FanNation

Cain-Willis. In & Out... said 12/10, 05:33 PM
I agree with most of your picks. However, you left off a man who should be in the top 10 list.

Carson Palmer. Palmer passing percentage is 65.2. That is higher than Peyton Manning, Jeff Garcia, Hasselbeck and Derek Anderson.

Palmer is 8th in the NFL in throwing TD's with 21. He is ahead of Brees, Garcia, Garrard.

Palmer is 4th in the NFL in passing yards. Only Brady, Favre, and Romo have thrown for more yards.


Any man with a completion percentage BETTER than MANNINGand who has thrown for more YARDS than MANNING is in the top ten in the NFL.


Donovan McNabb has a higher QB rating than Derek Anderson or Drew Brees. He is not on your list.

Jon Kitna has a higher QB rating than Derek Anderson or Drew Brees and HE IS NOT ON YOUR LIST!

Your list IS NOT the BEST 10 QB's in the NFL.......

.......more to come.....

Cain-Willis. In & Out... said 12/10, 06:51 PM
Derek Anderson has been on a nice streak. But let's face it. He's reletively new to the NFL. Can you get a good picture of him in the partial season he has played and say he is better than Carson Palmer, Jon Kitna, AND Donovan McNabb?

.....

Cain-Willis. In & Out... said 12/10, 10:02 PM
there you go, Palmer it is. I put Palmer in the place of Anderson. Therefore, by your admission, I win.

PS: Palmer will always be better than Anderson.