do not belong in this throwdown unless someone picked them as a top 5 WR, but we both did not and you cannot change your pick.

The Bengals defense being bad is not Johnson???s fault. It is not his fault that they stink and the Bengals keep losing because of their defense.

If you look at the comparison between Johnson and Warsd in my 2nd argument. Then you can determine who you think is the better WR so far this season. In my opinion I think it has to be Johnson.