Views
685
Comments
4
  • December 13, 2007 01:10 PM ET

The Mitchell Report should be sealed.

Conservative Voice (4-2-1) vs FoosBall (116-12-3)
1
Votes
6
Votes
1
Votes
6
Votes


I realize the monumental effort put forth by Senator Mitchell in the compilation of the soon to be released report. However, to publicly release the report can only do harm to the fans of baseball. Don't get me wrong, I don't believe we should live in the blind and ignore what's happened. All players that have broken the rules (and in some cases the law) should be punished accordingly. But, I believe it should be handled within the league and behind closed doors. It serves no purpose to the fans or the game to "air the laundry". It does, however, provide ESPN and the like with something else to talk about. We ALL know how the media can take a hang nail and make it life threatening. I will probably lose this one and that's fine. I am not morbidly curious about who did it....we know it was done and it's being handled. Period.


If the report names names ... then why should be sealed. What is the point of MLB paying $20 Million (that is the amount I read somewhere) for a report that doesn't show who did what. A few years ago here in Canada there was A fully Open Inquiry called the "Dubin Inquiry". It investigated Drugs in Sports and was prompted after Ben Johnson was stripped of his gold medal during the 1988 Summer Olympics...
It was fully open to the public and media and didn't hide anything. There were months of testimony (from coachs and athletes) about the use of performance enhancing drugs. The final report criticized the testing policies & procedures of both the Canadian Federal Gov't & amateur sports associations. Afterwards Canada strenghtened it's drug testing policy & procedures and created an independent antidoping org., which is now responsible for national drug testing for athletes. Canada is a leader in the fight against performance enhancing drugs.


Yeah for Canada. I understand your position. Personally, I don't need to know who has done it. I know players have. The bottom line is that releasing the report is bad for the game. It will hurt fan attendance, sales, merchandising, and endorsements. More than just baseball will suffer because of it. The point of paying the $20 Million is to find out how bad it is. Granted it could just turn a blind eye and keep going. It could have implemented testing across the board of ALL players without a report years ago. Point is...what good comes from releasing the report? The MLB will institute penalties whether the report splatters names everywhere or not. The Players union can prevent the drug use. As a fan all I can do is go...or not go to a ball game...buy or not buy their stuff. What is gained from releasing the report? Nothing. It only hurts the game.


It may hurt in the short term yes... But as they say Short Term Pain means long term gain. The 1994 MLB Strike hurt the game in the short term...but it recovered. If this report names names especially the ones that are suspected... Barry Bonds, Rogers Clemens etc... sure it will be a black mark for baseball. But baseball will recover... It recovered after the Black Sox scandal, and multiple strikes... It will recover after this as well.
Sometimes go need to air the dirty laundry and take the hit... to survive long term. If some good comes out of this like a tougher drug policy ...stiffer penalties, player bans whatever... It will be in the best interest of the game.


Well you can have this one. As I stated I expected to lose not because I feel I am wrong. Quite the contrary, I know I'm right. But the curiosity and thirst for a scandal rule the day. It's yours. I have no further arguments.

Comments (4) Add A Comment

December 13, 2007  01:15 PM ET
Report Abuse | QUOTE

It should be revealed. The reason i say this is that if random people start getting suspended and there is no explanation given the fans will eb very upset. The media has made sports a very intrusive thing. We want to know everything and are upset when we don't.

I can't wait for it to be released... i'm on the edge of my chair.

December 13, 2007  02:10 PM ET
Report Abuse | QUOTE

Speculation has already ruined baseball. The report will remove doubt.

December 13, 2007  05:53 PM ET
Report Abuse | QUOTE

that's awesome "handle it behind closed doors" so you're going to randomly suspend players and ask them to pay fines without an explanation?

dude, these players should be kicked out of the sport. They set a HORRIBLE example for ANY SPORT, not just baseball. Kick them out, don't let them play ever again. and as loveithateit said, releasing names will clear the air and remove the doubt. Now i'll know who's a cheat and who's ACTUALLY good at the sport. don't just release the article, plaster their names all over the place...

 
December 13, 2007  07:13 PM ET
Report Abuse | QUOTE

Holy mother of prudence! This needs daylight, not to be sealed away in some dark corner!

I can't believe anyone would even suggest such a thing... except for maybe Barry Bonds.

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


Leaderboard

  Fan W L T Win %
1 Hyped78 187 19 4 90.0%
2 FoosBall 116 12 3 89.7%
3 Argos: Has the Swine. 45 6 4 85.5%
4 Southern Discomfort 42 6 3 85.3%
5 [The] Coach 128 21 7 84.3%
6 BBK - Now it's all football 51 8 6 83.1%
7 MNY: Cut Corp 49 10 3 81.5%
8 BSchwar... 127 27 6 81.3%
9 BobbyOr... 42 10 3 79.1%
10 rstowe 315 79 20 78.5%

The Si.com Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Meeting with fans backfires on Browns owner
    Views
    18776
    Comments
    846
  2. 2
    Canseco wants to fight A-Rod
    Views
    30639
    Comments
    188
  3. 3
    Yankees ace recruiting LeBron to Knicks
    Views
    15362
    Comments
    74
  4. 4
    Can Red Sox re-sign Bay?
    Views
    5236
    Comments
    67
  5. 5
    Brady denies influencing officials
    Views
    4805
    Comments
    60

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
    Porkins: F U to Hell, BCS
  2. 2
    RobertMenn: You stole my rake
  3. 3
    Perfectpats
  4. 4
    sign here
  5. 5
    Oso: Yankees win again?

Message Boards

  1. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    CFB Game Day 11/7/2009
    Views
    254
    Replies
    105

  2. MMA > General MMA

    What happens if Fedor loses?
    Views
    197
    Replies
    63

  3. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    Rivalries/hated teams
    Views
    192
    Replies
    20

Blogs

SI.com

Swimsuit

Jessica HartJessica Hart
Jessica GomesJessica Gomes

SI Photos

Rare Photos of George SteinbrennerRare Photos of George Steinbrenner
Cheerleader of the WeekCheerleader of the Week