FanNation | The Republic of Sport

Community

Rusty Shackleford won the Throwdown.

Esco

Throwndowns: 8
Record: 4 - 4 - 0
,
All Throwdowns

Votes

Throwndowns: 50
Record: 26 - 21 - 3
Youngstown , OH
All Throwdowns

Votes

all time nfl team (the catch is every player has to be of a race other than african american)

Rusty Shackleford said 11/28, 09:25 PM
this is in no way a prejudice or racist throw down. i am not doing this out of malice or anthing like that it is just a lot more challenging because african americans dominate most of the skill positions. that aside i am thinking that we sould do roster 1st and arguments after that

qb-peyton manning
rb-franco harris
fb-larry csonka
te-tony gonzales

wr-steve largent
wr-fred biletnikoff
wr-don maynard

ot-anthony munoz
og-john hannah
c-chuck bednarick
og-steve hutchinson
ot-bruce matthews (he played all the positions on the line)

a 3-4 or 4-3 def. is fine

dl-howie long
dl-bob lily
dl-jack youngblood

olb-jacl lambert
ilb-brian urlacher
ilb-dick butkus
olb- bill romanowski

cb-jim thorpe
ss-john lynch
fs-troy polamalu
cb-roger wehrli

Esco said 11/28, 09:55 PM
First off, I want to say I do not at all find this racist or prejudice (and everyone knows I'd let them know if I thought it was)

QB- Joe Montana
RB- John Riggins
FB- Jim Taylor
TE- Dave Casper
WR- Steve Largent
WR- Lance Alworth
WR- Don Hutson
OT- Anthony Munoz
OG- Bruce Matthews
C- Jim Otto
OG- Joe DeLamielleure
OT- Forrest Gregg

DE- Howie Long
DT- Art Donovan
DT- Dan Hampton
DE- Jack Youngblood
OLB- Jack Ham
MLB- Ray Nitchske
OLB- Jack Lambert
CB- Jim Thorpe
SS- Paul Krause
FS- Larry Wilson
CB- Roger Wehrli

Rusty Shackleford said 11/29, 01:06 AM
ok i goofed on the safties, i tried to get as many current players on the roster as possable because i thought just going up and down the list of hall of famers was pretty weak, especially since most of the white guys were from the nonsuperbowl era. i would also like to add that i think the rediculous int numbers of krause and wilson are more akin to the crazy # of wins that early baseball pitchers had than thier over all brilliance. the game has changed a lot and i think that while they are great players, those numbers are a bit inflated. that aside, my pick of romo is legit as he had 14.5 more sacks than ham and he is only 2 ints from joing the 20 sack 20 int club that ham pioneered. i also like my o-line more than yours. bednarick is one of the greatest and toughest players of all time and he had the origional "hit" (on frank gifford that put him out for a year). also i like peyton more than montana. montana was a west coast qb and without a speed reciver it would be hard for him to put up big numbers as who would get the yards after the catch? tony g is with out a doubt a better TE than casper based on stats, and bob lily went to more pro bowls than donovan and hampton combined

Esco said 11/29, 02:46 PM
Peyton Manning over Joe Montana?!? Montana has more yards, more touchdowns, more bling, more Pro Bowls, fewer INTs.

And how can you discount Paul Krause?! He played until 1979, and went up against some of the best QBs of all time. Its not like he played in the leather helmet era, he played in the Super Bowl era. Wilson also played into the '70s, so I'm not sure what you are talking about there.

Also, Franco is half black, so you can't exactly count him. Riggins had more touchdowns and rushes, so I would win there anyways.

Rusty Shackleford said 12/06, 03:58 PM
Forfeited Turn

Esco said 12/06, 04:07 PM
Well then, this is over.

Report Offensive Throwdown

Comments (61)

Most Recent Comment Add Comment RSS

I'll get at this tomorrow.

Esco | 11/28/07, 09:29 PM

An SI.com and CNN Digital Network Site

Search

Already a member?

all time nfl team (the catch is every player has to be of a race other than african american)

Esco beat Rusty Shackleford 25 to 1

Add a comment