FanNation

Lifer: Metallica Sucks! said 11/27, 03:11 PM
Okey dokey, sorry about the wait.

1. Tom Brady
2. Brett Favre
3. Ben Roethlisberger
4. Tony Romo
5. Derek Anderson
6. Peyton Manning
7. Carson Palmer
8. David Garrard
9. Jon Kitna
10. Matt Hasselbeck
11. Jeff Garcia
12. Jay Cutler
13. Drew Brees
14. Jason Campbell
15. Donovan McNabb

Lifer: Metallica Sucks! said 11/27, 04:15 PM
Wrong. Roethlisberger has 23 TDs and 9 INT, Anderson has 22 TD and 11 INT. Not sure where you're getting your stats. Ben also has a better QB rating by over 15 points, better completion% by almost 10%, and more Y/A. Oh yeah, and Ben has led HIS team to a better record than Anderson has for his Browns, regardless of where the Browns "should" be. Comeback Player? Probs to Moss, but could be Anderson, not that it matters here. Pro Bowl? Same w/ Big Ben. Value to the team? Ben is already the leader of the Steelers.

You had Kitna way too high. He has the 14th best QB rating, 9th best completion%, 9th best Y/A, 11th most TDs and he is tied for 6th most INT thrown. He can't run, has the most sacks in the NFL (44), and is tied for most fumbles. He shouldn't be 6th place.

How could you not have Jeff Garcia on your list, either? 6th best QB rating, 13th in completion%, 11th in Y/A, and a great TD-INT ratio with 11 TD and 3 INT. He can also run, and doesn't get sacked or fumble often. Certainly he has top 15 numbers.

Lifer: Metallica Sucks! said 11/27, 04:38 PM
First off, when you have 9 sacks more than the next closest guy...and when you're on pace to be only 6 sacks away from the record...it can't just be the OL. Also, you have to take into account how Kitna has probably a top 3 WR corps in the NFL, certainly top 5.

53.8% of Kitna's TDs & INTs are touchdowns. Among the other guys you compared Kitna to as far as TDs and INT go in the above argument, none of them have a worse % than Kitna. Also, Garrard has a better Yards/Attempt than Kitna, and although Manning is worse there, he beats Kitna in QB rating, TDs, TD-INT ratio, fumbles, sacks, and he also has way more rushing TDs.